3 ms·
I don't think you can conclude the attacks are proof that surveillance has failed unless you know with certainty surveillance has failed at stopping most attack
by mc32 11y ago
I don't think you can conclude the attacks are proof that surveillance has failed unless you know with certainty surveillance has failed at stopping most attacks. Surveillance organs could have stopped anywhere from zero attacks to all but the ones we've witnessed.
That's not to say surveillance is the answer, but its saying it may be an answer depending on effectiveness and our willingness to make this bargain.
- jacquesm 11y agoWith the amount of fanfare surrounding those attacks that were foiled where the government all but helped push the trigger you can bet that if there were more we'd hear about them, they are desperate for justifications for their activities and nothing would help them more than foiling a major plot like the one that just killed a large number of people. See for instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_unsuccessful_terrorist_plots_in_the_United_States_post-9/11 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_unsuccessful_terrorist... It does not look as if the Snowden revelations have made America any less safe.
- mc32 11y agoSo do you think the lack of fireworks since the London and Madrid attacks are more about the terrorists being lazy and not wanting to attack rather than their being foiled?
- jacquesm 11y agoIf they're half-way clever about it they'll hit in places that are perceived as 'soft'. Note that this is the second attack on Paris. The UK is a harder target because you have to cross a border that is not as easy to traverse as a road and the Spanish police has gotten a lot more 'up-close-and-personal' with wanna-be terrorists than they were before. Belgium it turns out is an easy place to hide for these characters and that's one reason I suspect Amsterdam would be more likely than Madrid simply because it is physically a lot closer. It is also why I doubt the effectiveness of the 'double screening' for airline passengers announced today, none of these guys traveled by plane. Even so, that doesn't rule out another attack in Spain - or even Madrid - nor does it rule out an attack in London, Amsterdam, Berlin, Copenhagen or anywhere else in the Schengen zone. Weapons and easily radicalized youths aplenty. It's a matter of time before the next attack, but that doesn't mean we should sit still. It means the plan of attack needs to change, possibly radically so, but not after sufficient reflection on why the current approach does not appear to work as well as it should.
- mc32 11y agoSo I'm still unsure if you think a lack a multiplicity of attacks is due to their not wanting to attack despite their statements or if or their inability or curtailment due to current methods of mitigation. I understand we can expect more attempts and sadly more attacks and we need to take more innovative measures, but I wonder if you think current methods have been a complete failure or have succeeded in thwarting other attempts we are mot privy to. For one plans dont go from 0 - 100 instantly, they develop over time. So any plans could be intervened any time in between and we may only get to hear about the late stage interventions, or, perhaps were ineffective and the terrorists kind of really lazy baddies who aren't opportunists.
- jacquesm 11y agoI suspect their resources - boots on the ground if you wish - ready to be activated are rather limited even though the supply of potentials is very large. This attack apparently featured 9 people, that's a relatively large number and it would not surprise me at all if that's a substantial portion of the resources that they could activate right now. But given time new idiots will step up to fill the vacancy. Give it a few months or a year. Just long enough to get everybody to forget to be more watchful. Sleeper cells are a very old concept. Go about your daily business and wait for a pre-arranged signal, go to a place, pick up instructions and weapons, do the deed. It could go from 'innocent dude working in a bakery' to 'hey, that's my brother that blew up 20 people' in less than 48 hours. And that's precisely how they should do it if they wanted to stay under the radar. This recipe could be repeated just about forever without much chance of interference, and even that wouldn't matter much as long as once every year or so a group would make it through. The window in which one should catch a would-be terrorist is between 0 and 19 years of age, not in the last 2 days before they execute a plan. That is playing very bad odds.
- mc32 11y agoGiven their stated intentions, why would there be so few "boots on the ground"? Are our current intelligence strategies and mitigating policies keeping them at bay? One possibility is they only catch people at T -1, or not caught at T 0, or there could be many more caught at T -X. In the U.S. the ATF isn't disbanding just because we haven't seen manor action by supremacists. And just because we haven't seen any announcements does not necessarily mean the ATF aren't doing their work or aren't successful.