7 ms·
Mindfulness meditation trumps placebo in pain reduction
- chvid 11y agoWhen I read about studies like these I always wonder how the placebo is done. Here it is actually stated: "sham meditation" and petroleum jelly cream. One of the problems with this is that the experimentors would know who got the placebo and who did not. I don't think it is far fetched than a subject would sense whether they were being taught mindfulness mediation which the experimentor perceived as being genuine or "sham meditation" which the experimentor knew to be false. Whether a subject perceives she is undergoing an effective treatment obviously will effect the placebo effect and probably also show on brain scans.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoHm. Double-blind studies are supposed to measure whether a medical effect is real or all in your head. But meditation is, in a sense, "all in your head" either way. If a patient who genuinely believes that they are doing pain-relieving mindfulness meditation enters a mental state in which pain is relieved, does it matter if that state is "real" mindful meditation or not?
- austinjp 11y agoEverything you will ever experience is all in your head. No snark intended. This is a potent insight in pain science.
- lisper 11y agoIt's not all in your head. If I hit you on the head with a sledgehammer, the pain you will feel will in some sense be "all in your head." But the sledgehammer, which is not in your head (unless I hit you really, really hard!), still had something to do with it.
- DanBC 11y agoBut some people esperience pain without the external cause. No sledge hammers, no cancer, no disease, but pain is present.
- lisper 11y agoYes, of course, but so what? It is still not true that "Everything you will ever experience is all in your head."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bcook 11y agoIt is correct, from my perspective. Pain is just the interpretation of signals from sensory organs. Our brain could just as easily interpret it as something else or disregard it.
- lisper 11y agoNot really. Try this experiment: hit yourself on the head with a sledgehammer and then try to "interpret" the pain as something else (eating chocolate, say) or just "disregard" it. You'll find it's not so easy. In fact, you already know that I'm right about this. You are in fact so convinced that I am right that you will not try this experiment. How do I know this? Because millions of years of evolution has hard-wired this understanding of pain into your brain. Anyone who doesn't have this understanding hard-wired into their brains tends not to survive because they end up doing stupid things like hitting themselves on the head with sledgehammers just to see what will happen. In fact, there are a very few people who can't feel pain. It's a very serious problem. They have to be extremely careful because they can easily sustain life-threatening injuries and not realize it.
- DanBC 11y agoBut you're being a bit dogmatic. We use psychological techniques to reduce pain in, for example, cancer patients. You're reducing pain to some reaction to the physical world, but we see that some people have pain with no physical stimulus; and we some people who can reduce their pain even though there are physical stimuli present. When you properly control a study on pain meds you see such a strong placebo response that it's hard to justify using the meds: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10351230 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10351230 http://www.nature.com/news/strong-placebo-response-thwarts-painkiller-trials-1.18511 http://www.nature.com/news/strong-placebo-response-thwarts-p...
- austinjp 11y agoThe "all in your head" element is always present. Trials seek to discover an effect beyond this, not instead of it.
- jhdevos 11y agoTrue - which is why they did the cream as well. At the very least, this study tells us that the mindfulness meditation is a 'more effective' placebo than the cream. It's very hard do really do in a 'double blind' way - I would not be able to think of something that is to all appearances equal to the real mindfulness mediation, but actually only a fake. There's no substance to it. Do you have any suggestions to do it better?
- austinjp 11y agoThis is why trials designs other than RCT can be appropriate. For example, one group could be randomised to receive meditation therapy now, and another group would receive it later. Ethically this is more comfortable too, since neither group is denied a potentially effective treatment. I wonder if there is a well tested, robust placebo for meditation. Time to trawl the literature for protocols and designs.
- lisper 11y agoUse an activity-based sham therapy as the control, and have it administered by someone who believes it works. Waving magnets over the subject's body, for example.
- nroets 11y agoSome meditation teachers concentrate on Buddhist teachings that's not part of mindfullness. They believe those teachings to be more important than mindfullness. If the experimentors ask one of those teachers to teach the patients to meditate, the meditation will be "fake".
- stone-monkey 11y agoCan that really substitute as a placebo, though? I'd imagine you'd have to first verify that those teachings are no more effective than a placebo, which runs into the same problem as the original purpose of finding a proper placebo comparison. Edit: Sorry, I misunderstood your comment. However, if they're testing the effectiveness of the meditation technique, then the teacher's belief in the method shouldn't affect the outcome of the result, assuming the technique is the same in both cases.
- benevol 11y agoPain reduction is just one benefit. Another one is stress reduction, leading to a stronger immune system, less asthma, improved digestion, etc. The main point is probably that you rewire your brain: http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2011/01/eight-weeks-to-a-better-brain/ http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2011/01/eight-weeks-to... which means doing it on a regular basis improves your hardware, not just your software. You will end up managing your emotions more efficiently, which is extremely useful for people who need to stay away from d e p r e s s i o n and a n x i e t y.
- zuck9 11y agoWhy did you space out those two words? To make it unsearchable? But why?
- skbohra123 11y agoIronical headline, to my knowledge, mediation is mindlessness state.
- rikibro 11y agoMediation doesn't appear in the title. Mindfulness meditation does, and it's an almost exact opposite of a mindlessness state.
- DiabloD3 11y agoBoth "mindless" meditation and mindful meditation have their purpose. They are not the same thing, and people who do not practice meditation do not understand they are different. I find both extremely important in maintaining my mental state during times of stress. A half hour of meditation a day keeps the mental hospital away.
- hobo_mark 11y agoOk so how do I try this out?
- rikibro 11y agoYou could try this, which is similar, but more serious and demanding (the 10 day course): https://www.dhamma.org/ https://www.dhamma.org/ If you have the time, it can be one of the most unique and life changing experiences, in a good way, one can have.
- vijayr 11y agoSilence, food etc are easy. But ten hours of meditation everyday for 10 days sounds scary. Could you talk more about your experience?
- rtl49 11y agoI attended one of these ten day retreats in September. It was a worthwhile experience, but it hasn't produced any great change in my day-to-day experience. That said, many people I met at the retreat reported feelings of great personal significance. I'm completely open to the possibility that the fault lies with me, but I wonder whether these reports were influenced by group pressure, since there is something of a sense of community and to admit that you "didn't feel anything" is to exclude yourself. After ten days of silence and seclusion from the world (there's no technology, communication, reading, etc.), you will want all the social interaction and acceptance you can get. Also bear in mind that this is basically a self-selected group of people who are searching for "something." Whatever "it" is, it doesn't come as a surprise to me that people find it after ten days alone with their thoughts (which still come to mind, however much you try to focus on bodily sensations). As an aside, I was also turned off by some of the quasi-religious content of the retreat. The website claims that this is a strictly evidence-based practice, but you'll quickly realize this isn't the case when you hear Goenka chanting in Pali or explaining the benefits of meditation as an effect of releasing "sankhara." After the retreat, I thought a fellow named Harmanjit Singh did an excellent job evaluating Goenka's teachings here: http://harmanjit.blogspot.com/2007/07/critique-of-vipassana-as-taught-by-mr-s.html http://harmanjit.blogspot.com/2007/07/critique-of-vipassana-... If I ever have another continuous twelve days to spare, I'd still be willing to try another retreat with a more secular focus.
- tokenadult 11y agoFrom the footer of the press release kindly submitted here: "Story Source: The above post is reprinted from materials provided by Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center. Note: Materials may be edited for content and length." It helps the quality of discussion here on Hacker News, especially the quality of discussion of medical topics, to prefer sources other than press releases and press release recycling services like ScienceDaily for news on medical topics. Most new medical study findings are never replicated and are presumptively false.[1] Most study findings about placebo effects do not take into account the complications of defining what a placebo is, really, in a clinical trial context or what mechanisms might produce a placebo effect.[2] The small-n study reported here relies on subject patient measures of a subjective symptom, pain, and doesn't suggest any actual clinical effect on patients that can be objectively measured (such as reduction of tissue damage). Press releases are a known part of the science hype cycle used to draw in more funding for research labs.[3] Let's go behind the hype and see what experienced science journalists and other scientists say about each lab's press release before opening discussion here. Anyway, Hacker News participants have been saying for years that it's a good idea to look for better sources than Science Daily.[4] If Science Daily is the only place of publication for a finding, I find it more useful to look for another source before presuming the hyped finding represents a fact about the world. [1] "Why Most Published Research Findings Are False", John P. A. Ioannidis, August 30, 2005 http://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124 http://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/jou... [2] "Are Placebos Getting Stronger?" Steven Novella, October 21, 2015 https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/are-placebos-getting-stronger/ https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/are-placebos-getting-st... "Placebo by Conditioning", Steven Novella, July 29, 2015 https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/placebo-by-conditioning/ https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/placebo-by-conditioning... "Placebo, Are You There?" Harriet Hall February 24, 2015 https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/placebo-are-you-there/ https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/placebo-are-you-there/ [3] "The Science News Cycle" http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1174 http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1174 "Related by coincidence only? University and medical journal press releases versus journal articles" http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/related-by-coincidence-only-journal-press-releases-versus-journal-articles/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/related-by-coi... "Anatomy of a Press Release" http://www.skepticblog.org/2012/06/21/anatomy-of-a-press-release/ http://www.skepticblog.org/2012/06/21/anatomy-of-a-press-rel... [4] Comments about ScienceDaily: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3992206 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3992206 "Blogspam. "Original article (to which ScienceDaily has added precisely nothing): http://www.washington.edu/news/articles/abundance-of-rare-dna-changes-following-population-explosion-may-hold-common-disease-clues http://www.washington.edu/news/articles/abundance-of-rare-dn... "Underlying paper in Science (paywalled): http://www.sciencemag.org/content/early/2012/05/16/science.1219240 http://www.sciencemag.org/content/early/2012/05/16/science.1... "Brief writeup from Nature discussing this paper and a couple of others on similar topics: http://www.nature.com/news/humans-riddled-with-rare-genetic-variants-1.10655 http://www.nature.com/news/humans-riddled-with-rare-genetic-... http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4108603 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4108603 "Everything I've ever seen on HN -- I don't know about Reddit -- from ScienceDaily has been a cut-and-paste copy of something else available from nearer the original source. In some cases ScienceDaily's copy is distinctly worse than the original because it lacks relevant links, enlightening pictures, etc. " . . . . if you find something there and feel like sharing it, it's pretty much always best to take ten seconds to find the original source and submit that instead of ScienceDaily."
- jamesk_au 11y agoYou can read the full paper here: http://jn.sfn.org/press/November-18-2015-Issue/zns04615015307.pdf http://jn.sfn.org/press/November-18-2015-Issue/zns0461501530... Fascinating results.
- plusquamperfekt 11y agoPlacebo is just a derrogatory term for the fact that your mind influences your body and your perception of what is real. It is a perversion of capitalist societies to only accept a physical and obvious influence as being able to change something. The trick is - our mind is physical - at least physically manifested - and so it should be evident for even mildly educated people that your mind can affect your body. So instead of disregarding placebo as some bullshit that is used to test whether something actually works - why not invest some time and money into perfecting the application of placebo effects? Well, and here we are back to the mechanisms of capitalism - you couldn't sell that very well ... that's the problem. And if you think about it - perfecting the reliability and effect of placebo "medication" would inevitably lead in a straight path to ... meditation.
- nns 11y ago"Mindfulness meditation reduced pain by activating brain regions (orbitofrontal and anterior cingulate cortex) associated with the self-control of pain while the placebo cream lowered pain by reducing brain activity in pain-processing areas (secondary somatosensory cortex). Another brain region, the thalamus, was deactivated during mindfulness meditation, but was activated during all other conditions. This brain region serves as a gateway that determines if sensory information is allowed to reach higher brain centers. By deactivating this area, mindfulness meditation may have caused signals about pain to simply fade away, Zeidan said."
- jpmattia 11y ago75 subjects divided into 4 groups, so about 19 people per group. Suppose the study was studying the effect of coin tosses per group. The standard deviation is sqrt(19)/19 or about 23%. And that is only one sigma. So we might also conclude that those who flip heads are <insert effect here> than those who flip tails. Is anyone really surprised that the reproducibility study [1] found reproducibility comparable that of a coin toss (to about one sigma)? [1] http://www.nature.com/news/over-half-of-psychology-studies-fail-reproducibility-test-1.18248 http://www.nature.com/news/over-half-of-psychology-studies-f...
- epistasis 11y agoThe std. dev. of a binomial is sqrt(n p (1-p)). So for 19 coin flips that's ~2.2, or 11%, not 23%. Plus your setup is not relevant to the setup that they performed (check figure 3). I am not so surprised that many studies are not replicated, but I also am not surprised when critical internet comments are weaker than the analysis they criticize.
- jpmattia 11y ago> The std. dev. of a binomial is sqrt(n p (1-p)). So for 19 coin flips that's ~2.2, or 11%, not 23%. You are correct. The usual way in which std dev is applied is ± sigma accounts for about 68% of the trials, which is 2 std deviations, and is what I had in mind. So for 19 people flipping a coin, you'll have a range of about 23% variation. That factor of 2 does not change the message.