5 ms·
I'm shocked by the amount of anti-China bias on HN. Consider a few points: - The conditions inside US prisons (daily, predictable rape, etc.) rival those in a
by grandalf 17y ago
I'm shocked by the amount of anti-China bias on HN.
Consider a few points:
- The conditions inside US prisons (daily, predictable rape, etc.) rival those in any labor camp anywhere in the world.
- Many US prisoners are nonviolent drug offenders.
- Don't forget the human rights abuses in Abu Ghraib and Gitmo and the hundreds of thousands of innocents killed in our oil wars.
- China's main social issue is rich coastal cities and extremely poor inland areas. This geographical accident is behind many economic policies. The US is lucky to have rivers that tend to lead to a far more even distribution of wealth across geographical areas.
- In its early days the US embraced mercantilism. It has particular political causes and over all countries who practice it lose more than they gain from it, but the tradeof is considered worthwhile for political reasons in spite of its foolishness. In China's case, it represents a way to grow the Chinese economy while not risking social stability (which is considered highly important considering the above bullet).
- The US was also formerly a thief of intellectual property. Notably, many writers and publishing houses in England were irate that presses in the colonies paid no royalties, etc., a situation made worse after the American revolution.
- Massive sectors of the US economy are under significant government control, even before the bailouts. It's splitting hairs to bemoan China's "communism".
- The average person in China does not care about all the political nonsense that we are being propagandized to stew over. Most people all over the world just want to be able to lead a reasonably happy life, etc. China surely has some "backward" aspects, but consider that we did not have women's suffrage in the US until quite recently, and that we had a draft until VERY recently. Suppose China is 100 years behind, is that the end of the world? Do we really deserve to feel such righteous indignation?
- poutine 17y agoI would like to clarify that at least personally I'm anti Chinese government and not anti China or the Chinese people. I love the country for many reasons and don't fundamentally wish it harm. When someone points out something bad about a country it's silly to say they can't say that because there's bad things about their own country. There's bad things about every country, it doesn't make them beyond criticism. And that sir is why you get my downvote.
- PieSquared 17y agoYou make a good distinction, I agree (between government and country). Also, I think he doesn't deserve that downvote. He contributed his own thoughts, which were in no way rude or trollish, and seemed more or less educated. They also sparked a bit of interesting discussion. Anyway, my upvote balanced it out. ;)
- grandalf 17y agoUpvote appreciated. I find it sad how readily so many in the US jump on board criticizing foreign governments... it's as if we're all reading some sort of George W. Bush Patriotism manual.
- grandalf 17y agoI think the problem with your stance is that you don't give the Chinese people credit for their own sovereignty. Why is it not possible that Chinese leaders are not all-powerful despots who rule with an iron fist? They do not have absolute power, and regardless of whether they have official democracy, power is largely decentralized and influenced by populist needs (notably channeling some of the coastal wealth to the country's majority who are extremely poor)... You are, I think, falling into what I call the "Saddam Trap". Saddam was a bad guy, most likely, but we were all told to hate him so that we'd support a war that killed hundreds of thousands of innocents. I think a far more accurate and rational perspective is to realize that no ruler has fully centralized power and that by its nature decentralized power is essentially populist (if not somewhat democratic) in nature, even if there isn't an explicit constitution declaring it to be. The Tienanmen square uprising offers evidence of vibrant currents of dissent within China, and so change is inevitable over time. The question is why you think it must happen on your timetable or on the timetable of the Tienanmen protesters. * * * * Also, are you sure that the propaganda is not intended to make Americans view the Chinese people as broken saps held hostage by despots and worth sacrificing a few hundred thousand of should our leaders deem military action necessary? For all the concern about Saddam's despotism, the myriad innocent Iraqi dead from our oil war don't make US headlines.
- 17y ago
- PieSquared 17y agoYou're criticizing US past, mostly. That's key: it's the past. No one is criticizing foot binding here. If you want to provide examples of the US being immoral, make them current. Now, I have no doubt there are dozens of examples. On the other hand, at least US laws allow the rest of the world to know about these examples when they happen. And yes, if China is 100 years behind, it may be a significant. Is there any reason that the suppression present should be endured? The more pressure is put on China and other countries that devalue human rights, the sooner they'll have to change. Personally, I would love to see more indignation at the United States as well. Some of the stuff going on with this country is just plain unacceptable for a first world country.
- cglee 17y agoIndignation is precisely how NOT to engage China. The political culture is very different from the US. Leaders want face and respect above all - there are no Jon Stewart type shows poking fun at any political bosses. You want China to change - it is, at its fastest pace in its long history. You want China to improve its human rights record - it is, just not as fast as you'd like. The right course of action - FOR CHINA - is through incentives that make the leadership look good. Another way to put it is, everyone learns differently. You don't publicly scold a sensitive child and think that is going to be effective. China is that sensitive child (at least relative to the in-your-face ways of US politics).
- plinkplonk 17y ago"You want China to improve its human rights record - it is, just not as fast as you'd like. " Evidence please?
- cglee 17y agoI could go Google something, but it'd be easier and more entertaining if you came over and had dinner with my folks, who grew up in the Cultural Revolution era. Or my grandparents, who lived through famines and saw the transmformation from the Dynastic era to a Republic. Don't forget, China has a LONG history.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- zaphar 17y agoChina isn't just 100 years behind they are going backwards. China has a civilization going back 1000's of years. It's the comparatively recent changes in government for their country that have caused the ruin you see now. The conditions inside US prisons (daily, predictable rape, etc.) rival those in any labor camp anywhere in the world. Those in US prisons for the most part all did something harmful to society that caused them to be put there. In China you get sent to prison for bad-mouthing the wrong person. I personally know people who have experienced this. And it's the norm not the exception. The comparison you make only demonstrates how truly different it is. China's main social issue is rich coastal cities and extremely poor inland areas. This geographical accident is behind many economic policies. The US is lucky to have rivers that tend to lead to a far more even distribution of wealth across geographical areas. The inland areas aren't poor because of geography. They are poor because it suits the government for them to be so. Do we really deserve to feel such righteous indignation? yes
- grandalf 17y agoChina believes that it imprisons people who are doing things that are harmful to its society. How is selling someone Marijuana harming society? I think your conspiracy theory about China's poor regions is fairly off the wall. Look at the mountains and rivers and see how there are not good shipping routes, etc.
- zaphar 17y agoChina believes that it imprisons people who are doing things that are harmful to its society. That's an assumption. Their actions seem to indicate it is far less about harm to society and more to do with harm to Governments "status quo". I think your conspiracy theory about China's poor regions is fairly off the wall. Look at the mountains and rivers and see how there are not good shipping routes, etc. None of those things are insurmountable. And China has not been attempting to surmount them. Thus my point.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"I'm shocked by the amount of anti-China bias on HN" I think any bias that exists is not so much anti China as anti authoritarianism, anti-democracy, anti-suppression-of-freedom-of-speech, anti-bunch-of-thugs-killing-people-for-having-a-different-opinion etc. I doubt it is really China specific. It is just that the present Chinese government is a nasty ruthless authoritarian dictatorship. The same arguments would be raised here against, say North Korea or Saudi Arabia in other circumstances. People here seemed to be biased towards democracy, rule of law(even with occasional lapses), freedom of expression(even with an occasional lapse or imperfection) etc etc. Not sure it is a bad bias to have.
- grandalf 17y agoYou are right in the sense that one would hope that citizens of the US who live in a relatively free state would appreciate the concepts that we claim to hold above all else. However, the question I have it "what should we do about it?". Should we impose trade sanctions? (surely the US tire lobby would appreciate that). Should we begin flying drones over Beijing? (surely our defense lobby would appreciate that), should we engage the CIA to help Chinese dissidents bribe/assassinate Chinese officials who oppose democratic reforms? Should we send warships to wait near Taiwan? All the ire must be directed into action if there is any purpose to it other than self-congratulatory "we're so great b/c we don't use tanks to shut down civilian protests, at least since the 1960s"... What range of actions are you comfortable with? Which of them truly promote the interest of democracy and freedom in China, and which serve a more narrow or militaristic interest? China is full of enlightened people who see the direction they wish China to go over time. Do they all want to become martyrs and die in some coup attempt engineered by the CIA? Or would they rather make a few sacrifices and do what they can to nudge their country toward change? I think it's awfully arrogant for anyone in the US to attempt to engineer revolutions and suffering abroad. The sort of self-righteous moral high ground that China bashers use is essentially neoconservative ideology. Yet we are told it's about human rights. Wake up!
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]