2 ms·
No, it doesn't make sense. Risk in lending is not just the term, it's also how much you lend to whom.
by snowwrestler 11y ago
No, it doesn't make sense. Risk in lending is not just the term, it's also how much you lend to whom.
- vegabook 11y agoAgreed. But lending to a riskier counterparty for 24 hours is usually going to command a lower risk premium than lending to anybody, even the US government, for 10 years. That's the essence of the story here. You make a valid point though: until now it has been riskier even to lend for 24 hours to a bank because of the binary nature in which banks go bust: they're solvent until they're not, and the run can happen in an event-wise, unpredictable fashion. The real story then is that even taking into account this high banking-sector risk, the US government is now riskier. But this has much more to do with the unlimited printing of debt (the real story) than the IRS market swap spread, and my wider point is that daily margining has been ignored by many of the people (here and in the financial markets chatter) who are talking up this issue as some kind of rubicon moment. This has been in the making for years and the slow grind below zero is not something that should be seen as extraordinary, nor, given the aforementioned slow grind lower, should it come as any surprise that it can go negative.
- snowwrestler 11y ago> But this has much more to do with the unlimited printing of debt (the real story) than the IRS market swap spread I don't get how U.S. debt is the driving factor. The rate of federal net debt growth has actually been slowing over the past ~3 years as the federal deficit has shrunk, i.e. the arrow is pointed in the right direction.
- tobltobs 11y agoSure it makes sense. He tried to explain the influence of term on risk calculation. Nowhere he stated that it is the only factor.
- snowwrestler 11y agoHe's making the case that the simple fact that a Treasury can have a 10-year term makes it riskier than a swap that is marked to market every 24 hours. This might be a makeable case, but just comparing the terms is not enough to do so. And, while he is using it to explain why Treasuries seem to have a risk premium now, it doesn't explain why they did not previously. Did swaps just start being m2M every 24 hours? Certainly there has been no major change to the nature of Treasuries over the past few months. So why the sudden shift?