3 ms·
> People should learn to take harsh critique and not let it affect them too much personally. Well, my straight-up critique is that you're trying to pass your
by wpietri 11y ago
> People should learn to take harsh critique and not let it affect them too much personally.
Well, my straight-up critique is that you're trying to pass your personal preference off as some sort of broad rule, and I think that's bunk. If you like being a jerk, godspeed. But other people get to think that you're a jerk and ignore you if they want.
> Taking delicate care [...] but doesn't pave the way for real progress.
That's the opposite of my experience. My simple model for it is "trust credit". If I'm generally kind and respectful, if I usually work to create good feelings, then I slowly build up trust credit. The more trust credit I have, the more people are willing to listen to difficult truths from me.
Today at work we did a project retrospective covering more than a year of work. There were a lot of difficult things to say. But what got us through was all the effort we put into building strong relationships as we worked together.
- mafribe 11y agoYou can only build up trust credit over extended periods of time. In modern, globalised science, you often have to deal with people you've never met before, and may never meet again. This requires a different approach critique. What counts as an acceptable critique is part of the core methodology of each scientific discipline, and differs with subject matter. In mathematically oriented fields one can often come up with clearcut counterexamples as a way to criticise a statement. This is not so simple in humanities. One may wonder if the dismissal of critique as AH-behaviour may also be a social strategy to dismiss criticism. It is not surprising that the author of the original article has a humanities background.
- leoc 11y agoI'm not sure what position you're arguing here. But if it is that chest-puffing confrontational behaviour is less common or less effective at "winning fights" in areas which lack clear-cut standards of proof I think the opposite is the case.
- detry 11y agoIt seems to me that the reason you spend time accruing trust credit is to maintain your likability among people when you're obligated to do things that are unlikable. That's fine. But how much does that improve performance or enable progress? What is the optimal amount of likability for healthy workplace that performs well? Let's take military bootcamp as a counter-example. People form strong friendships in a high stress environment where they might actively dislike their superiors. Their skills, abilities and tasks progress in leaps and bounds. Obviously this doesn't directly apply to normal workplaces, but provides an example of a situation where disregard for likability doesn't result in a bad work environment. I believe the sense of belonging is a core human need, and people go to different lengths in making sure they have that. We all do at some level. What you do with "trust credit" probably makes your workplace a nicer environment, but I don't know how much it matters for performance.
- XorNot 11y agoMilitary bootcamp is a very specific experience that is not meant to represent the general life of being in the military, but is meant to prepare you for the differences. It is a very poor example for any functional workplace because it really isn't one, even for elsewhere in the military.
- wpietri 11y agoThe military is a terrible example. It is literally illegal to leave. If you leave during war, they can execute you. Boot camps are meant to deeply change how humans behave so that they can survive war, a deeply traumatic experience that often results in lasting psychological damage. When people apply boot camp models in civilian contexts, abuse is widespread: https://www.google.com/search?q=boot+camp+abuse https://www.google.com/search?q=boot+camp+abuse > but I don't know how much it matters for performance. Sure, we can agree that you don't know. Maybe you should try it and find out. But I'm saying that in my experience it has mattered a great deal, and as recently as yesterday. You're saying that you want people to be different, to learn to take harsh criticism and subtract the harshness. I prefer to work with people as they are, which is as human beings who are sensitive to harshness, people who have a much easier time listening to people that they trust than people who are assholes to them. I'm not particularly good at it. I'm arrogant and self-centered enough that I'd rather just say what I want in a fashion that is convenient and emotionally satisfying to me. But if I am going to work with other people, I often have to choose between the thing that is easy for me and the thing that makes change easy for them. Even if I didn't want people to generally do well and be happy (which I do), I just won't get very far in having the real-world effects I want if other people are indifferent or hostile to me.
- derefr 11y ago> Well, my straight-up critique is that you're trying to pass your personal preference off as some sort of broad rule, and I think that's bunk. Ehhh. I think it's just a consequentialist statement. "Everyone will be more effective at achieving their goals if they don't get offended by criticism." This says nothing about whether the other person is offensive; they probably are! But allowing that to determine to what degree you absorb the factual statements of their critique is a suboptimal game-theoretic strategy. No general ever won a war by ignoring information he didn't like the tone of. (But he still probably tried to get the source to be less offensive, both for the sake of that person's effectiveness at interacting with others who aren't as pragmatic, and for the sake of his own mental energy spent putting up with the offense.)
- XorNot 11y agoThis sounds good when you say it. It also completely ignores reality: there's never clear factual content to anything, especially in tech. Quite literally, unless your critique is coming from a presentation, with an outlined testing method, summary of results and a chart showing the problems with some method and the benefits of another, then you are almost certainly injecting a heavy amount of bias. But wait you say, this is about someone's approach to a prob...let me stop you right there. If the criticism is now about how someone works and you think you're being or sound objective...
- wpietri 11y ago> suboptimal game-theoretic strategy If people were independently operating, weakly interacting game theoretical robots of very modest capacity, this might make some sense. But humans are enormously complex animals evolved to live in a highly intertwined society. Critique is used for all sorts of things besides helping other people do better at their jobs. No human motivation is rational; rationality just constrains and informs action. [1] It would be an interesting world where people could just turn off social and emotional response. But it's not the world we live in. That means that people will (and should) evaluate every personal interaction in terms of what the other party's motivations are. Is this person critiquing me because they want to help? Because they are cranky and want to lash out at somebody? Because they want to discourage me? Because they want me to change behavior they they find inconvenient or aesthetically displeasing? Etc, etc, etc. That doesn't mean they might not also later say, "Well, he is an asshole, but I guess he has a point." That's not easy and it takes work. So if I am going to take the time to tell somebody a hard truth that I really want them to hear, I might as well help do the work that lets them really hear it. If I'm not willing to do the work, I might as well just keep my mouth shut, because there's nothing particularly rational about me taking the time to say things that people won't listen to. I get that wishing other people would be more rational seems pretty rational. But it's an irrational stance. People are people. If I'm going to work with 'em, I have to work with the actual thems, not the thems that in some ideal world would be convenient for me. [1] See, e.g., http://www.amazon.com/dp/014303622X/ http://www.amazon.com/dp/014303622X/ and a lot of other things