3 ms·
The author was right: I did not. I do not want to read another article by someone who thinks the Iraq war was about terrorism, and who seems to have potato lev
by Someone1234 11y ago
The author was right: I did not.
I do not want to read another article by someone who thinks the Iraq war was about terrorism, and who seems to have potato levels of knowledge about international politics.
> and now in Syria, before in Libya, and only created more failed states and ungoverned spaces that provide havens for terrorists and spilled terror like dropped paint across borders.
Yeah, no, that isn't at all what happened. The US didn't create Syria or Libya. They're both civil wars that started organically (see "Arab Spring"); the US (and UK, et al) tried to fund certain factions after the conflicts kicked off, but they didn't initiate it.
While I agree with the overall thrust that we shouldn't sacrifice freedom for security, this whole article reads like a YouTube comment (meaning: uninformed, of low quality, making emotional but vapid arguments).
- seszett 11y agoYeah, I also didn't really agree with this: > Whack-a-mole is a game, not a plan. Leave the Middle East alone. Stop creating more failed states. For some reason, I have difficulty thinking that just "leaving the Middle East alone" will somehow lead ISIS to disappear on its own and the Syrian government/Syrian rebels/Kurds/various fundamentalist islamist groups to magically arrive to some peaceful balance. Especially with ISIS having the stated goal of world domination (yeah, just leaving alone those who want to dominate the world rarely works, we tried that for a while before 1939). The truth is, human society and civilization isn't a fundamentally stable system that's being thrown off by US or European interventions. Intervention is sometimes useful, sometimes bad, and it seems difficult for everyone to estimate whether interventions will be good or not.
- Retric 11y agoThe natural progression for 'lawless' areas is for stronger country's to attack and take land. They don't necessarily take over the whole country just the valuable pieces. Then repeat after that has been assimilated. Western intervention has stalled this process by imposing arbitrary borders on huge landmasses. ISIS only works because larger state actors have been held in check. But, a true hands off policy would likely lead to some regional wars which would quickly crush ISIS or see it evolve into a more traditional nation state. PS: Of course the other way this breaks down is when a large and mostly stable nation contains lawless regions. But, that does not really describe the region involved.
- dmix 11y ago> "leaving the Middle East alone" will somehow lead ISIS to disappear on This is a strawman attack. The author never stated that ISIS or terrorists will disappear or that a non-interventionist position by the west is a solution to a century of middle eastern conflicts. The article is about reevaluating failed strategies and exploring other strategies which might help minimize the negative externalities of the middle easts constant turmoil. Not fanning the flames is a very valid position to take in this context.
- minimuffins 11y agoHow do we know leaving the Mideast alone would not work? We've literally never tried it. Not since then end of World War II anyway. Human civilization may not be a naturally "stable system" but Western intervention in the Mideast or anywhere has an extremely poor track record.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoWell there's egypt. They went their own road didn't they? With "democratic unelections" and all that. I lost count of the coup there, but seems more stable now, even if less free.
- minimuffins 11y agoThe US propped up the Mubarak regime for decades. That was instrumental in creating the conditions for their revolution. The US only stopped its intervention when supporting Mubarak was obviously not viable anymore. Sadly it seems like they're back to a somewhat "stable" authoritarianism in spite of it all. In tech parlance, revolutions are hard.
- samstave 11y agoI'd just like to point out that the civil wars in both Syria and Libya were far from 100% organic. The U.S. Was pushing to fuck around with Syria and were embarrassed by Russia about two years ago, just prior to that we were funding and supplying rebels, who we now call terrorists. The U.S. Is very very good about fomenting "organic civil wars" among many other things... Syria is the new hotness in proxy war. And one of the things that sucks is that now the Paris issue tied with fake Syrian refugees is resulting in all sorts of craziness all over the world, including U.S. States' governments refusing any "refugees" My pessimistic side feels that some portion of the governments of the world are looking for the next arch duke Ferdinand to whack as a tinderbox.
- lobster_johnson 11y agoThe Syrian civil war might still have happened if the US hadn't already destabilized Iraq. But Iraq directly led to ISIS, which is partly composed of Iraqi ex-Baathists and holds a large amount of ground in Iraq along traditional Sunni divisions; arguably ISIS would not be the organization it is today if its scope had been geographically and politically limited to Syria.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]