7 ms·
Sure, everyone is happy with normal tax planning. But some of these tax avoidance schemes are only legal because tax authorities do not have the number of staf
by DanBC 11y ago
Sure, everyone is happy with normal tax planning.
But some of these tax avoidance schemes are only legal because tax authorities do not have the number of staff needed to investigate and prosecute all of them. They use weird loopholes (which get closed, and which sometimes require repayment of unpaid tax) and bizarre corporate structures which only exist to avoid tax.
Tax avoidance has changed its meaning from normal tax planning to become that gray not-yet-regulated area near outright tax evasion.
- junto 11y agoIf they really wanted to close these loopholes they would. Politicians only push them to be closed whilst a) the companies in question aren't lining their pockets, and b) the politicians start to lose votes because of it.
- rbcgerard 11y agoI think that that for every "loophole", separating the legitimate and illegitimate users (however you wish to define those) objectively is next to impossible.
- asift 11y agoWhile I think there is truth to your point, it's also true that some loopholes are the result of unintended consequences rather than conscious creation. In these instances, there will still be companies lobbying to keep these loopholes open, but the government can still fail at closing loopholes even when they are explicitly trying to close them.
- junto 11y agoIndeed, many loopholes are due to the fact that taxes are national whist companies are global.
- LordKano 11y agoBut some of these tax avoidance schemes are only legal because tax authorities do not have the number of staff needed to investigate and prosecute all of them. There is a difference between something that is legal and something that is illegal but difficult to prove. You seem to be conflating the two issues. They use weird loopholes (which get closed, and which sometimes require repayment of unpaid tax) and bizarre corporate structures which only exist to avoid tax. If tax law were not so onerous and burdensome, there would be no incentive to crease these corporate structures and to manage business in such a way. There is nothing legally or morally objectionable about using the rules, written by your adversary, to your own advantage.
- joosters 11y agoBut tax laws have to become more and more onerous in order to close each loophole... it's a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- jpgvm 11y agoNot entirely true. Tax laws have loopholes because exceptions were made. If there were no exceptions there would be no loopholes. So the real goal should be instead of trying to patch the infinite number of loopholes created by ever increasing complexity is to throw it all out and come up with a simple ruleset that applies to everyone and everything with no exceptions.
- derekp7 11y agoLet's try on an example: All revenue is taxed at 20%. Now this will work for some businesses, as the cost to make the product is low enough, and the sale price high enough, that 20% can be paid and there is still profit left over. But then there are very low margin, high volume businesses. They may have only a marginal profit per unit sold due to the nature of what they are selling, leaving no room for 20% tax. So we add in an exception that says "You can deduct from revenue the cost of goods sold" (i.e., tax on net instead of gross). Now all the business has to do is find ways of hiding profit in the cost of goods sold. Then there are products which contain materials that changed hands many times before it got to the final product. So if a raw material (lets say, cotton) is the majority expense, it has to go to one company to refine it, a second company to turn it into thread, a third to add color, a fourth to make it into fabric, and finally a fifth company to make a shirt. So that cotton gets taxed 5 times before it gets sold to the end consumer. So let's add another exception, that goods sold for use in making another product aren't taxed -- that way, large businesses that produce the entire vertical stack in-house don't have an unfair tax advantage against smaller companies. Gee, now we have another loophole that can be creatively exploited.
- gizi 11y agoConcerning "normal tax planning", there is no definition for the term "normal tax planning" for which we could implement a function that returns a yes or a no. In other words, the term "normal tax planning" would never appear in any policy document. The tax code is already arbitrary enough as it stands.
- rbcgerard 11y agoWhat many forget, but is fairly straightforward, is that tax planning is usually performed by accountants and lawyers at an hourly rate and is largely disconnected from the sum involved. Therefore the ROI of tax planning increases dramatically with larger sums. i.e. spend $50k to setup some complex structure to save $60k in taxes? no thanks, spend $75k to save $1m? i'm listening...