3 ms·
I still have no idea what you are trying, and failing, to say. But I will reply to this line: > Considering how long, say, Iran has been working on concentrat
by ars 11y ago
I still have no idea what you are trying, and failing, to say.
But I will reply to this line:
> Considering how long, say, Iran has been working on concentrating uranium, just how the heck did the first country in the Mideast get the critical materials?
I'm sure you've noticed that technologically Israel is light years ahead of Iran, and on-par or even ahead of the US. They most certainly could have purified the materials themself.
- blackguardx 11y agoIn what way is Israel ahead of the US? I could see them being equal to the US, but their economy just isn't big enough to be ahead technology-wise.
- ars 11y agoThis is old but it's a good example: http://www.seattletimes.com/business/how-israel-saved-intel/ http://www.seattletimes.com/business/how-israel-saved-intel/ Israel is very very very focused on high technology, much more so than the US. It's the reason for their economic success, and they have the human capital to be good at it. Since the US (people in the US) can do lots of things for income, it doesn't have that hyper focus and strong need to be great at tech. On top of that Israel has a huge need for technology for defense which is an even stronger motivator (for example every military vehicle sold by the US to Israel has no electronics, instead Israel puts in it's own custom stuff). It works out for the US anyway because the US is such a great ally to Israel that virtually all the tech is immediately shared between the two countries (and that includes the military with secret stuff - people think US aid to Israel is a one way street, but nothing could be further from the truth). > but their economy just isn't big enough to be ahead technology-wise. First the economy is shared with the US in many ways. Second technology is all about brainpower, and Israel has that. It's not about quantity, it's about quality.
- blackguardx 11y agoIt was my understanding that the US downgrades export munitions because it doesn't want other countries, allies or not, from having the same advanced weapons systems. Do you have any references?
- graycat 11y agoYou are angry, and for nothing about anything I wrote.
- graycat 11y ago> They most certainly could have purified the materials themself. Know how? Yes. Actually do it? Likely not -- starting with just common uranium, it's a lot of work and a big installation to get to weapons grade uranium or plutonium, and hiding that installation would not have been easy. Easy or not, the old story was that Israel got the bomb materials, plutonium, from the US accounting error, deliberately done and covered up in the US. My point in my post was to suggest that the OP, considering current and recent events in the Mideast, was to remind enemies of Israel that Israel does have nuke bombs and did get the plutonium from the US via an effort in Pennsylvania. Again, that story is old -- I heard it long ago and saw it essentially repeated in the movie The Sum of All Fears. That is, my comment was to mention a possibly curious purpose to the OP. This conjecture about the purpose of the OP can continue to stand whatever the truth was about how Israel got, if they ever did, materials for nuke bombs. Tough for me to believe that the highly technical HN audience had so much difficulty with my post.
- selimthegrim 11y agoSurely you're familiar with the story of Arnon Milchan, late of Hollywood?