5 ms·
Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTube videos
- protomyth 17y agoI would assume this would mean that any internet startup in Italy might want to move. Who knows what other types of content will get hit.
- pavel_lishin 17y agoThe decree was also condemned by Articolo 21, an organization dedicated to the defense of freedom of speech as enshrined in article 21 of the Italian constitution. So what are the first 20 dedicated to?
- davidw 17y agoHave a look: http://www.senato.it/documenti/repository/istituzione/costituzione_inglese.pdf http://www.senato.it/documenti/repository/istituzione/costit...
- ugh 17y agoFundamental principles, other rights: http://www.senato.it/documenti/repository/istituzione/costituzione_inglese.pdf http://www.senato.it/documenti/repository/istituzione/costit... [pdf] The freedom of speech article is the ninth of the rights. A bit late as constitutions go (USA: first, Germany: fifth) but pretty consistent with many Europeans’ views on freedom of speech. In many European states free speech is not the same sort of fundamental right as it is in the US. Important, sure, but not quite as.
- eru 17y ago> The freedom of speech article is the ninth of the rights. A bit late as constitutions go (USA: first, Germany: fifth) but pretty consistent with many Europeans’ views on freedom of speech. In many European states free speech is not the same sort of fundamental right as it is in the US. Important, sure, but not quite as. In defense of Germany: In the US rights come as amendments. The German constitution starts out with the human (and civil) rights at the very beginning. (Yes, someone wanted to distance themself from the Nazis.)
- ugh 17y agoIt’s about the order of the fundamental rights, not so much where they are in the constitution. Well, considering that the US bill of rights is freaking 158 years older than the German constitution, it wins always, anyway. Never mind the order :) (Full disclaimer: I’m German and quite like our constitution. Just not so much when it comes to free speech. The article and how it’s been interpreted by the constitutional court is quite good, but I’m quite a fan of US style freedom of speech.)
- Zak 17y agoI've been told by Germans, none of whom were law enforcement or lawyers that calling someone an asshole or sticking up your middle finger is a finable offense. It's well known that publishing Nazi propaganda, denying the holocaust and the like are illegal. It seems to me that free speech is less than fundamental in Germany. The US has a less than perfect record on the issue as well, with obscenity laws and the like.
- jrockway 17y agoThe US has a less than perfect record on the issue as well, with obscenity laws and the like. To be fair, these laws have been consistently struck down by the Supreme Court. That doesn't stop the government from continually passing similar laws and prosecuting people, however: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_of_America_v._Extreme_Associates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_of_America_v._Ext... The real problem here is not with obscenity, though, but the concept of plea bargains. How many people will end up in prison because of unconstitutional laws before someone stands up against the oppressive regime?
- Zak 17y agoTo be fair, these laws have been consistently struck down by the Supreme Court. I wish that were completely true. Unfortunately, it's not quite the case: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test
- eru 17y ago> The freedom of speech article is the ninth of the rights. A bit late as constitutions go (USA: first, Germany: fifth) but pretty consistent with many Europeans’ views on freedom of speech. In many European states free speech is not the same sort of fundamental right as it is in the US. Important, sure, but not quite as. In defense of Germany: In the US rights come as amendments. The German constitution starts out with the human (and civil) rights at the very beginning. (Yes, someone wanted to distance themself from the Nazis.)
- fleitz 17y agoIf you want to get technical about the US constitution the constitution merely enumerates SOME of the rights that exist, it certainly does not grant them, the ones listed are simply not disputed (what the right entails certainly is). The US constitution should really be viewed more as enumerating the rights of the government, as all rights not explicitly granted FROM the people TO the US gov't vest with the states or the people. The Federal Gov't actually gets most of it's power in legal theory from a serious abuse of the interstate commerce clause. You'll notice that the US constitution doesn't actually grant a right of free speech, it prevents congress making laws abridging the freedom.
- ugh 17y agoWell. Yes it does. Sure it does. You may not share that opinion, but the way the court sees it counts, not the way you see it. A constitution is more than a piece of paper.
- eru 17y agoPlease pardon my double-post. The mobile broadband dongle gives a very spotty connection.
- davidw 17y agoThis article seems to be saying something slightly different: http://www.repubblica.it/tecnologia/2010/01/15/news/decreto_tv_google_e_i_provider_preoccupati_per_effetti_sul_web-1955476/ http://www.repubblica.it/tecnologia/2010/01/15/news/decreto_... Basically it makes video services like Youtube responsible for their contents, which is still bad, but is certainly not "individuals must apply to the government to upload videos". So I think it's either a bad translation or someone playing fast and loose with the actual facts in order to create some traffic.
- lssndrdn 17y agoThere's another article on Repubblica that describes the proposed decree in more detail. http://www.repubblica.it/tecnologia/2010/01/14/news/decreto_sulla_tv_la_denuncia_delle_opposizioni_giro_di_vite_su_internet_e_sul_cinema_indipendente-1947217/ http://www.repubblica.it/tecnologia/2010/01/14/news/decreto_... In the last paragraph, it says that the rules for tv broadcasting would be applied to websites that provide video (meaning they would be subject to governmental approval).
- davidw 17y agoYes, the websites would come under the authority of the government. That's plenty bad, but what the original article in English says is: > New rules to be introduced by government decree will require people who upload videos onto the Internet to obtain authorization
- crocowhile 17y agoThat is wrong. What this law says is that content providers are directly responsible for what users publish or upload. The reason to this decree is that one year ago Mediaset (Berlusconi's TV group) sued youtube for publishing a lot of copyrighted material and asked for 0.5 Billions ( see http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/italian_tv_company_mediaset_su.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/italian_tv_company_medi... or google "mediaset yotube"). If this new bill will pass (and it will) then youtube will be deemed responsible for copyright infringement. This has nothing to do with users asking for authorization.
- antirez 17y agoRephrase this as "Berlusconi government composed of stupid ministers" wants to officially apply ... As part of Italy really understand how stupid is this, and is just praying to see this unqualified junk to go away from our government. Also don't worry anyway as our laws are rarely applied. For instance we had for some time, a few years ago, a law that "forced" every web site owner to print the content in A4 paper and sent it to some government address. Not sure if I should smile or cry.
- aurora72 17y agoIn a satellite channel (broadcast in english by the Italian) I had once watched a program where it was reported that the chief cameraman in Italian parliament had a salary more than (or in a comparable level as) the Prime Minister! It was all demonstrated by the numbers and I was shocked. So when I heard the news that Italy wanted to put such an obstacle for the Internet, I'm not particularly surprised.
- acangiano 17y agoAnd this, ladies and gentlemen, is an example of why I left my country back in 2003.
- dotcoma 17y ago'Tis an unweeded garden, That Grows to seed; Things rank and gross in nature Possess it merely.
- zaatar 17y agoRelated news ... ? Some Italian guy posted a discriminatory video on Youtube Italy, four top Google Executives now have arrest warrants in Italy, and cannot be anywhere in the EU (due to reciprocal extradition treaties). The Head of Google Video Europe moved to Google UK to head Consumer Marketing in consequence, cannot travel anywhere within the EU at this time, and who knows for how much longer? References: [1] http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/02/02/google-executives-face-jail-time-for-italian-video/ http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/02/02/google-executives-f... [2] http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/17/technology/17google.html?_r=2 http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/17/technology/17google.html?_...
- ciupicri 17y agoUK is a member of the EU.
- electromagnetic 17y agoFor the UK it depends whether the warrant was EU-wide or just Italian. If it was Italian, they can get anyone in mainland Europe very easily. However, IIRC, this is due to the Schengen area and the lack of borders. As the UK kind of has a border issue, being an island and all, it's hard to apply the Schengen laws.
- vetinari 17y agoUK is not a part of Schengen area, so it is not just being island and all.
- gojomo 17y agoItaly, France, China: the new axis against Google?