3 ms·
It's not because of American value in conformity that school is the way you describe. It's logistics. If there were 1:1 teacher:student ratios, of course things
by threatofrain 11y ago
It's not because of American value in conformity that school is the way you describe. It's logistics. If there were 1:1 teacher:student ratios, of course things would be very different. After math, you go hiking with your teacher. As you're hiking you discuss life and world events. Very personalized and balanced growing plan for your child.
- smokeyj 11y agoIt'd be interesting to experiment with a model where the roles of student and teacher are interchangeable. Some form of peer learning mesh network.
- derefr 11y agoI would imagine you could learn a lot about peer education from the "one-room" schoolhouses in developing countries. By necessity, there aren't enough teachers to go around, and all the students of different levels are learning together. If students manage at all in such an environment, it's because they're learning from their peers. (Maybe not in an effective manner; there's no formal encouragement of the practice and nobody is given any collaboration tools—but there are probably still learning strategies that can be derived from what students do manage to accomplish.)
- derefr 11y agoI don't see why you need to change ratio. Just put kids in grade 1 when they're ready, rather than when they're 6, and work from there. The challenge (and most of the point) is to remove the negative bias both teachers and children have against being "behind" by one or more grades. Reversion to the mean happens. Ability to do e.g. most kinds of arithmetic eventually arrives in everybody by the time they're 13 or so, yet we say the kids who can multiply at 6 are "gifted" and the ones who can't until 13 are "disabled". Neither of these labels tend to still apply in any practical sense once the base skill is learned, and yet you're stuck being treated differently by the educational system, stuck in a different "track", because you took to some things "early" or "late". Removing that systemic effect would be the best thing we could do for education. The first degree of the Taylor-series of solutions probably looks like figuring out each child's "average" developmental age, and trying to start kids in school so that everyone in grade 1 has the same development level, rather than the same age. The second degree would probably involve separating school into "subjects" at a much earlier level, such that a child could be placed in grade 3 math but grade 1 reading, rather than ending up frustrated in a totally-grade-1 or totally-grade-3 classroom. (The analytical solution is likely something like a "flipped classroom" MOOC+Montessori model, where recorded lectures are taken in at home, while school is effectively a huge library full of tutors and labs and self-testing apparatuses, with a micro-skill "tech-tree" being filled in by each test, and procedurally-generated tests being able to be repeated until each micro-skill can be achieved at 100% fluency. But don't look for that any time soon, unless Bill Gates or Elon Musk decides to fund one.)