5 ms·
The swing was in the photos on the AirBnB listing. When you make money from your property, using the swing in your adverts, you either need to make sure it's n
by DanBC 11y ago
The swing was in the photos on the AirBnB listing.
When you make money from your property, using the swing in your adverts, you either need to make sure it's not going to kill people doing normal things (swinging on the swing is normal; getting 8 drunk people to swing on the swing would be abnormal) or you need to put big disclaimers up.
And depending where you are disclaimers might not be enough.
When you invite the public onto your property for a fee you probably need to make sure your public liability insurance is paid up. You can't make anything totally safe, but you need to make an effort to minimise the hazards.
- jacquesm 11y agoLiability insurance won't save your life if you get hit by a few hundred pounds of tree. It will just move money around. If you want to use an old tree-swing the onus is on you, the user to make sure that it is safe because if it isn't you pay the price. Somebody else might have installed that swing for a bunch of kids weighing 45 pounds and they used it for years without a problem. Then some full grown adult comes along and the branch breaks, either because the rope has scoured the bark enough that it started to rot or simply because it is overloaded. Trees are natural items, not engineered, ridiculously strong, most of the times and unpredictable when it comes to failure modes. Even perfectly healthy trees can lose branches. Sometimes accidents are just that: accidents. What could the owner have done to ensure that this did not happen? For all we know he tried the swing himself the day before and it was fine. At least at the time of making the advert it was still fine and short of 'destructive testing' to figure out how much load it supports there is no way to know what it will handle except for trying to see if it supports your weight.
- joosters 11y agoIndirectly, in a general sense, it does. The effect of liability insurance can be to push premiums higher for facilities that aren't robustly checked. If (say) a hotel chain had lots of playgrounds that weren't properly maintained, their insurer might decide to charge higher rates or even refuse coverage. This may well incentivize the hotel to improve their maintenance.
- maxerickson 11y agoI expect the insurance company that paid the settlement did bother to check if a reasonable test of the swing had been done.
- gozo 11y agoAs far as I remember from the original article the tree had been dead for two years. Not sure if the host knew that or not though.
- jacquesm 11y agoDead trees are called widowmakers for a reason and even cutting one down is an extremely risky operation.
- cowsandmilk 11y agouh... so? That just means it is even more the owner's responsibility to bring out someone to cut down the dead tree.
- vacri 11y ago> What could the owner have done to ensure that this did not happen? Remove the swing? If you have the foresight to say that the swing is so dangerous, then why not the person who actually owns the thing?
- jacquesm 11y agoI don't think anybody involved had the foresight to say that that particular swing was dangerous if they had they no doubt would have taken it down. But swings are dangerous, and users of swings should be aware of that. The very same thing could have happened to the owner of the house.
- DanBC 11y agoThere are swings at my local park. They were designed by competent engineers. They were installed by competent builders. They're regularly maintained. The council (who own and operate the park) have insurance. I am aware that there's some risk involved in swings - don't walk in front of one when it's being used, don't use it when I'm drunk, don't do handstands on it, but I also know that using it normally is pretty safe.
- jacquesm 11y agoThe swings in that park are indeed probably normally safe. Swings installed by homeowners are usually held to a different standard and tree swings should be considered dangerous until personally inspected before use.
- jusben1369 11y agoNot have a tree swing on an old tree and advertise it? The owner bares the burden of ensuring their service is safe - not the user. Try and imagine a world where that's the opposite as you're proposing.
- jacquesm 11y agoI live in that world. The responsibility for my life is mine and if I climb on some who-knows-how-old treeswing in some rustic cottage tied to an old tree without any leaves on it then you can be damn sure I'll check to see if it is solid before I trust my own weight to it and I'll check it myself before I let my kids play with it. Because money from some settlement won't give me back my life or my children and because trees have been known to break every now and then even when not burdened with tree swings carrying adults and even when they're healthy and not dead like this particular tree. It all boils down to personal responsibility and if you let that go then accidents can happen. This is not the brakes of your car services by some competent mechanic in which case I can easily see a liability issue but in the case of old stuff hanging from trees different rules apply. For that matter, when visiting a friend who has two young children and a nice swing in their garden I spent the better part of a day re-inforcing the swing and its foundation because I thought the whole thing was an accident waiting to happen.
- iand 11y agoI actually support your view but to play the other side of the argument for a bit: what you are suggesting is that the customer has to be an expert in tree health before they use a facility provided by the host. Do they also have to be an electrician before they trust the cooker wont electrocute them; or a heating expert to check the service condition of a heater so it doesn't leak CO and kill them in their sleep?
- jacquesm 11y agoElectricity in a house is (usually!) installed by licensed electricians and inspected after installation, ditto gas and heating devices. If you stay in someone else's apartment and it does not have a CO alarm and a stove that may or may not vent into the apartment then you should at a minimum sleep with a window open. Tree-swings are not usually installed by licensed engineers, they are typically installed by people with a tree with a suitable profile, a rope and an old tire, any of which may fail at unpredictable times, but most likely when being used (and even more likely: when being used by an adult).
- Alex3917 11y ago> What could the owner have done to ensure that this did not happen? You can do a simple impedance test on the tree. If the tree had rot then electricity will go through the core faster due to additional water content. And they give you a nice graph to prove whether the tree is safe or dangerous.
- jacquesm 11y agoI don't think that handy bit of knowledge has made it into the 'how to make a tree swing' manual yet but it really ought to. Also should be in 'proper care of your tree swing' over the years and the periodic inspection.
- Alex3917 11y agoIt's already pretty common knowledge for tree care in general, there's nothing specific about this for swings. Already ever major town or city around the country has an arborist or team of arborists to make sure trees don't randomly fall on people and kill them, and the way they do that is by using either this test or else just manually coring the tree by cutting out a tiny section to check for rot. If you as an individual want to own trees, and especially if you want to let others use your property, I don't see any reason why you should be held to a lesser standard of care than any municipality across the country. If you can't afford to keep your trees safe then you can't afford the trees and/or the property. But yeah, this definitely isn't anything beyond what you'd learn in a plant pathology 101 class in college or a basic arborist certification.
- muzmath 11y agoThese are pretty high standards for the coveted position of tree ownership.
- in_cahoots 11y agoHave you ever owned or lived in a home with trees? Ensuring that your trees are healthy is pretty standard for homeownership. Otherwise sooner or later you'll have to deal with a fallen limb on your (or your neighbor's) house or car. It's a lot easier to sleep in the middle of a snowstorm knowing that the tree overlooking your bedroom isn't going anywhere.
- amorphid 11y agoIf there were a tree swing at a hotel, and someone died in the process of using said swing, I would expect that to be a legitimate liability.
- jacquesm 11y ago> Liability insurance protects you from this kind of thing. No, liability insurance moves money from the insurance company to the next of kin of the person who died from having a chunk of tree crack their head open like it was an egg. It does not protect you from this sort of thing.
- maxerickson 11y agoUh, it does protect the owner of the property from this sort of thing (this is the perspective the article is written from, at the end encouraging those listing properties on AirBnB and the like to carry their own commercial liability policy). Is anybody actually arguing that a property being covered by liability insurance makes the property safer? I suppose that is the case in more commercial/industrial settings where the insurance company has a list of requirements on the policy. Change the scenario. Is it reasonable for the renter to assume that the floorboards in the building are sound? This really only differs in degree from that.
- jacquesm 11y agoThese and many other considerations like it are the reason why I stay in hotels and with people that I trust rather than in AirBNB places. I also tend to make sure there are at least two ways out of whatever place I sleep in but this is a thing that is related to one of my grandmothers dying in a fire and probably irrational.
- iends 11y agoDo you also check for fire and CO2 monitors? That's one of my biggest fears when using AirBNB because I don't know the surroundings / neighbors.
- DanBC 11y ago> Liability insurance won't save your life if you get hit by a few hundred pounds of tree. It will give my family the money they need to bury me. It will give my dependents a bit of the money I would have given them across the rest of my life. > If you want to use an old tree-swing the onus is on you, the user to make sure that it is safe because if it isn't you pay the price. Not if someone has charged me for access to the swing. It's the commercial activity that has caused the extra attention here.
- DannyBee 11y ago"What could the owner have done to ensure that this did not happen? For all we know he tried the swing himself the day before and it was fine. At least at the time of making the advert it was still fine and short of 'destructive testing' to figure out how much load it supports there is no way to know what it will handle except for trying to see if it supports your weight." This falls into the area of "jury argument" ;-) However, i will point out "if you can't figure out whether it's safe, you generally have a duty to remove it or warn people it's possibly not safe". (Whether i like the law or thing it just generates tons of warning labels, that is the law).
- jacquesm 11y agoIf I try the swing today and it is safe (with my weight, and with my use of the swing) trying my hardest to see if it will break and it does not, then the next day you come by and you sit on it and it breaks am I liable? Should I have judged my test as 'inability to figure out if it was safe'? Nothing short of a destructive test will tell you exactly what load a swing like this will support, but common sense will tell you to be careful with tree swings regardless of whether or not someone tells you that it is safe. It's a non-engineered project probably made on a budget (even though in this particular case the tree swing had chains rather than rope so it was constructed fairly well) and it ended up being the tree trunk that snapped rather than the branch the chains were attached to.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jmilloy 11y ago> It's a tragic accident, I don't see much in terms of liability. > Liability insurance won't save your life if you get hit by a few hundred pounds of tree. It will just move money around. By this argument you seem to be claiming that there's no liability in cases where people die. Just because you could have stayed alive by not doing something doesn't mean there is automatically no liability. Obviously we agree that it would be better to not sing and be alive than to swing, die, and get a payout. I'm also not sure whether there is liability here legally, or even whether I think morally there was reasonable expectation that the swing was safe. But surely the question of liability doesn't factor in whether or not the payout brings someone back to life, and this part of your comment obscures your point a bit.
- jacquesm 11y ago> By this argument you seem to be claiming that there's no liability in cases where people die. No, that's not what I'm claiming. There are many cases in which there is clear liability when people die.
- jmilloy 11y agoSure, but what you've written suggests the opposite, so it was weird.
- rwmj 11y agoIn the UK you have a duty of care even if your visitors aren't paying. And even if you didn't invite them (eg. trespassers). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupiers'_Liability_Act_1957 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupiers'_Liability_Act_1957