3 ms·
Well, the thought that leaps to my mind is that smell isn't like most of the rest of the senses. Eyes and ears are so easy to quantify and abstract with quantit
by jerf 11y ago
Well, the thought that leaps to my mind is that smell isn't like most of the rest of the senses. Eyes and ears are so easy to quantify and abstract with quantities that we've been doing it for decades now. Even if our eyes are not literally CCDs and our ears are not literally microphones, they're close enough for the quantifications to be useful. Touch and proprioception back to a geometric shape (our body) which provides obvious spatial abstractions (higher, lower, harder, softer, etc). Taste (considered separately from smell, which is normally a bad idea but bear with me here) is based on a small number of types of sensors (sweet/salt/sour/bitter/umami, if there's one or two missing it doesn't change things much).
Smell is hundreds or thousands of distinct sensor types for various chemical characteristics, with no particular relationship to each other. We don't have a systematic coverage of some vector space of X dimensions, we have quasi-random point samplings that poorly populate an n-dimensional space. If it's hard to get abstract concepts out of that, it could be because it really is mathematically demonstrably difficult to get useful abstraction out of that source of data. It sounds to me like even those cultures that happen to have them are still very, very weakly covered compared to vision or sound.
- kazinator 11y agoApplies to colors, beyond the basic few. That blend of red and yellow is named after a fruit. Violet is a flower. Purple comes from the Greek word for certain dye-producing mollusks. And when we get into the names of paint shades or crayons, we get names like "burnt ochre" (which could be the name of a smell too).
- colanderman 11y agoExcept we can describe unnamed colors relatively to nearby named colors. e.g. "That's burnt ochre with a touch more blue." Every graphic designer and photographer works this way when proofing prints. This is only possible because color is the sum of only three distinct sensations. The dimensionality of smell is likely way to high for this.
- wtbob 11y ago> sweet/salt/sour/bitter/umami Better than 'umami' is the native English word: savoury. I really don't know why folks feel the need to reach for a foreign word when we already have a sufficient one, other than wanted to sound fancy. It's like 'cilantro' instead of coriander, or 'arugula' instead of rocket.
- jerf 11y agoSavory metaphorically had its chance, but whiffed it due to decades of being left out of lists of all taste buds produced by people in the west that listed sweet/sour/bitter/salty. This is the same set of lists that also showed the now-discredited "zones" of where each taste bud lives. Savory also means more than just "the flavor detected by the taste buds in question". For all I know "umami" means more things in Japanese too, but in English the new foreign import word had a chance to get nailed to the exact right concept with no previous baggage, so it won out in this narrow usage. Note it gets used nowhere else, while savory continues to lead the rich, complicated life of a "full" English word.
- jessaustin 11y agoPerhaps GP wouldn't object if it were spelled "oomaumy"? We could even imagine a proper fake Old Norse etymology for that.