6 ms·
The Men Who Live Forever
- siculars 17y agoThe Tarahumara of Mexico have been getting a lot of play recently specifically because of a book called Born to Run, by Christopher McDougall (http://www.amazon.com/Born-Run-Hidden-Superathletes-Greatest/dp/0307266303 http://www.amazon.com/Born-Run-Hidden-Superathletes-Greatest...). The Tarahumara people have been known in the elite runner/super athlete circles for a few decades yet but it seems that since the book came out everyone has been searching for their own experience with them. They are also somewhat responsible for the recent barefoot running phenomenon.
- alnayyir 17y agoI was wondering what started this particular health fad. Given that there's some legitimate cultural anecdote and biological history behind it, maybe it'll actually work.
- oliveoil 17y agoI think this was the original barefoot post on hacker news: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/moslive/article-1170253/The-painful-truth-trainers-Are-expensive-running-shoes-waste-money.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/moslive/article-1170253/The-...
- nod 17y agoThis article IS that book -- I just finished reading it. This article is ripped word-for-word from several sections of that book, with a little stitching together. It's an entertaining book, if a bit rambling.
- shin_lao 17y agoIt's pretty obvious we are doing things backward. We eat crap and compensate with synthetic vitamins. We exercise little and compensate with few hours per week on a machine. Since I've reduced - not suppressed - meat and sugar, walk one hour a day, and spend time contemplating I've witnessed significant improvement of my well being.
- vixen99 17y agoIf you want some peer-reviewed background on why it's smart to cut out sugar and the foods to which it's added by manufacturers, do take a look at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM This is one of the best nutritional videos I've ever seen. There's a chunk of biochemistry in the middle but it's worth watching to the end! Don't miss it and add years to your life.
- cwan 17y agoI'd also add this one by Gary Taubes doing a lecture at the Stevens Institute of Technology "Big Fat Lies": http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=4362041487661765149# http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=4362041487661765149#
- cwb 17y agoA bit wordy I think. Summary: Run (with low-padding shoes). Eat better.
- gursikh 17y agoi found the narrative essential to the information he was conveying. it was a story of evolution rather than a fact sheet.
- arnorhs 17y agoa fact sheet would have been more interesting to read
- verisimilitude 17y agoI disagree -- and I'm troubled that people seem to assert that just because you can say something quickly, means you should be compelled to pare down your ideas into CliffsNotes. The readers lose out on the richness of the ideas being conveyed. Sometimes novels should've been essays. Why must essays always become tweets?
- bh23ha 17y agoIt's not that essays should be tweets, it's that I and a lot of other people here prefer a particular style of writing. Think of "Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!", a fact heavy almost detail free style. But most people prefer a longer story based style and I suspect most people on HN today are of that type.
- joubert 17y agoIn yesterday's NYT: Vigor Quest http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/17/magazine/17antiaging-t.html?ref=magazine http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/17/magazine/17antiaging-t.htm...
- bootload 17y ago"... But none of that wisdom has prepared me for this. Eric warned me that running low on water during a 12-hour run in 85° heat would be crucial, and now, with my pee the color of convenience-store coffee, I know I'm too dehydrated to finish. ..." Not very bright. Dehydration means approx. 10% loss of performance and potential for damage. Isotonics work well in this situation. But 12 hours of water. You cant carry it. It has to be a refill about every 2Hrs.
- mark_l_watson 17y agoNot a good article. I have been around the Tarahumara. The women are friendly but very shy, the men are not to be seen when outsiders are around. My guide told me that they have a 50% infant mortality. However, their history is very cool: when the Spaniards were enslaving everyone they could catch in northern Mexico for a short and harsh life in silver mines, the Tarahumara did not like what they saw, and headed for remote areas.
- bd 17y ago"My guide told me that they have a 50% infant mortality." This would explain "the secret of longevity and perpetual health" - quite literal survivorship bias.
- gursikh 17y agoA survivorship bias would not explain the effects of the diet and exercise regimen on the author, a seemingly average American male of Irish-Italian descent.
- bd 17y agoThis is orthogonal. One guy getting in a better shape after diet and exercise is quite expected. Whole society being virtually free of big bad diseases is, on the other hand, extraordinary claim: "When it comes to the top 10 health risks facing American men, the Tarahumara are practically immortal: Their incidence rate is at or near zero in just about every category, including diabetes, vascular disease, and colorectal cancer." This sounds quite dishonest if what mark_l_watson said indeed holds. You could then equally say: "When it comes to #1 health risk facing Tarahumara men, Americans are practically immortal: almost all their babies survive."
- gursikh 17y agoA man being able to run a super-marathon through a desert within months of switching to their diet and exercise regimen is hardly orthogonal. =)
- thisisnotmyname 17y agoWas that journalism or an ad for Nike shoes?
- gregwebs 17y agoWhy does this article have that title and then give no discussion on that point? The whole concept is pretty ridiculous that they have discovered this healthy people that must be healthy because they eat corn and run marathons. All indigenous people were relatively free of diseases of civilization pre-contact (which basically includes all of our medical problems) and would appear remarkably healthy if they survived to old age. This is about the only culture that runs marathons.