4 ms·
Yay, let's tack on a bunch of controversial and useless junk onto a vital transportation bill so it risks being voted against and or vetoed. If these ideas wer
by Someone1234 11y ago
Yay, let's tack on a bunch of controversial and useless junk onto a vital transportation bill so it risks being voted against and or vetoed.
If these ideas were so great they would be able to stand on their own in their own bill and be debated about. But instead, no, let's tack them onto military budgets/transportation funding/education bills, you know, stuff that people often won't vote against.
Most other countries frankly don't allow this. A bill or act has a single theme and a single mandate. I don't understand why the US allows it, and it screams of corruption/bribery/etc.
- _cudgel 11y ago> I don't understand why the US allows it, and it screams of corruption/bribery/etc. Seems to me like you understand it completely. The US is, like most countries, mired in a bit of corruption/bribery/etc. I am of the opinion this is simply part of the human condition, and is virtually impossible to eliminate.
- jimrandomh 11y agoIt didn't used to be this bad in the US, and there are many countries where it isn't like this. Corruption needs to be fought against, not apologized for.
- llamamamama 11y agoI'm not sure when you think corruption began in the US, but I'm certain you're naive and wrong.
- Retra 11y agoDiseases aren't cured by people who think they're incurable. And your opinion effectively defends the status quo, which, if it needed defending, it wouldn't be the status quo.
- Tiktaalik 11y agoIt may be more common in other countries than you think. Canada's recent Conservative government got in the habit of using massive "omnibus" budget bills to pass contentious laws alongside necessary budget legislation when they were a minority government that needed the support of opposition members of parliament to legislate. That government has just recently been replaced by a majority Liberal government, which is unlikely to continue the practice, as they no longer need opposition support to pass legislation. The ruling party has enough MPs that in practice the government should be able to do whatever it wants for the next four years.
- jdmichal 11y agoReposting from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10331848 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10331848 That is kinda how political negotiation works. One side says, "We want X." The other side says, "Ok, we'll support X if it also has Y." Repeat that, in this case for a few years, and you have a very large number of Y's. The problem with saying this, > Because tons of it is likely to be things that would not pass if they were part of small little individual deals where the vested interests were not so huge. Is that the thing that potentially would pass would never make it out to see the daylight without negotiation, which is how you get the things that potentially wouldn't pass stand-alone. (And I say potentially, because for every person we're probably talking about different things.)
- Splines 11y ago> One side says, "We want X." The other side says, "Ok, we'll support X if it also has Y." Repeat that, in this case for a few years, and you have a very large number of Y's. Why don't they separate these into distinct pieces of legislation (or whatever the term may be), and tie the votes for each together? Someone should write a law about this...
- jdmichal 11y agoSo we have two things, X and Y. What happens now is that those get bound together into a single bill, (X, Y), which then gets collectively voted on. Your proposal seems to be to instead maintain them as separate bills, (X) and (Y), which are still collectively voted on? If I understood it correctly, that distinction makes little difference since the line-item veto was introduced. It would provide better conceptual separation and to allow multiple bill titles; that's about it. It would basically be the equivalent of introducing modules or namespaces into legislation.
- bdamm 11y agoExcept, obviously, X and Y could have different outcomes.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoAny bill that is that important and that uncontroversial has got a lot of political potential energy. And that means that politicians can take some of that lack-of-opposition, add some pork, and wind up with a personal benefit and a slightly-less-unopposed bill. The end-point of this process is that most bills will barely pass, unless they're so hot politically that it's easy to attack someone over messing with it (think some of the post-9/11 terrorism related votes).
- justinlilly 11y agoApparently there are fixes for this even in our own country. Oregon's state legislature, for instance, has a clause which says what the bill is about. Any amendments that don't meet that qualification are not allowed to be tacked on.