4 ms·
I have no problem with the idea that certain forms of speech should end your career. If someone starts yelling slurs at people, they shouldn't have a job that
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
I have no problem with the idea that certain forms of speech should end your career. If someone starts yelling slurs at people, they shouldn't have a job that involves interacting with people anymore. That doesn't infringe upon their free speech rights; they can say anything they like, and others can respond accordingly, which includes firing them or choosing not to hire them.
The question then becomes where to draw the line: what speech deserves that level of response? And that seems like a topic people can vigorously disagree about.
In particular, any conflict of fundamental values generates heated debate. It's "easy" to evaluate a conflict between a fundamental value and something that isn't: the fundamental value tends to win. That's part of why people rarely change their minds about fundamental values; not necessarily a feature. But when a conflict arises between two fundamental values (say, "free speech" and "non-discrimination") that many people hold simultaneously, people have to actually think to resolve the issue. You'll get some people taking sides (such as declaring "free speech" absolute and telling people to grow a thicker skin), but you'll also get people learning to define their values more precisely (e.g. your right to speak doesn't require others to listen without reaction, or to give you a platform from which to speak).
- bmelton 11y ago> And that seems like a topic people can vigorously disagree about. Thankfully, most industries don't have blacklists, so each "career-ending" moment can be evaluated independently by people who do hiring in that respective field. Speech that mocks a Jeb Bush might disqualify you from work at Fox News, or (if any exist) conservative-leaning universities, but might actually be viewed as favorable to others. It is because we so vigorously disagree on those levels that, for the most part, even though there may be some job losses in the present, except where they are universally disagreed with, should not necessarily be career-ending. Or, at least that's how it works in theory. Gary Webb's career never rebounded from having printed a generally true series of articles, but then again, it might eventually have righted itself had he not died in 2004.
- tedunangst 11y agoShould they get their job back when they stop yelling slurs?
- ddingus 11y agoDepends. They will have demonstrated a basic lack of consideration important for that sort of work. It is on them to make the case they now will demonstrate that consideration. A very common thought will be, "they do, until they don't" and their case will center in on that risk. If successful, they will improve on that basic dynamic over time spent demonstrating that consideration.
- progressive_dad 11y ago"I don't want to spend my life not having good food going into my pie hole. That hole was made for pies." -Paula Deen
- ddingus 11y agoCase in point, yes?