11 ms·
One of many reasons I find it amazing that applications ask for permission to the microphone when they don't have a good reason. The latest Netflix update on A
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
One of many reasons I find it amazing that applications ask for permission to the microphone when they don't have a good reason.
The latest Netflix update on Android asks for microphone permissions, saying that in the future they'll offer a way to call Netflix support from within the app. No, that's not a good reason; I have a phone for that. I've specifically avoided that upgrade; I'm hoping that my Nexus gets the upgrade to M before then, so that I can upgrade Netflix but deny it access to the microphone.
- danepowell 11y agoThis is why on-demand permissions are one of the best features of Android 6.0. Don't want Netflix to access your microphone? No problem--don't let it.
- tgb 11y agoDoes it also allow a "popup request for each use" option? Seems like the right option for the Netflix hotline support feature.
- aiiane 11y agoNo, but you can go into the phone settings and re-enable a permission for an app if you change your mind.
- pki 11y agoAren't privacyguard's actions Ask / Never / Always?
- andrewaylett 11y agoMost of them, yes. There are a couple that are just on/off, like wake locks.
- maccard 11y agoAnd remember. iOS has had this since its inception
- rogerbinns 11y agoBlackBerry had it too. There was a tree of permissions (broad categories at the top, specifics in the leaves) and you could set permissions to deny, allow or ask each time.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoNo, it didn't. iOS originally gave apps access to just about everything except background execution without any warning. At the time Android had the superior permissions model, with each app telling you what it needed at install and you being in control of whether or not you wanted to install it with that information. Older iOS apps had access to your photos, your contacts, and other stuff and could use it with no warning to you. As a result of early privacy breaches, later releases of iOS added per-function permissions on demand, leap-frogging Android in terms of permissions functionality. Android has had some level of per-function permissions on demand in the works since Android 4.4 -- and you could use it in unofficial Android builds like CyanogenMod by turning off individual permissions for apps -- but the feature only finally made it into official builds in Android 6.0. It also got it properly in the API and manifest of apps as well so they can ask permissions as they need them... like the Facebook app needing access to your photos when you select to attach a photo to a post.
- threeseed 11y agoApple started adding location services permissions 5 years ago. Android 6.0 has only just been released. Whichever way you look at it it's pretty unacceptable that it's taken so long for Android to implement this.
- yareally 11y ago> "Apple started adding location services permissions 5 years ago. Android 6.0 has only just been released". Location permissions have been in Android since the version 1.0 of the API. http://developer.android.com/reference/android/Manifest.permission.html#ACCESS_FINE_LOCATION http://developer.android.com/reference/android/Manifest.perm...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lucb1e 11y agoGot this via Cyanogenmod already on 4.4 and I use it all the time. Not just for permissions by the way, Privacy Guard can also prevent wake locks and auto start permissions. That's a serious battery life saver.
- barbs 11y agoThanks for this, I didn't realise you could do this in CM. You can also check when the permissions were being used. For the Netflix app I noticed the "record audio" permission had never been used, but I've set it to explicitly ask me if it tries to use it.
- kachnuv_ocasek 11y agoI use this extensively myself, but the one problem that I'm facing is that it makes some applications unstable. Usually, I just uninstall them as I'd rather sacrifice my comfort than my security and privacy.
- modeless 11y agoAndroid 6.0 does those things for you too. (Doze and App Standby)
- conceit 11y agosounds like cm is used as a testing channel for new features.
- eklavya 11y agoI used to believe that and installed CM 12.1 on my phone only to find out that the restrictions don't really work. Whatsapp was able to read my messages (automatic phone verify) when I had disabled the access. Digging around I found out this is the case even with XPrivacy (there are open issues on github) which is supposed to be more extensive. There are some situations when the blocks aren't enforced at all (like some native calls). I got a nexus 5x, android 6 permissions feature actually works.
- digi_owl 11y agoJust sad that Google has lumped the permissions into categories, and also put a bunch of them into "safe". Yeah yeah, clueless aunt Tillie will flip something and complain that its broken. But persisting this way means that you (Google and anyone agreeing with their stance) are breeding whole generations of Tillies.
- gedrap 11y agoFirefoxOS (I was using v1.3, not sure about earlier or later versions) did the same, it was pretty neat. It's really nice that they are doing it from the very early days, not waiting for their app marketplace to become bigger.
- OJFord 11y ago> I've specifically avoided that upgrade; I'm hoping that > my Nexus gets the upgrade to M before then, so that I > can upgrade Netflix but deny it access to the > microphone. Weird - mine stopped working when the upgrade became available; until I reluctantly installed it.
- CountSessine 11y agoI wonder. If an Android app sticks to api level 22, then presumably they can continue demanding those permissions without having them denied, even on Android 6.0, no? There are already apps that let you re-write a side-loaded app's permissions, but that usually doesn't work very well. I tried re-writing Facebook's permissions and it aborts fairly quickly.
- dethstar 11y agoI guess it depends how they worked it in. Is it in the app permission requesting code? Then yeah, app would need to upgrade their api level. Is it on the OS level, and they'll do something like just give null/useless data when you deny the permisson? Then it wouldn't matter.
- CountSessine 11y agoThat's how cyanogen does it - empty address book, camera that always takes black pictures, etc. But I didn't think that Google would ever do that, and @T-A's link to howtogeek.com seems to confirm this. The app will fail on api calls that previously worked and you'll be stuck restoring the permissions.
- T-A 11y agohttp://www.howtogeek.com/230683/how-to-manage-app-permissions-on-android-6.0/ http://www.howtogeek.com/230683/how-to-manage-app-permission...
- CountSessine 11y agoWhen revoking permissions from older applications, you’ll see a warning message saying, “This app was designed for an older version of Android. Denying permission may cause it to no longer function as intended." Older applications weren’t designed for this feature, and they generally just assume they have access to any permissions they request. Most of the time, applications should just continue working normally if you revoke their permissions. In some rare cases, the application may crash — if it does, you’ll need to give it permission again. So yeah, if Facebook decides to stick to api level 22 for a while, you won't be able to un-privilege it.
- raverbashing 11y agoYeah, coarse-grained permissions are complicated Sometimes they need it for only one feature. But in this case it could ask for permission for only a specific task, but since this functionality is not present (I think IOS allows on-demand permissions) it must be asked "for ever"
- Johnny555 11y agoHaving to call or chat support is the worst thing about Netflix support, most of the time I don't want to talk with someone on the phone about my problem and resolve it in realtime, I just want to send them an email, explain the issue, and then they can email me back in 24 hours. I haven't tried their Chat support, but I assume it's like all of the other chat services where agents handle many customers at a time so it takes forever for each response back.
- joshribakoff 11y agoI tried their chat support, they were very outgoing, personable & solved my problem almost immediately. If they were helping other people at the same time, I certainly didn't notice.
- CamperBob2 11y agoThe latest Netflix update on Android asks for microphone permissions, saying that in the future they'll offer a way to call Netflix support from within the app. Seriously? Because that kind of overt lie would cross the line into outright evil. "Call Netflix support?" Really? How stupid would someone have to be to buy that?
- gene-h 11y agoSo can you prevent javascript in the browser from accessing android sensors without permission now?
- blazespin 11y agoHmm I wonder if there is a way to test if netflix is using the technology. Maybe play the audio sound and check the processor usage or connect to the process and track the syscalls.
- bhauer 11y agoWindows 10 (desktop, tablet, mobile, all flavors) needs fine-grained permissions that can be granted and revoked in a similar manner. Even traditional desktop apps need to have similar sandboxing features.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoBut on Windows, stuff like the "Install->Next->Next->Next->Next->I agree->Next->Waaait for it->Next->Finish" dance has conditioned everyone but the security zealots to click "Yes" without even reading the dialog box. I've seen people with twitch-gamer like reflexes for accepting Windows prompts.
- Kiro 11y agoJust because you allow microphone access does it really mean they can listen to it without you being aware?
- SeanDav 11y agoYes - exactly that.