7 ms·
> there is no advocacy of using violence to achieve ends Please explain the harrowing of hell. My local cathedral has stained glass (14th century) of Christ
by DanBC 11y ago
> there is no advocacy of using violence to achieve ends
Please explain the harrowing of hell. My local cathedral has stained glass (14th century) of Christ in full armour, with big sword, going to hell to release the righteous (but not the damned), conquering hell in the proces.
http://vidimus.org/issues/issue-04/feature/ http://vidimus.org/issues/issue-04/feature/
(Possibly not quite hell, but the bit before that.)
There is a long tradition of Christians using their bible to justify violence. There's plenty of violence in the bible. But, when pointed out, Christians start saying that those bits don't count, or those bits have been misinterpreted, or that you need to read that other bit as well.
I have you saying that the quran is violent, and I have hundreds of millions of muslims telling me that it's a book of peace.
- tomohawk 11y agoThere is a long history of charletans, politicians, criminals, and other unsavory characters using one religion or another as a pretext for their actions. That doesnt' mean that their actions had anything to do with those religions. You have to exercise a little more discernment to dig into what they're saying and what the religion actually advocates to come to a conclusion. In the case of Christianity, I think it is telling that at the time the founder was teaching, there was a dictator in Rome who claimed to be god and who was heavily suppressing the ethnic group (Jews) that the founder belonged to. Did this man advocate any sort of political or violent acts to remedy the situation? No. I don't think it really matters what the opinion is of a lot of people when we can merely look at recorded history and see what the founder of Islam did.
- hackuser 11y agoAs I pointed out above, this is silliness and nonsense. How does the "founder" affect what a particular individual does today? Should an indivdual be judged as a person, or be guilty or innocent, or have their rights taken away, based on what a book says a religious leader did 1300 years ago? If Jesus was so peaceful and the founder is so influential, how do you explain all the evil acts of Christians? The founder of all three religions, Abraham, impressed God by being willing to perform human sacrifice of his own son! I hope I'm not judged by that. Or if you only count Abraham as the founder of Judaism, should all Jews be expected to perform human sacrifice?
- acqq 11y agoIt seems you don't know what which religion claims. The "founder" of Christianity is considered by Christians to actually be "God." ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity ) The "book" in which Muslims believe is by Muslims considered to be the actual words of God, and they negate the claims of both Jews and Christians, these just prepared the ground for Muhammad who is the last one who will ever receive the messages from God. And the messages are accurately recorded by miracle. My favorite "actual last words" of God from those are where he says (roughly) that the uncle of Mohammad will go to hell and that the wife of the uncle will carry the wood for that fire. (111:1 etc) Such a natural thing for God to worry to pass to the humanity for ever and ever. The uncle of Mohammad dared to consider the claims of Mohammad (that he receives the messages of god) as stupidity and dangerous, Sunnah explains. I'm not making this up.
- jnbiche 11y ago> I have you saying that the quran is violent, and I have hundreds of millions of muslims telling me that it's a book of peace. Why not try reading it and making up your mind for yourself? I happen to share the opinion of the parent poster about the founder of Islam, but at the same time, the Qu'ran is a very interesting and in parts beautiful work of literature. Furthermore, Islam has given rise to some peaceful and open-minded groups, the Sufi tradition comes to mind (although yes, even the Sufis have suffered violent splinter groups over the centuries).
- acqq 11y agoQu'ran is available online and searchable, search for the word "slay" for example: http://quran.com/search?q=slay http://quran.com/search?q=slay "And slay them wherever ye find them, and drive them out of the places whence they drove you out, for persecution is worse than slaughter. And fight not with them at the Inviolable Place of Worship until they first attack you there, but if they attack you (there) then slay them. Such is the reward of disbelievers." Also search "disbelievers." And on sunnah.com search "stoned."
- jnbiche 11y agoI'm very aware of those passages and others that reflect the religion's violent origins, having actually read the book, or most of it (have you?). If you were disagreeing with me, did you miss the part of my comment where I said I shared the parent's opinion of Muhammed (and yours as well, I presume)? I simply was encouraging someone wondering about the Quran to read it himself so he could make up his own mind, regardless of our opinions. Obviously, in the interest of fairness, similar passages about stoning/slaying can be found in the Tanakh/Old Testament. Luckily, few Christians or Jews take those passages literally today.
- acqq 11y agoYes, reading the Old Testament, the New Testament and the Quran and comparing them is really instructive. However Quran is just one of the two primary sources (the messages received by Muhammad), you'd have to read Sunnah for the deeds of Muhammad during which he received the messages (the second primary source). It's only there that you'd find the beheadings and stonings by Muhammad. Just like "the New testament" isn't just one of the gospels, but the four gospels and all the other books, including the Apocalypse of John and all the epistles. Sunnah are also searchable online.
- 7952 11y agoHumans have a natural propensity for violence. Would you suggest that other base instincts (such as lust) are just because of some outside influence? Because that is exactly what religion believes and it is ridiculous. We need to deal with people as they are, the rationalisation (religion) comes after.
- muraiki 11y agoIn Orthodox Christian theology, the harrowing of Hades occurs immediately after the Resurrection. In order to understand this event, we first have to understand what Hades is. For Jews that believed in an afterlife, many did not expect something that we would consider to be like Heaven or Hell. Rather, Hades was the destination of all those who died. Hades was, for lack of better words, a place of gloom, essentially a jail of all the dead. For those who lived good lives according to the Law, the best they could hope for was that they would find themselves in "the bosom of Abraham": close to the religious they loved, but certainly not something like Heaven. St. John the Baptist is also known as the Forerunner, the person who helped prepare the people for Jesus' message. He was the forerunner not only in life but also in death: he preached in Hades of the Messiah who, far from being a worldly conqueror, would truly liberate all humanity: He would liberate them from death and Hades. To cut a long story short, the Resurrection is the death knell of Hades. The jail which kept the dead prisoner was destroyed in taking upon the Sinless One, God Himself. And those who were liberated were those who received the message of St. John. It is of course not possible to know what form St. John's message took. It must have been something that even the dead could perform, though. And the dead, lacking life, do not really have anything to give. So I will -- perhaps unwisely -- hazard a guess that it might have taken this form: love and forgive your enemies.
- hackuser 11y agoI'm not sure what your intent is, but it reads like essentially what the grandparent described: > Christians start saying that those bits don't count, or those bits have been misinterpreted, or that you need to read that other bit as well.
- muraiki 11y agoThat person asked for someone to "Please explain the harrowing of hell". I tried to explain a view that is held by a large number of Christians and which has precedence in the early church; this is important in this instance because there is only a single verse in the New Testament about the harrowing of Hades, and it gives very few details. Thus, most of what we have is the tradition taught by the Church. When it comes to the diverse views among Christians, here are two things to consider: 1) St. Paul in the NT says "hold fast to the traditions you have been taught, whether by word or by letter." This indicates, along with historical evidence, that a substantial body of Christian teaching lies _outside_ of the written documents of the New Testament. In as much as some people try to use "the Bible alone," we can see that this results in a tremendous amount of conflicting teachings. It's of note that the New Testament did not even exist in a definitive compiled form until a few hundred years into the history of the Christian Church. 2) Ultimately, for Christians the Word of God is a person, not a book. The God-man Christ did not issue a new set of laws, but took on flesh and taught by example how to live. The Christian is concerned with understanding this Person, and people are much more difficult to describe than laws. So for the Christian, while the Bible is of course an important guide, it does not represent the totality of Christian teaching. And since this teaching is about a Person, and especially a Person who does not simply say "do X in Y situation," we can come across some conflicting views. It is the goal of the Church in every generation to help the people of God to know Christ given the unique circumstances of each generation, without veering off into craziness that jeopardizes their love of God and neighbor. Ultimately it is up to the individual priest or bishop to exercise the right balance between akriveia (precision) and economia (house building) in each particular situation. For the priest it is more about the daily lives of parishioners, and for bishops about the actual teaching of the Church. Anyways, this is starting to turn into an essay, and for that I apologize. But it is necessary to understand the details of the things we are talking about if we are to really talk about them. I do not say this to offend you, but out of recognition that many here are probably unacquainted with or have sadly had bad experiences with religion. To the degree that I can use my background in religious studies and my experience across various religions to help explain things, I am trying to do so.
- ern 11y agoThe Koran is ambiguous, as is the Bible, and the US Constitution. Indeed any meaningful statute passed by a legislature has some measure of ambiguity. Reconciling these ambiguities by means of textual interpretation is a large part of the reason why there are theologians, rabbis, muftis and Supreme Court justices. Based on what I've read, in the case of Islam there has been a huge amount of exegeses and there are complex rules of interpretation that govern the meaning of texts. Trying to CTRL-F a translation of the Koran for "slay" as someone suggested elsewhere is a bizarre way to try to figure out the meaning of a text which has been pored over by great minds for centuries. I think it is a result of the fact that those of us with technical backgrounds tend to be dismissive of the humanities, uncomfortable with ambiguity and prone to literalism.[1] The interesting thing is that discarding exegesis is exactly the approach taken by the Salafist/Wahabist tradition of the Saudis, and of ISIS and Al-Qaeda. 1400 years of scholarship is replaced with a literal textualist reading of the Koran and Hadiths, and thus justification is found for the most henious of crimes. There is a Latin phrase that describes this approach of discarding precedent entirety in favor of novel readings of a text, but it escapes me for now. The Koran, or the Bible are not "violent" books not are they "peaceful", they are merely collections of words that need to be interpreted by their readers. It is unfortunate that the intellectually bankrupt literalist interpretation of the Koran is on the ascendant in the Middle East because of Saudi oil money, and that it presently lends itself to the justification of terrorism (even if the Saudi regime itself opposes terrorism). [1] This could be a reason why terrorist jihadism, buttressed by literalist readings attracts a disproportionate number of engineering types.
- azernik 11y agoAnd especially when referring to the Jewish and Christian Bibles, neither is a "book" in hr unified sense; both are collections of writings, originally created by different people with different agendas and beliefs hundreds of years apart from each other. Asking "what the Bible says" is a literally meaningless question
- acqq 11y ago> The Koran, or the Bible are not "violent" books not are they "peaceful" The Koran is directly violent and intolerant. It contains direct instructions that are such. The Sunnah describes the violent actions of the violent person claiming to be prophet of the god (which was invented earlier) and his followers. The Old Testament describes the actions of the violent god (an invented being by his believers) and his believers trying to win and control the Canaan territories. The New Testament describes the violent action of authorities who try to keep the order by crucifying the person claiming to be the prophet that brings the end of the world, then contains a lot of briefs of his followers and then one apocalyptic vision. And not a single one of these texts holds any scientific truth. All are based on myths and superstition. At the time of the "last revelations" already 800 years passed since Greeks measured the circumference of Earth, the size and distance of Moon and the size and distance of Sun. But the supposed god of the supposed prophet instead spends the energy to leave the message that the uncle of the supposed prophet will burn in hell. He cares about the priorities, you see. In the Old Testament the god actually comes through the house door to his favorite believer and shares a meal with him. Or strolls through the garden. You know, gods have to eat too. Oh, and god also has rest for one day after making the whole world in six. Read them all and compare.