6 ms·
What are the schools of thought regarding inflation? It seems to me that any mass handout would quickly raise the cost of living and nullify any benefit.
by dcw303 11y ago
What are the schools of thought regarding inflation? It seems to me that any mass handout would quickly raise the cost of living and nullify any benefit.
- littletimmy 11y agoWhy does it seem that way to you? "Cost of living" in basics like rent and food is what people buy anyway. How is having a basic income going to change that, unless you had like a huge homeless/starving population that can suddenly now get homes/food?
- dcw303 11y agoI admit that I don't know that much about basic income but had assumed that everyone would be "better off" by the same amount. Others in the thread have kindly informed me that is not the case, and that taxation will take out the benefit for higher earners. I must say that doesn't sound very "universal" to me.
- littletimmy 11y agoEven if we give $30,000 to EVERYONE, the poor will be more better off than the rich because $15,000 to $30,000 is a much bigger jump than $400,000 to $415,000. But the price of basics is not going to change that much because everyone buys them already. The "universal" part is that this is a universal floor on living standards that applies to everyone.
- Kiro 11y agoIt will raise the price of staples because people don't need to be frugal about those things anymore.
- littletimmy 11y agoWhat on earth makes you say that? If I buy one bag of rice a week, I'm not going to just randomly start buying 2 bags if I get more money. I'd rather buy some spices. People will be frugal because they'll want to spend money on other things. Imagine a poor person as a person just like you: he has wants outside of basic survival.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Kiro 11y agoPeople who cannot afford rice will start buying rice instead of noodles. And yes, they will probably buy spices also. Both are staples which could see a price increase.
- littletimmy 11y agoI don't see how there would be a price increase. Regardless, we can subsidize it to keep cost down. Problem solved.
- nabla9 11y agoFinnish social security already pays out handout that is comparable to proposed basic income. If basic income is implemented, poor people don't get significantly more and the basic income is taxed away from those who are wealthier. The benefit from basic income in Finland is reduced bureaucracy and welfare trap removal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_trap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_trap It's beneficial to work even low wage job part time when your wage is not reducing your basic income.
- lagadu 11y agoWhy would it raise the cost of living? This measure does nothing to increase wages, it has tendency to do the exact opposite in fact, as per described in the article.