3 ms·
Let's be honest this day isn't going to come or if it does no one is going to care. The only scientific issue that has such a strong political element is clima
by threeseed 11y ago
Let's be honest this day isn't going to come or if it does no one is going to care.
The only scientific issue that has such a strong political element is climate change. And given that the new government in Canada is left wing and pro environment I can't imagine their being much (if any) dissension. This was the primary reason the scientists were muzzled after all. All the other scientific issues from the lay person/media perspective simply aren't that interesting.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoThere are a variety of scientific issues with political elements. For example, evolution. Not the relatively uncontroversial evolution from (common ancestor) -> {humans, apes}, but evolution within humans after this point. See, e.g. James Watson: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Watson#Provocative_comments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Watson#Provocative_comme... Or economics. Consider this incident in the US: http://thehill.com/policy/finance/255726-dem-economists-attack-warren-over-brookings-firing http://thehill.com/policy/finance/255726-dem-economists-atta... The only real attacks on science that get coverage are the ones attacking environmentalism or pre-human evolution. But science does (or at least should) influence politics in a lot more places.
- pervycreeper 11y agoI would go further and say that any scientific topic which has any controversy is "political" by definition. Furthermore, the political dogmas that are held by laypeople almost universally depend on empirical or scientific facts which have not been established or have the imminent potential to be overturned. Political bias has an effect on what research gets funded and/or published, the size of which is correlated to the "softness" of the discipline.
- 542458 11y ago> The only scientific issue that has such a strong political element is climate change. Economic policy is hotly debated in both economic science and government. Same to immigration policy. Even statistics has it's controversial bits. Anthropologists also periodically produce some controversial nuggets. Also, let's not forget that many scientists won't hesitate to give their opinion on whatever is asked of them!
- dexterdog 11y agoEconomics- not really science. Where is their lab?
- MAGZine 11y agoI think it's wrong to say that research must specifically conducted on scientific matters. There are many people who actively research economics. Also, their lab can be anywhere, doesn't matter. science is about the scientific process, not labcoats and microscopes.
- 542458 11y agoEconomics is a social science. The idea that science must be performed in a lab is fundamentally wrong. That said, economists do have labs where they conduct data analysis, often with the assistance of large computing resources.
- nitrogen 11y agoTo summarize the other responses in trite soundbite form: Science is a methodology, not a location.