3 ms·

The Experiment Journal

19 points by dluan 11y ago

kirillzubovsky 11y ago
Really excited to this Journal come to life. The team at Experiment.com has been working really hard to crowd-fund science and this is definitely a step into the right direction. Science journals are really hard to consume for the general public, and with this, not only can we get small experiments outs of the way for cheap, but we can also get the findings quickly in a format that's friendly to the younger generation. Win-win.
- tmalsburg2 11y ago
  Science journals are really hard to consume for the general public A lot of things are difficult to consume for the general public. Every day people "agree" to terms of service that they don't understand. We hire lawyers to interpret the law for us. Doctors interpret the medical knowledge for us and make decisions for us that have serious consequences for our health. And so on. It's a mystery to me why people think that science should be different. It's a complex subject matter and most people will never be able to understand result from Riemannian geometry, systems neuroscience, computational climate research, etc. Requiring that the general public can consume the results of science will produce a dumbed-down Mickey Mouse version of science. What a waste.
  - kwhitefoot 11y ago
    It's not so clear cut as you seem to think. A lot of science is graspable in its essence by people who would struggle with the mathematics. And a lot of scientific journals are written in unnecessarily difficult prose. As for lawyers interpreting the law, well the law is much more complicated than science in several important respects: it is not a single system based on a small set of fundamental axioms, it is not even required to be consistent, it is continually changing. Also, even if we do get a dumbed down version of science then, so long as it is still science, we can build upon it. I'm glad you put 'agree' in quotation marks because of course people in general do not agree, they have in fact no option but to pretend to agree or forgo the service.

19 points by dluan 11y ago

Really excited to this Journal come to life. The team at Experiment.com has been working really hard to crowd-fund science and this is definitely a step into the right direction. Science journals are really hard to consume for the general public, and with this, not only can we get small experiments outs of the way for cheap, but we can also get the findings quickly in a format that's friendly to the younger generation. Win-win.

tmalsburg2 11y ago
Science journals are really hard to consume for the general public A lot of things are difficult to consume for the general public. Every day people "agree" to terms of service that they don't understand. We hire lawyers to interpret the law for us. Doctors interpret the medical knowledge for us and make decisions for us that have serious consequences for our health. And so on. It's a mystery to me why people think that science should be different. It's a complex subject matter and most people will never be able to understand result from Riemannian geometry, systems neuroscience, computational climate research, etc. Requiring that the general public can consume the results of science will produce a dumbed-down Mickey Mouse version of science. What a waste.
- kwhitefoot 11y ago
  It's not so clear cut as you seem to think. A lot of science is graspable in its essence by people who would struggle with the mathematics. And a lot of scientific journals are written in unnecessarily difficult prose. As for lawyers interpreting the law, well the law is much more complicated than science in several important respects: it is not a single system based on a small set of fundamental axioms, it is not even required to be consistent, it is continually changing. Also, even if we do get a dumbed down version of science then, so long as it is still science, we can build upon it. I'm glad you put 'agree' in quotation marks because of course people in general do not agree, they have in fact no option but to pretend to agree or forgo the service.