3 ms·
I don’t understand what “Amnesty” would mean in this context. We are used to governments offering amnesty, but that is specifically amnesty from prosecution, a
by teddyh 11y ago
I don’t understand what “Amnesty” would mean in this context. We are used to governments offering amnesty, but that is specifically amnesty from prosecution, and a normal citizen does not otherwise have much interation with the state in their daily lives. According to the article, VW workers are being offered amnesty from being “fired or [facing] damage claims”. However, there are very many ways in which VW could make workers’ lives a living hell without firing them, since employees by definition interact with VW all day, every day. VW would have to enumerate every one of those bad things they could do and promise not do it, which is, of course, impossible. This feels like an empty promise.
- lyschoening 11y agoThere's no reason for anyone in upper management to trust this offer, but I don't see why VW would harass any normal employees coming forward over this. VW has a good relationship with its workers and a strong works council and they need their full support at this time.
- teddyh 11y agoIf that were so obviously true as you make it out to be, VW wouldn’t have needed to even offer this “amnesty” to begin with – employees would have felt free to come forward without fear of being fired. Since VW did offer this “amnesty”, this is clearly not the case. Therefore, somewhat paradoxically, since VW have made the offer, it is an empty one.
- gohrt 11y agoNot quite. Before amnesty, we have a case where coming forward may meed confessing to being complicit in misbehavior, which could be rightfully punished. Amnesty says that that won't exercise that right.
- teddyh 11y agoNo it doesn’t. Amnesty, in this case, is limited to amnesty from being “fired or [facing] damage claims”. Nothing else.
- scott_s 11y agoThis offer does not apply to upper management, depending on where your cutoff for "upper" is. From the article, "The offer applies only to workers who are covered by collective bargaining agreements; it excludes top management."
- joshstrange 11y ago> VW has a good relationship with its workers Such a good relationship that none of them felt safe coming forward in the first place AND they were the first ones VW threw under the bus...
- andreasvc 11y agoWhat amnesty means is clearly defined, as you quote from the article. I don't see why the amnesty offered by a company would be so different from that offered by the government. A government could similarly make your life unpleasant, just as a company, and in neither case is it customary to exhaustively enumerate things. Ultimately it is based on trust, and governments have also been known to renege on their promises. I'm not saying this promise is trustworthy though, just that the fact that it is from a company doesn't disqualify it outright.
- teddyh 11y agoAs I said, an ordinary person has little interaction with the state, so there are fewer direct opportunities for harassment. Moreover, the state has little reason to harass the usual persons offered amnesty from prosecution, since those people have usually not been in direct opposition to the state itself – they are usually just criminals. However, if they had been in opposition to the state itself, it would probably be a different story. For instance, I don’t think Snowden could ever fully trust a (theoretical) offer of amnesty from the U.S. government. A similar situation (to the VW one) exists with employees of the state who continue to be employed by the state – they interact with the state more (in its role as their employer), and more interaction means more possibilities of harassment. Also, even some people who quit their jobs would be affected; these would be people who were employed by state actors which have a lot of interactions with people in general, like the IRS, the DMV or the Police. I would imagine that former employees at any of these organizations who quit their jobs and turned whistleblowers would experience trouble from their former employers. On the other hand, a whistleblowing former clerk from, say, the Department of Veterans Affairs, would probably not. What I’m saying here is that there are two factors: The degree of interaction a person has with the organization after the event, and the degree to which the person was percieved to be in direct opposition to the organization itself. The VW employees score very highly on both these factors, while the median person offered amnesty from prosecution from the state usually scores low on both.
- andreasvc 11y agoAh, I see your point.
- bsimpson 11y agoYou got VolksWagen's initials backwards every single time.
- teddyh 11y agoWhoops; fixed, thanks!