7 ms·
When I stopped hearing the voices in my head
- SCAQTony 11y agoBook: "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameralism_(psychology)#Breakdown_of_bicameralism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameralism_(psychology)#Brea... Theory: The brain has two hemispheres: One does the talking and one does the listening. Sometimes we react because the "self" is the last to know or just reacts not realizing it is a self evaluation below our awareness. (Dog goes to bite your hand and you react.) We then try to assign order to that chaos with a reason such as "god[s]", or "spirit[s] warned us or made us do so. Snippet: "..."... Leftovers of the bicameral mind today, according to Jaynes, include religion, hypnosis, possession, schizophrenia and the general sense of need for external authority in decision-making...."
- nwatson 11y agoThe Bicameral-Mind theorist apparently claimed that before 3,000 years ago all/most people behaved as the article's author, receiving direction and correction from externally perceived voices. Only at some point around that time did people become meta-aware, conscious of their own thoughts.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoAnd it also inspired some of the concepts in Neal Stephenson's "Snow Crash".
- vorg 11y agoAre there any more recent works that develop on this idea with new research and historical analysis, or is this 40-year old book still the best there is?
- SCAQTony 11y ago"The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: a critical reappraisal of Julian Jaynes’ hypothesis" (2006) http://www.functionalneurology.com/materiale_cic/224_XXII_1/2108_the%20bicamiral/index.html http://www.functionalneurology.com/materiale_cic/224_XXII_1/... a Institute of Neurology, London, UK b Department of Neurology, Amedeo Avogadro University, Novara, Italy c Department of Classical Philology, University of Bologna, Italy Reprint requests to: Dr Andrea Eugenio Cavanna Amedeo Avogadro University Corso Mazzini, 18 - 28100 Novara - Italy E-mail: acavanna@ion.ucl.ac.uk Received: October 2006 Accepted for publication: January 2007
- kefka 11y agoSo the solution is to provide drugs that somehow deaden random neurons in somewhat random parts of the brain, and hope they don't cause massive side effects down the line? Just like that dental article a few days ago, doesn't the current psychiatric medicine seem like using a backhoe on a flower pot? Sure, you move the soil, but you trash the porch.
- ksenzee 11y agoIt depends which medications you're talking about, and which conditions you're treating with them. A lot of them are more like using a shovel on a flowerpot. Still not precisely the right tool, but they get the job done and the porch is still in good shape.
- kefka 11y agoPoint well made. With my ex-fiancee, a psychiatrist had her on prozac and abilify. She had a complete breakdown in her senior year of university classes. They put her on a cocktail of stuff and weren't honest in their dealings (parents and doctor). She had quite a few voices and things in her head. And the drugs helped that, to a point. It was when she started getting tics that I investigated more, and saw the 3-5 pages of "adverse conditions". Tics (tardive dyskinesia) was a permanent adverse condition, and could be gained at any time after starting just Abilify. When you're trading one set of nasty stuff for another set of nasty stuff, and then eventually have to quit, is it worth it? Especially if you end up getting the initial set of nasty plus whatever the drugs have induced as well? Hopefully, better research will target neurons directly or properly calculate for hormonal deficiencies. Now admittedly, I'm for proper disclosure and informed consent. There's times in which a drug/surgery can cause more damage than what you're trying to fix. And in the case of my ex, it was that she was developing adverse conditions, and she wasn't told. I've taken antidepressants along with other medicines. Nothing wrong with taking drugs to help fix problems. If you're thinking about quitting, talk to your doctor. Some of those drugs are dangerous to quit cold turkey.
- DanBC 11y agoThat sounds like a horrible experience and it's not surprising that you feel the way you do about psychiatric meds. You're right that many of them at the moment suck. They have long lists of side effects, some of the side effects are severe (reducing quality of life, sometimes reducing length of life). At least in the UK there's some push towards patients becoming much more involved in their care. There's a bit of of focus on the informed part of informed consent. But we could do better here. For some of the severe mental illnesses it's a tricky balance - do we medicate people or let them live with their illness? Mostly this should be up to the patient. If someone has the capacity to decide then they're allowed to "make the wrong choice". And while the side effects suck they can be better than the illness, which can lead people to die by suicide or live miserable lives. But if someone just hears voices, and is okay with them, doctors should not be pushing that person towards medication but towards crisis planning and advanced directives.
- cygnus_a 11y agoI often have intense fantasies about conversations with personal mentors, historical figures and/or deities (what would Buddha say? How about Einstein? etc). Obviously I can't reproduce their thoughts, but knowing a little about them, I can try to think like them Surely they're not as visceral or reflexive as the author's voices. But I have always found value in empathizing with fantasized mentors, which has given me confidence in my opinions.
- sageikosa 11y agoI sometimes talk to myself or to hypothetical instances of other people I know. I try to do this quietly at times since I know it might not be perceived favorably by others. Mainly I do this to verbally externalize thoughts and force them back into my auditory memory (deliberately), hopefully reinforcing or bolstering a position I want to take or a course of action I need to take later. I hope I never lose track that I am initiating those conversations...I'm old enough to be well past the standard age for developing schizophrenia...but if I did lose track, I at least have my atheism to fall back upon and my memory of having read through Jaynes a couple of times.
- sevensor 11y ago> I try to do this quietly If you hold a mobile phone to your ear, nobody will give you a second look.
- iagooar 11y agoUnless you get a real call while doing so.
- jacquesm 11y ago"Please hold while I get the other line" (what should really worry you is if you hear 'ok.')
- jonsterling 11y agoJust make sure your phone is charged, since you'll look like a real douche if there's an emergency and you need to call police/ambulance with your dead phone that you've just been talking on...
- dx211 11y agoI have this thing where I wake up at 5:00 AM and my internal monologue sounds like someone twisting the tuning knob back and forth on a radio. Anyone know a name for that?
- ashark 11y agoKind of a horrifying cacophony? Mind is racing but unfocused, and you can't force it to focus? Makes it difficult to go back to sleep? Yeah, I get that every so often. Every couple months, maybe. No idea what it might be called.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoI think have that multiple times a week; almost feels like a waterfall in my head. Sometimes a song gets stuck in my head, and I just hum it until I'm "done waking up".
- ashark 11y agoOof, the times when it's one or more songs are the worst. I'd forgotten about that one.
- SCHiM 11y agoBut isn't that just called 'having a song stuck in your head?' I almost always have a song running in the background, never the same, but I wake up to a song and I go to sleep with a song.
- Riseed 11y agoHaving a song stuck in your head is like having a working player stuck on repeat-1. Sometimes "one or more songs" manifests not as one song at a time, but instead like a cacophony of players all stuck on repeat-1.
- grubles 11y ago
- khed 11y agoIt should be noted that studies looking at normal vs no/reduced antipsychotic therapy in patients with psychotic dieases have indicated that in the long term patients may do significantly better without antipsychotic therapy. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23824214 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23824214 http://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/director/2013/antipsychotics-taking-the-long-view.shtml http://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/director/2013/antipsychotics-t...
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoCan't help but be reminded of Jayne's Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind.
- namenumber 11y agoInteresting article. Moreso for me as this is perhaps the one topic around here i have some first hand experience with. That feeling is really really odd though. There's a moment when you go "wait, that's an apparently fully functioning consciousness that is capable of responding to my every thought, my brain/reality can DO THAT?". For me it took a long time to play off the many different possible solutions to that puzzle, and at the end of the day i settled for a mix of "currently unknown exactly how that is done" (sort of like consciousness itself, i guess) to "wow, reality sure does have some extra layers of "fun" i hadn't really been informed about. If the voice(es) in any way confined themselves to the spectrum of being/knowledge that i as an individual acknowledged that i was in posession of, that would be one thing, but the world becomes a weird place when they go outside your acknowledged "knowns". Now, i was lucky enough to have a very supportive and patient family that viewed it as something that could be managed outside of the realm of antipsychotic therapy. I'm not saying that handling it with prescribed drugs is necessarily a bad idea, if it works for you then i hope it continues to do so. Sorry for the rant, but i was just reminded of how weird all of that stuff was to go through. Its been a while since i thought about it.
- namenumber 11y agoI guess it goes parallell to another question i have. How is it possible for a brain without anything but pretty basic musical training to conjure up a fully functioning, never before heard, tunable symphony. This was a place i occasionally ended up in the midst of all of the nightly mental hoolahoops i had to go through. (It would collapse on itself eventually, but still, the array of instruments and sounds was way more than i could ever make in my normal waking time). It is basically the same question as "how does the brain conjure dream", i guess. But experienced from the awake state. And it just stays with you in a slightly different way when you experience it whilst awake. I guess i'll never know.
- archagon 11y agoI've always been jealous of people who could do stuff like talk to "other" people or listen to symphonies in their head. But I just realized: I do all that stuff too, but only when I'm dreaming. The incredible environments, landscapes, and people that come to me in my dreams seem to exist outside my head entirely, because there's simply no way for me to conjure them when I'm awake. It's as if my brain doles out my consciousness only as a tiny, fractional part of its full capabilities. In other words, I am maybe not as much its master as I thought. I wonder if there's a way to unlock that ability in my everyday life. Sidenote: I can sometimes sort of do it when I'm awake, but only when I'm really, really tired.
- contingencies 11y agoFor a few years, every time my mind was momentarily still it would repeat the word "death". It never bothered me, and I always interpreted it philosophically (eg. as a meditational aid) and put it down to reading too much Buddhist literature.
- archagon 11y agoSounds a bit like OCD. If I keep my mind still, something terrible always fills the void and I have to give my consciousness something to focus on. When I was younger, I referred to this as "hearing voices"; it was a huge relief when I eventually found out about OCD and its symptoms. It's exhausting!
- contingencies 11y agoThanks for your response, though I don't believe my experience matched the symptoms of OCD, as there was no O-C relation, C or D.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mirimir 11y agoWe all have at least one of these voices in our heads. Like the author, some of us give them names, and fancy conversations among them. But for the most part, they simply occur to us as "I". "I" likes to think that it's running the show, but really it's at best a commentator. All too often, that "I" fucks up and sabotages. As HenryTheHorse notes, in Buddhism it's called the "monkey mind". It's a machine that evolved for survival and reproduction. Anyway, it's useful to distinguish "It" -- the "monkey mind" survival machine -- from ones identity. And that's a practice to engage in. Understanding is the booby prize ;)
- DanBC 11y agoNo, hearing voices is a very different experience to the regular internal monologue that everyone has. People hearing voices perceive those heard voices in the same way they'd perceive an actual person talking to them. People experience different voices, but it's reasonably common to experience the voice as male and standing behind you. But the voice could be whispering (like white noise), or robotic, and it could appear to come from people actually in the room or from objects.
- mirimir 11y agoHow do you know that? Have you experienced both? Otherwise, you're at best interpreting what others have said. Or maybe just what others have written about the subject.
- DanBC 11y agoI've spoken to people who hear voices and they decribe the differences very clearly, and there's plenty of research about this.
- mirimir 11y agoFair enough. But I've heard many sorts of voices in my head. There's the usual one that observes and echoes what I'm doing. But there are other voices that come with stress and anxiety. Sometimes they warn me, alert me to danger. Sometimes they converse, and get into arguments. Then there are other fainter voices that come with various drugs, under various circumstances. When people seek help about such matters, they often find themselves working with therapists who have this or that conceptual framework. And so patients learn to frame their experience accordingly. Explanations are comforting. So anyway, I'm dubious about the distinction. I think that it's an artifact of social norms and therapeutic bullshit.
- peter303 11y agoI offer her kudos for suceeding!
- NickHaflinger 11y agoSound different from the life experience of a woman I met recently who also had to withdraw from uni through overwork. That was over fifteen years ago. Unfortunately she was sectioned by her family (who all then skipped off to America). She's been prescribed a cocktail of psychotropic pharmaceuticals ever since. She has developed type two diabetes, disruption of thyroid activity, kidney damage, fluid retention and dangerously overweight. A once intelligent and good looking woman reduced to a shambling wreak like something out of the living dead and can't even remember what you told her yesterday. Not much of a cure after fifteen years of 'treatment'. The mental health professionals must know the damage the drugs are doing. But I guess they are making a good living out of her. ------- I find that whole article manipulative and disingenuous in the extreme. A full page free advertisement for the psycho-pharma industry.
- frenchy 11y agoDid it ever strike you that maybe the physician recommended against the pharmaceutical treatment, but the patient still went for it anyway because "I have to do something"?