5 ms·
After you've paid these pennies, what is the incentive to not still show you ads or surveil you for commercial advantage? IMHO we're better off focusing on def
by mindslight 11y ago
After you've paid these pennies, what is the incentive to not still show you ads or surveil you for commercial advantage?
IMHO we're better off focusing on defeating the hostile behavior first. The Internet was a much nicer place before monetization via web spam.
- carbocation 11y agoIn fact, after you have paid these pennies, you have proven that you are willing to pay. This makes you even more valuable for an advertiser than you were when you paid nothing...
- privong 11y ago> This makes you even more valuable for an advertiser than you were when you paid nothing... But it's the websites that are being paid by the advertisers. If the reader is more valuable to the website than the advertiser is, then advertising might be reduced. Of course, it's possible advertisers would respond to this by offering more money per ad.
- tptacek 11y agoIt was? I don't remember it that way. There was definitely a lot less web spam before web spam, and pages loaded faster, but we weren't more secure (we were less secure, for reasons having nothing to do with web spam), and we had fewer choices and less content.
- mindslight 11y agoLess "content" was great. It was nicer to sift through a few pages of search results to find a few dense authoritative sources, edited and published by people with something to say. Today, the results are better ranked but more fragmented and sparser in originality, with a heavy weighting towards commercial platforms that aggregate tidbits. (I don't really see what security has to do with this)
- idlewords 11y agoTurn off ghostery and ad blocking for a few days and see if you still think things are better. I say this with sunken eyes and sepulchral voice, having had to surf the actual internet for a week in researching a talk.
- tptacek 11y agoI don't use ad-blockers or Ghostery; just out-of-the-box Chrome.
- idlewords 11y agoI'm frankly amazed. My laptop fan kept spinning and I had to keep religiously closing tabs.
- tptacek 11y agoWell, ok, look, yes, that happens to me several times a day, and I'm very well acquainted with the Chrome Task Manager window. I'm not sticking up for ad-tech! I just wouldn't trade the 2005 Internet for the one I have now.
- dredmorbius 11y agoDoes this mean there's another Idlewords essay appearing soon?
- dredmorbius 11y agoDoes this mean there's another Idlewords essay appearing soon?
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> we had fewer choices and less content But the content was better and the signal to noise ratio was much bigger.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- privong 11y ago> After you've paid these pennies, what is the incentive to not still show you ads or surveil you for commercial advantage? The parent may have been saying that if we'd had micropayments earlier, the ad culture may never have arisen or gotten as bad. However, I think there's still a chance that micropayments could reduce ads. If it can result in a reasonable revenue stream, it might become advantageous to reduce ads and market that one's website doesn't track people with ads. That might further drive revenue.
- ZoFreX 11y agoThe amount currently paid by users (in terms of their bandwidth used for ads) massively exceeds the amount websites get for displaying those ads. If users paid directly, they would need to pay _very little_ to be outbidding the advertisers so much that it wouldn't be worth the effort to add an ad platform to your website. That's the incentive to not still show you ads.
- chongli 11y agoYou pay a penny to read an article. If they show you an ad and you find that objectionable, withhold future pennies. Further, inform anyone who will listen that the publisher is being dishonest about ads. Anyone who finds this objectionable will likewise withhold their pennies. What makes this hypothetical microtransaction-based market different from classical publishing/broadcasting is the lack of friction on the internet. Friendster, Myspace, Digg et al. is the lesson we should all take to heart.