2 ms·
Ask HN: Should we assume “free” apps that are closed source have a catch?
There's a lot of really cool tools out there, and I've noticed many of them for Windows are still closed source, even if the publisher seems to have no business, no advertising, or apparent monetization model in mind. I think for Windows programs, that's mostly because open source isn't often assumed to be a goal.
I use NirSoft's tools from time to time, and I think a lot of people seem to agree they're pretty reputable. But a lot of times when I see a post for a new tool that's free, but not apparently open source, my instinct is to wonder if there's a catch.
A networking or system management tool that isn't open source could potentially be mining the network information I input and sending it elsewhere. I don't know if there's any significant number of common cases where that's ever been found in previously assumed to be decent tools.
Should we assume free tools with no ads have a catch if they aren't open source?