2 ms·
Very welcome and good to see the info getting well-received. Can't get rid of support for this monstrosity (C) until people see exactly what and why it is.
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Very welcome and good to see the info getting well-received. Can't get rid of support for this monstrosity (C) until people see exactly what and why it is.
- agumonkey 11y agoI don't react as strongly (was it the main motivation behind your research ?) alghouth, C weaknesses really do allow for too many nasty issues in code we rely on. What astonishes me is how something which seems a crude plagiarism became the mainstream of low-level and fast for so long. Even UNIX ... I sense a strong pragmatism about market, ecosystem, network effect and the like. I left the video thinking Unix/C was the WordPress/PHP of its domain and era....
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIt was a partial motivation. Many have stars in their eyes seeing C as best-designed system language to the point that modifications aren't considered for bare-metal. One motivation is countering that with cold-hard truth about its alleged design and real history. Other people already see its issues but might want to learn more or enjoy the full context. This re-enforces the move away from such features where possible along with providing evidence to deliver in future conversations supporting that. Either benefit is a fine result to me. "What astonishes me is how something which seems a crude plagiarism became the mainstream of low-level and fast for so long. Even UNIX ..." Richard Gabriel explained that well in his Worse is Better essays. Hence why you see me mention it a lot. Has much to do with ease of participation, economics, and group dynamics. Things like C, UNIX, and early OSS made it easy to get started to gain a critical momentum. Past that, it's basically all momentum and its effects. One usually can't counter momentum so much as create an alternate momentum or divert flows off the existing momentum. Hence, co-development of radical approaches like SAFE or JX OS's plus legacy-supporting approaches like Nizza Security Architecture or Cambridge CHERI processor & CHERIBSD. Yet, the full momentum of UNIX and C remain as more gets piled onto them despite the cost. https://www.dreamsongs.com/WorseIsBetter.html https://www.dreamsongs.com/WorseIsBetter.html Note: Ignore his emotional rants tied to specific tech to focus on the effects of the New Jersey approach on market take-up. Truthfully, I think he discovered the time-to-market effect of technology and a method of achieving it before it became a common thing people wrote about. Then again, I haven't studied the history of that enough to be sure.