4 ms·
Yeah, I like your continuation of my analogy. However, as I understand it, from someone I know who worked in the automotive sector a while back, all vehicles ha
by dboreham 11y ago
Yeah, I like your continuation of my analogy. However, as I understand it, from someone I know who worked in the automotive sector a while back, all vehicles have a special emissions test mode. It exists for legitimate reasons such as you don't want to have ABS turned on when on a dyno for safety reasons. It probably also exists for less legitimate reasons arising out of the history of testing practice -- essentially that the test never has been truly representative of real road conditions, and everyone involved in the testing process knew this. That being the case, all you need then is to add one more flag to the list of "things to enable/disable under test conditions". I agree that somewhere there must be some kind of record of when and who made that configuration change though.
- kbenson 11y agoOkay, I can accept there may be a legitimate reason to want to determine if a test is being run for a case like that, but that's a component that isn't related to engine performance and emissions. I'm not sure there's any case where you could legitimately want the engine performance and emissions to be different during emissions testing. In any case you want it different (for example, testing different parameters), you would also want to test it on the road.
- oxryly1 11y agoThese details of emissions modes and engine control software configuration could easily explain the defeat. What remains is explaining how engineering managers higher up (all the way to the top) could remain willfully ignorant of the fact that VW's diesel engines "passed" emissions without resorting to exotic tech like Mercedes' bluetec exhaust fluids. They knew there was some sort of magic in their engines that set them apart, but they either understood it was cheating, or they never asked any questions.
- dboreham 11y agoI suspect this will turn out to be due to some corporate mass psychosis similar to when an airliner suffers controlled flight into terrain because nobody wanted to disagree with the captain.
- gherkin0 11y ago> What remains is explaining how engineering managers higher up (all the way to the top) could remain willfully ignorant of the fact > What remains is explaining how engineering managers higher up (all the way to the top) could remain willfully ignorant of the fact that VW's diesel engines "passed" emissions without resorting to exotic tech like Mercedes' bluetec exhaust fluids. How often do high level managers at a big company have a good handle on technical implementation details of specific systems and what the implications of those details actually are? It's possible that these people either had non-technical backgrounds, technical backgrounds in unrelated areas, or out of date technical backgrounds (like they last worked with this stuff back when cars still commonly had carburetors).
- oxryly1 11y agoMartin Winterkorn (the VW CEO who resigned) was an engineer. Specifically, he was an powerplant engineer who helped spearhead VW's diesel technology. I wouldn't be surprised to see him go to jail.