4 ms·
First, the reason to be concerned about civil forfeiture is well stated at http://uclawreview.org/2014/04/29/criminal-forfeiture-is-taking-the-just-out-of-justi
by btilly 11y ago
First, the reason to be concerned about civil forfeiture is well stated at http://uclawreview.org/2014/04/29/criminal-forfeiture-is-taking-the-just-out-of-justice-kaley-v-united-states/ http://uclawreview.org/2014/04/29/criminal-forfeiture-is-tak.... The problem is that we introduced it for a specific purpose, and over time the laws have been used expansively and creatively against an ever growing category of people and businesses many of which bear no obvious relationship to organized crime.
I believe that this long ago crossed the line to being actually used as civil rights abuse.
On this case, you're mostly right. The seizure happened under civil forfeiture law, a the second paragraph of The Economist article makes that clear. So this really is a question about civil forfeiture law. But it is tied to a potential criminal civil forfeiture.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The seizure happened under civil forfeiture law, a the second paragraph of The Economist article makes that clear. The initial seizure happened because property was targetted for civil forfeiture, the expanded seizure happened because property was targetted for criminal forfeiture, the request for a pre-trial hearing (which was denied leading to the series of appeals that ultimately reached the Supreme Court) was for a challenge to the criminal forfeiture action. The question addressed in the Supreme Court case was about criminal, not civil forfeiture.