6 ms·
Exactly! Which is IMO actually one of the reasons why Twitter is having such a hard time monetizing. I see them more like a router protocol where people are poi
by ThomPete 11y ago
Exactly! Which is IMO actually one of the reasons why Twitter is having such a hard time monetizing. I see them more like a router protocol where people are pointed towards consuming content outside of twitter instead of on the twitter platform.
My guess is that they will change exactly that sometime soon. First allowing you to write longer texts as attachments and first then might join FB and Apple in "killing the open web"
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoGetting content directly through Twitter and being linked to it through Twitter wouldn't change all that much from a monetisation standpoint. The value of Twitter is in the interest graph.
- mbrock 11y agoIs there no value also in how millions of people stare into its feed day and night? Or the vast amounts of content created for free by its huge amount of users who include both the influential and the aspiring?
- ThomPete 11y agoNot really because they stare at the feed only to find something that then lives somewhere else. It's like being that guy the girls hang out with because you are good friends with the handsome guy in school. You might get to hang out with them but in the end they go home with your friend.
- brianzelip 11y ago> Not really because they stare at the feed only to find something that then lives somewhere else. Maybe not. When I want to jump in to @fat's stream of thought and humor for a while i read his twitter log, scrolling thru dozens of tweets. For me, twitter is for a few things: connecting with folks in a cold-call way; learning of trends and new ideas in my areas of interest; getting to know someone.
- ThomPete 11y agoYou spend way more time reading an article outside of twitter than you do reading @fats stream of thought. Many many many people don't use it like you do but almost everyone use it as a way to find new content and so thats where twitters opportunity is.
- mbrock 11y agoIn other words, you are a perfect vector for advertising. If another guy wants to reach those girls, he might want to pay you his whole allowance. Edit: to clarify my point, I say that Twitter not only is friends with the attractive guy, but is also funny and charming and interesting in his own right, and that this is a major value.
- ThomPete 11y agoIt doesn't matter what I am. The point is that twitter doesn't monetize properly right now and the primary reason for that is that people don't consume the content twitter links to on twitter but somewhere else.
- mbrock 11y agoI don't know what the primary reason is. Facebook has directed huge amounts of traffic to external sites for years and that doesn't seem to have been a major problem.
- ThomPete 11y agoYou consume way more content ON Facebook than you are aware of. Thats the big difference. And a lot of content is being written ON FB. The discussion is ON FB and they allow them to be long which keeps people there too. Just the ability to do a preview of on article is such a big eyeball keeper that it leaves twitter in the dust. Or to write a comment to the article which make people then react to what someone wrote about the article without maybe even reading it. It's like with checkins. People think FourSquare and Swarm is big but it's dwarfed by FBs checkins it's just not a major focus for them and so we don't think about it as a place a lot of people check in. But it's a numbers game.
- StephenCanis 11y agoPeople only stare at Google to find content that lives somewhere else. There is alot of value of linking users to content they are interested in.
- ThomPete 11y agoThats not at all how Google works. Google works because it give you a selection of what you are looking for right now. It knows whats top of your mind and. Twitter gives you things other people are interested in or find interesting. They are in no way comparable. One is letting you find things you are looking for, the other is mostly showing things you don't care about sometimes things that are interesting to you.
- StephenCanis 11y agoI'm only pointing out that you don't need to host content to provide value.
- ThomPete 11y agoYeah but you are using the wrong example since twitter is not a search engine.
- StephenCanis 11y agoBoth Twitter and Google help you find information you're interested in. The internet is massive so sorting and serving useful content to a user is valuable. Google finds this information based on keywords. Twitter finds this information by looking at conversations and people you are interested in. Saying Google and Twitter are in no way comparable isn't helpful. They are comparable though certainly different! Google has better information on your preferences and exactly what you're interested in. That doesn't mean Twitter doesn't have good information. If you follow a ton of yoga instructors then Twitter can feature yoga ads in your feed. While not as targeted as Google ads they still provide value to the user and the advertiser. I don't want to get into an argument, just wanted to explain where I was coming from.
- ThomPete 11y agoI believe you are mistaken. In fact having more content on twitter and users consuming more content on twitter would allow them to actually get value of the interest graph which they don't have now. It would completely change because suddenly you are consuming your content on twitter not someone elses page and so twitter would have much better ability to do advertising.
- rbranson 11y agoIt doesn't seem like Twitter has a hard time monetizing. They have a much harder time growing their user base.
- ThomPete 11y agoThey have both problems.
- sporkenfang 11y agoI'd agree with that. It's not that there is no value in Twitter nor in the amount of data on things people like and talk about on the service, but more it's more difficult for new users to intuitively jump in and start than it is with facebook or snapchat (Twitter strikes me more as a platform to listen to lots of others than as a platform to have a broad audience unless you, the content producer, are bringing fame from elsewhere).
- psadri 11y agoGoogle web search has exactly the same behavior. They are able to massively extract value from that flow.
- samstave 11y agoReddit basically has the exact same behavior -- with deeply engaged user bases around each external link talking about it and forming rather cohesive "communities" around each topic... Yet they have a tough time monetizing that. Why hasn't a twitter or a reddit sought to get rev share from the traffic they drive from the resultant pages? (I don't know enough about adrev/rev-share to know if this would work) -- but reddit and twitter know exactly how many people click on each link. One thing I would like to know is the diff in % of users that click into a comments session without ever clicking on the actual link. I know that I do this as amajority of the way I read reddit and HN even. I get the gist from the title, some additional details from the comments and sometimes other, better links from users as well as commentary, corrections or what not. I also upvote an extremely few number of posts and stories. How many times have I clicked a link or read comments about a post without ever upvoting or down voting it? Probably about 90%
- jdmichal 11y ago> Why hasn't a twitter or a reddit sought to get rev share from the traffic they drive from the resultant pages? Why would I, as a site owner, ever pay Twitter or Reddit? There's only two ways they can motivate me: * Prevent linking to my site if I don't pay. This has obvious (and terrible) side effects on what those sites are and how they work. * Provide some sort of advantage to payers. For something like Reddit, this would be possible through rank boosting or "sticky" posts, likely on posts that I the payer create myself. Twitter could maybe have tweets distributed to random users, regardless of whether they follow the originator. (I believe Facebook does something similar to this.) Content and relevance is meant to be controlled by the users in these platforms. Both these options begin to abuse that implicit trust by placing the ability to pay on equal footing with the ability of users to naturally boost content. This will work for a while, until the users' trust is sufficiently eroded that they begin to leave.
- psadri 11y agoGoogle web search has exactly the same behavior. They are able to massively extract value from that flow.
- lukasb 11y agoNot sure Twitter agrees with you, since they're collaborating with Google* et al on the Accelerated Mobile Pages (AMP) project - which can be thought of as an open, web-based alternative to Instant Articles. *my employer
- ThomPete 11y agoI am not talking about just articles. I am talking about content. (essays, discussions, comments, videos, promotional posts.
- mooreds 11y agoI'd say that google search is a router protocol as well--you go there to go someplace else. Seems to have worked pretty well for them.