3 ms·
I think some of your prices are quite low, but for comparison's sake, I'll just assume they are correct. I pulled calorie counts from the USDA and from calorie
by dpark 11y ago
I think some of your prices are quite low, but for comparison's sake, I'll just assume they are correct. I pulled calorie counts from the USDA and from calorieking.com
1 pound dried pinto beans - 636 Calories, $1.00
1 pound raw cabbage - 120 Calories, $0.50
1 pound frozen spinach - 108 Calories, $1.40
1 dozen large eggs - 840 Calories, $1.00
1 pound chicken breast (with skin) - 780 Calories, $2.00
Total: 2484 Calories, $5.90 or 421 Calories per dollar
I went to Wal-Mart.com to find some junk food and grabbed a couple of the first items I saw that kept me to about $6 and had online availability (so I could get accurate pricing). I pulled calorie counts from the Kellog website and walmart.com since I had exact branded items.
1 dozen limited edition frosted pumpkin pie pop tarts - 2400 Calories, $3.50
13oz chips ahoy chocolate chip cookies - 1760 Calories, $2.50
Total: 4160 Calories, $6.00 or 693 Calories per dollar
So assuming your prices are correct, you get 65% more food per dollar if buying name-brand junk food without even trying. You could push these prices even lower if you buy generic. You can also sub in a number of different "junk food" options and get similar results (e.g. chips look similar to the cookies, soda should work out in the same ballpark as well).
[1] http://www.walmart.com/ip/Kellogg-s-Pop-Tarts-Frosted-Pumpkin-Pie-Toaster-Pastries-16ct/19890848 http://www.walmart.com/ip/Kellogg-s-Pop-Tarts-Frosted-Pumpki...
[2] http://www.walmart.com/ip/Nabisco-Chips-Ahoy-Original-Chocolate-Chip-Cookies-13-oz/22880503 http://www.walmart.com/ip/Nabisco-Chips-Ahoy-Original-Chocol...
- CuriouslyC 11y agoThe prices I quoted were actual prices I pay for food at Kroger (not even the cheapest supermarket) in North Carolina. The food you proposed as an alternative would result in pretty bad malnutrition, so it isn't really an alternative. You might as well just compare a gallon jug of generic vegetable oil, the results in terms of health will be almost identical: 1 gallon vegetable oil, ~$5, containing ~30,000 calories, comes out to 6,000 calories per dollar. Finally, note I didn't say healthy food was cheaper than unhealthy food, only that healthy food is completely affordable. Obesity is extremely common among poor people (_far_ more so, in fact, than among the affluent), they clearly can afford a slight increase in marginal cost per calorie.
- dpark 11y ago> The food you proposed as an alternative would result in pretty bad malnutrition, so it isn't really an alternative. That's kind of the point, and exactly the problem. It's cheaper to eat unhealthy food. > Finally, note I didn't say healthy food was cheaper than unhealthy food, only that healthy food is completely affordable. Well, you were replying to a comment that started with "To the best of my knowledge, healthy food is in fact more expensive.", and your comment made it seem as if you disagreed with that premise. It is certainly true that you can eat healthily on a pretty small budget. The USDA even published guides on this. They have a low-cost and a moderate-cost (which is probably still low-cost relative to many peoples' budgets) plan. A big issue often left out of these discussions is that it is also very time consuming to eat healthily if you don't have lots of money to spend. If you have the time to cook from scratch, you can make healthy food cheaply. Finding time to cook from scratch is difficult for a lot of people, though, especially people working multiple jobs, or single parents raising kids and also working. If you're starting with raw veggies and dry beans, you're realistically looking at an hour or more of prep and cook time, plus cleanup. If you stop at McDonalds, you're looking at 5 minutes. :\ Another big issue is that a lot of people are honestly pretty bad cooks. It's hard to convince your kids to eat healthy food if you consistently make it taste bad, which is exceedingly likely if you're trying to cook "healthy" by cutting out most salt and fat. Hooray for dry baked chicken breasts and steamed vegetables. All of this adds up. It's not just monetary cost, but when you factor all of this (and more) in, there are a lot of factors pushing people, especially poor people, toward unhealthy foods that are easy, fast, tasty, and pretty cheap.
- CuriouslyC 11y agoThe time argument is another one that I really disagree with. It takes less than 5 minutes to dump some beans, water, frozen veggies, and taco seasoning/ranch dressing mix/misc other flavor packet in a rice cooker (you can get a nice one with a slow cooker setting for less than $30) or crock pot. You can also throw ground hamburger, sausage, chicken, etc directly in there with everything else and it'll cook up nice and tender. Want variety? Switch up the frozen veggies you add, the type of bean you use, the flavor packet you add, etc. You don't have to cut out salt to eat healthily (unless you are a sodium sensitive hypertensive). I will concede that most people have no idea how to season and flavor food to make it taste good. Ultimately, it is entirely possible to eat an incredibly healthy, very tasty diet with a moderate amount of variety for very little money and time investment. It just requires a little knowledge and some up front thought.