5 ms·
I agree immensely with this. I recently attended DebConf 15, (the conference for Debian), and in an introductory session some long-time attendees were asked to
by teddyh 11y ago
I agree immensely with this. I recently attended DebConf 15, (the conference for Debian), and in an introductory session some long-time attendees were asked to express why they attended the conference. What they said were things like “This is where all my friends are.” and I even heard someone say “Debian is my family.”. This is emphatically not why I go to any conferences. I go to conferences in order to advance the state of the field by listening to talks and getting to personally talk to people also working to advance the field, in this case the Debian GNU/Linux operating system distribution.
I did get a lot of that done, but this spirit of chummy familiarity was pervasive. Every problem of getting people to cooperate and collaborate more was approached as a problem of not enough socializing. But I don’t want to socialize with lots of random people. I want to make Debian more awesome, not shoot the breeze with random people with wine and cheese (yes, DebConf has a Wine and Cheese event in addition to the large social outing). Beyond having a title and summary for talks (and some rather narrowly scoped BoF sessions), there were no concerted efforts to get people in the same field of interest to get to speaking about common topics and solving common problems. I voiced a complaint to someone about this, that in order to find anyone who was interested in the topics I wanted to discuss I would have had to basically randomly wander around and ask every person I met about what they did, which would have taken a lot of time and energy. But the person I talked to saw it as a good thing to essentially force me to socialize with people even though pure socializing was not my goal.
Optimizing groups to be more social to the detriment of all else is not what you want to do if your group has any other overriding reason to exist beyond being a pure social club, since you exclude people who would rather work towards the group’s proclaimed goal than being social and chatting with friends.
- moron4hire 11y agoYou're doing conferences wrong, then. The entire point of conferences is the interpersonal networking. Online materials are far better way to disseminate information, the speaking sessions are literally a waste of time, just an excuse to get people in the same hotel together.
- teddyh 11y agoI can certainly do networking, but there’s a difference with that and pure socializing. When you network, you want to know that the people you’re about to talk to have some reasonable chance of being interested in your topics. In pure socializing, it doesn’t matter, you just mash as many different people together as possible and it’s all good. When I network, I want to know that this group, here, at this time or in this room or at this table, is actually interested in a specific topic which I wish to discuss. I can’t do that with a conference of hundreds of people most of which are not interested in the topics I want to discuss. A conference should not be simply an opportunity to socialize. If that’s how you do conferences, then you’re doing them wrong.
- moron4hire 11y agoDebian is your common topic. The people who are there are interested in a topic you're interested in. From what it sounds like, you want to precognate that down to one or two people. Networking is about meeting people you can get along with who maybe, one day, some day, if things work nicely, might have a mutual benefit. You don't begin it with a pretense about what they can do for you now. That sort of opportunism is phony and can be smelled from a mile away. Networking works best when you just meet people to become friends with them, then hope to figure out ways you can help them, as friends do. My experience is that people pay it back in spades. If it were just about merits, resumes would be a thing that actually worked and were important. Conferences are about networking and networking is about socialization. Yeah, it could be years before the networking you do today pays off. That's just the way it is. You're dealing with people, not machines. It's like dating, you can't magic up a spell to make someone like you. People have their own agency, but they tend to congregate around and like to help out other people who are friendly and helpful without expecting anything in return, too.
- teddyh 11y ago> Debian is your common topic. What is necessary is a topic to narrow the scope down to be few enough people for me to actually have time to talk to most of them. I can’t (and I feel I shouldn’t be made to) talk to hundreds of people merely to find them. Also, I could be of more help to people who need help in a field I know something about. > Conferences are about networking and networking is about socialization. Why do you assert this, when my point was that it is not so?
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoAt the risk of sounding provocative, Debian are a political effort first and a technical project second. They're much more of a target platform than a leader in their own right. As such, I'm not surprised that there was significantly more interest in self-preservation and socializing than in any technical work. I don't recall Debian ever pushing boundaries.
- teddyh 11y agoDebian has plenty of technical work done within its boundaries. (Don’t forget the pioneering work that Debian did with its package format which was greatly superior to that of Red Hat’s RPM at the time.) A distribution is not created by simply downloading all software from the upstream authors, compiling them and burning a CD. Simply read the Debian Policy manual to get a feel for the vastness of an undertaking which creating a distribution really is: https://www.debian.org/doc/debian-policy/ https://www.debian.org/doc/debian-policy/
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoOf course they've done technical work, they're a distribution. Of course they have a distribution standard, they're a large committee-driven project. None of these are pushing the boundaries as such. I never said anything to the contrary, but rather that those are all secondary to the primary political goals. A distribution having a detailed technical policy does not refute any of this. I don't support Red Hat, either. dpkg's original conception was a tarball-based package management Perl script with rudimentary substring match dependency processing. It evolved as time went on. GNU is the same. Politics first, technology second. They've generally been much better at both, however.
- jschwartzi 11y agoAny time you put more than two people in a room together and ask them to finish something, there will be politics. The only thing you can do is make sure everyone has some goals that are the same as the organization's. In a corporation, this is achieved by paying people to be responsible for certain aspects of the company's operations. In a volunteer organization, this is accomplished by having the people in the organization socialize around the organization. Everyone has their reasons. Some people are motivated by producing beautiful functional code. Others are motivated by the ideals of Free Software. Still others want to use the community to sell hardware. At the end of the day, as long as they're all moving in a similar direction, the movement is successful. Whether or not the movement is a good thing depends on your values and motives.
- jordigh 11y agoSocialising is very important (hell, why are you talking on HN if you don't want social interaction)? The teams that have lunch together perform better. http://ridiculouslyefficient.com/boost-employee-productivity-with-office-lunch-traditions/ http://ridiculouslyefficient.com/boost-employee-productivity... I think the precious little time at Debconf is good for socialising. It seems ok if that's the main purpose. There is already plenty technical discussion in Debian mailing lists.
- teddyh 11y ago1. Strawman. I never said that socializing was unimportant. But socializing is not the only way to actually collaborate. You don’t have to be best buddies with your collegues to work with them. “Having lunch together” does not imply being friends with people, but it could certainly imply having a set time to talk more informally about more general problems without a set “owner”. 2. I was at Debconf for two weeks. I hardly consider that to be “precious little time”.
- jordigh 11y agoBut you emphatically said that you do not go to conferences to socialise. That's the most important part of a conference. I daresay, it's really the ultimate goal. Otherwise, we could just all post screencasts online instead of having a conference. That would be a lot cheaper. Emphatically not wanting to socialise sounds exactly like you think socialising is not important. A less emphatic "no" might still make it sound like you think it has some importance. And two weeks a year is precious little time, if you compare it with having lunch with your coworkers every day.
- plonh 11y agoHaving lunch with your coworkers gives you 250 chances per year to have an important work-related conversation. A conference offers precious little time, so it is important to be efficient in getting people together who have things to say to each other.
- rumcajz 11y agoSeconded. I always find it hard at conferences to find people who are genuinely interested in stuff that I care about.
- teddyh 11y agoAlso: The “big names” in the community, the more famous people, do not have this problem. For them, the “unplanned social chaos” model of conference organization works perfectly – lots of people are constantly coming to them to talk about the topics that they are interested in – they don’t see the problem, they live in a kind of bubble. But in reality, this is a symptom of the problem – people seek out the big names because they are the only persons that people know of who are intestested in the topic. There is no mechanism to make people aware of each other’s interest.
- will_pseudonym 11y agoIt sounds like you've had a lot of bad experiences with conferences let you down by not focusing on the technical discussion. I'm really sorry you've had to go through that so often. In thinking about your predicament, it seems like there's an opportunity here for the organizers to put together an online forum before the conference so that people can put in for being put into groups and sessions where people have specific things that they want to talk about. It seems like both you and the other poster you were discussing this with were equally bothered by the other's preferred activities of conferences. I think if you could arrange discussions ahead of the conferences, you'd enjoy your time a lot more.
- teddyh 11y agoSounds like a good idea. One other thing which organizers should watch out for is not to create enormous distractions away from discussions and networking: https://web.archive.org/web/20130808111450/http://ryanfunduk.com/culture-of-exclusion/ https://web.archive.org/web/20130808111450/http://ryanfunduk... (Previously discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6373983 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6373983)
- ant6n 11y agoAt Pycon, there's a lot of socializing and community building going on, and those are very important. But if you really care about meeting people with specific technical interests in order to advance on some project together, there are plenty of strategies to go about that. 1) Give a talk about the technical problem you are interested in. People who also care will attend, and later meet with you to discuss the topic (and related ones) in person. Giving a talk yourself is probably the best way to find people interested in your subject. 2) At Pycon you can book open spaces (e.g. https://us.pycon.org/2015/community/openspaces/ https://us.pycon.org/2015/community/openspaces/). There are basically a bunch of small rooms, and you can book some time slots to assign the room a certain topic, and see whether like-minded people will show up. (You could also do something non-technical like board games...) 3) After Pycon proper, there are usually a couple of days of code sprints (e.g. https://us.pycon.org/2015/community/sprints/ https://us.pycon.org/2015/community/sprints/). This gives people the chance to advance an open source project together. Some people use that as a way to meet in person with other developers, or it's possible to recruit new developers for a project.
- teddyh 11y agoYes, things like those “open spaces” are exactly what I like to see! Very nice. I also remember the tables they had at a CCCC I once was at, with lots of people from a project sitting and working at tables, with large signs on each table so you could simply walk up to a table and talk to the people there about their project.