3 ms·
Many weekends ago, I did a bunch of research on UBeam as I had an opportunity to invest. I hope I'm wrong (because wireless power would be cool), but after ~5-
by arbitrage314 11y ago
Many weekends ago, I did a bunch of research on UBeam as I had an opportunity to invest.
I hope I'm wrong (because wireless power would be cool), but after ~5-10 hours of research, I think wireless charging is unlikely to happen at any scale that would make UBeam a good investment.
The amount of sound power required to charge even small electronic devices is enormous relative to the volume of the sounds we hear every day. Therefore, charging must occur at a pretty high frequency that we can't hear. Power efficiency begins to drop at these high frequencies, however, and sound at these frequencies might have other unintended consequences beyond human hearing. Power transmission efficiency is low pretty much regardless.
The only way for UBeam to work, I think, is for people to think it's so cool to wirelessly charge things that they'll pay a lot of money to try it out. "Killing the power cord" on any sort of larger scale seems very unlikely.
- jasonlaramburu 11y agoDo they have a working prototype to show investors? It seems like anything would go a long way to silence critics at this point.
- saintgimp 11y agoAs far as I know, no one (not even the investors) has claimed to have seen a working prototype deliver significant power to a cell phone.
- arbitrage314 11y agoI've seen, with my own eyes, working prototypes deliver amperage. That's pretty easy, though--just crank resistance down to 0, and you can get as many amps as you want.