5 ms·
The author paints a rosy picture of PC gaming, but in my experience (I work for a AAA game studio) PC sales are by in far the least profitable (10%~) and the mo
by dijit 11y ago
The author paints a rosy picture of PC gaming, but in my experience (I work for a AAA game studio) PC sales are by in far the least profitable (10%~) and the most likely to cause piracy (crackers even use the PC version to figure out how to reverse engineer the console versions)
This would tell me that we simply don't know how to make games for the PC platform; but the author also ascribes the freemium model to PC gaming- which I personally see as a blight on gaming and firmly in the realm of the smartphone market..
or at least they do it more tenaciously.
- Mithaldu 11y agoOn the other hand games on PC have a much longer tail with much less effort and can often bring in money decades after release (see GOG). There's also a difference in store design that makes it really easy to find things on steam you didn't know before and are relevant to you, even if they're really old; while the stores on consoles are utterly useless if you are not buying the newest games or know which game you're looking for. As for the freemium comment, you didn't understand him correctly. There's different ways to do freemium. One way is to sell cheats, and design the game so it becomes progressively more unfun to play without cheats. (mobile games) The other is to make the game free to play and offer either cosmetics (tf2) or pieces of the gameplay (warthunder) for cash. The latter is really nice, and seems to happen exclusively on PC.
- Zikes 11y agoI'm utterly baffled at how terrible the Playstation 4 store experience is. I can't help but think it's somehow intentional, but for the life of me I can't figure out why.
- Mithaldu 11y agoIt's not intentional. Just like Nintendo, Sony is just very helplessly ignorant about many things. Even their webstore has childlishly naive failings. They recently added a wishlist, which has a maximum of 100 entries, and doesn't automatically remove games bought. As well, when they update the webstore, on tuesday, it becomes a literal minefield because they update every single item slowly, over the course of 3-4 hours, in production, and often the storefront will display different prices for items than you see in the cart.
- soylentcola 11y agoI'd also add the model that's essentially the same as shareware (also popularized on PCs and other home computers). It's not as common as I'd like but on both PC and mobile, I occasionally run across games or other applications that offer the first 10 levels (for example) out of 100 for free and then you can choose to buy the full game after getting a chance to try it out. Or maybe the first chapter of an interactive story game or the first third of a point-and-click adventure. The point is still the same and some non-game programs do similar things (free version gets the main function, paid version unlocks all of the more specific options of features). I really like this model because I'm not buying a game or application sight unseen but I also don't need to keep feeding it quarters in order to progress. I have no problem buying software on PC or mobile but it's a lot easier to buy something without reservations if I know it's what I want. Likewise, when I buy something, I generally want to buy it once and not get stuck in a cycle of endless microtransactions or open-ended subscriptions. I'm sure I'm not the target market but when I play a mobile or PC game, I find myself wanting to pay when it's something I enjoy or find useful. But if a game uses microtransactions (pay to win), I basically refuse to ever spend any money on it at all and just play until it gets old and then move on to the next distraction.
- Zikes 11y agoIt seems that industry-wide, PC revenue is on par with or surpassing consoles, though. [0] Completely anecdotally, in my experience as a consumer when games do better on consoles than on PC it's because they A) are poorly ported from consoles, often by a third-party developer, B) are poorly suited for PC, such as "party" type games better played with many friends in one room, or C) don't offer enough new or differentiated content to justify the purchase, since the PC platform has (nearly/theoretical) unlimited backwards compatibility. Sometimes the new Assassin's Creed just isn't a different enough experience from all the previous games to justify the purchase when you can just go back and play any of the others on the same platform. [0] http://hexus.net/gaming/news/industry/83972-pc-games-sales-eclipse-value-console-games-sales-2016/ http://hexus.net/gaming/news/industry/83972-pc-games-sales-e...
- rodgerd 11y ago> It seems that industry-wide, PC revenue is on par with or surpassing consoles, though. Revenue is not profitability, and there are much higher costs shipping a PC game.
- jsnell 11y agoSure, you have to do a lot more QA and support than on consoles. And there will be some PC specific development, both for the engine and for amenities that PC players expect like keyboard+mouse support, graphics options, etc. But the biggest costs in AAA gamedev aren't going to be platform specific. The assets (textures, models, animations, sound fx, music, level designs) should just port over. Likewise most marketing will be platform agnostic; you don't have to triple your marketing budget when going from one platform to three. And art + marketing is probably like 70%-80% of the budget. The marginal profitability of a PC port should thus be extremely high. (Which is why pretty much every AAA game will launch on the PC too, not just on the consoles. If the PC really was a marginal and expensive platform, they wouldn't bother).
- ensignavenger 11y agoInteresting point- care to share any data? I know a PC game requires supporting a variety of hardware, but it also does not entail paying a licensing fee to a console maker... so it would be interesting to see which one is less expensive for a reasonably popular game.
- jccalhoun 11y agoI think it could be argued that the high rates of piracy are forcing devs to look at these alternative models. That he doesn't suggest this hypothesis is kind of a hole in his argument.