8 ms·
Facebook and Apple News might be "killing the open web", but Twitter? I'd say Twitter is a great champion of the web. Linking is so fundamental to the Twitter e
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
Facebook and Apple News might be "killing the open web", but Twitter? I'd say Twitter is a great champion of the web. Linking is so fundamental to the Twitter experience. Half of Twitter is links to other websites.
- mattlutze 11y agoDoes Twitter load other web content through a built-in web browser in the app? That seems to be the big "white-washing" problem with the various reader apps (Facebook, Flipboard, etc), that they're unifying the interaction experience.
- chinathrow 11y agoThey did that for some time but that isn't the case anymore these days, at least on Android.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> Does Twitter load other web content through a built-in web browser in the app? On iOS, yes, it has a built-in browser. You can go to Safari if you like. They're not packaging up web content as if it's not web content, though. It's just to access sites quickly.
- mattlutze 11y agoFacebook also shows what should/could be the whole page, but I'm not sure we know what all they strip out in the name of making things faster or more pleasant. I'd wager the same is true for any built-in browser that overrides the default action of sending a web link to the actual mobile browser. And I've gotta say, I'm really bothered by the way Facebook handles browsing. I have to copy the link, exit Facebook, open Safari, then paste and navigate to the link whenever I want to have a page I found on a Facebook post in my bookmarks, reading list, etc. Super frustrating.
- JSoet 11y agoYou can make it automatically open links in an external browser (on android at least?). Hit the little hamburger icon on the right, scroll all the way down to app settings, then turn on 'Links open externally'
- mattlutze 11y agoYeah, the debate is on the forcing functions these companies and apps are deploying, I think. Though it's good that that's an option.
- davidbarker 11y agoIs this on iOS? I've had the option to open a link in Safari for quite some time now (as long as I can remember, at least). If I open a link in Facebook, tap "Share", I see "Share in New Post", "Send in Messenger", "Copy Link", "Open in Safari", and "Save Link".
- mattlutze 11y agoI mean when I click the link in a post, or click a link post. If there's a hidden option somewhere that's something, I guess. But I'm going to bet most folks aren't going to go hunting for the hidden option...
- anton_gogolev 11y ago> Half of Twitter is links to other websites ...via URL shortners, which is very unfortunate.
- 49531 11y agoWhat is wrong with URL shorteners? (Sincere question)
- maxerickson 11y agoIt introduces a dependency on the shortening service, if the service vanishes the link breaks. It allows the shortening service to track clicks on the link. It obfuscates the target of the link.
- oneeyedpigeon 11y agoIt also creates unnecessary traffic, of course.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoNot necessarily. Link shorteners can act like referrer guards, which is useful from a privacy standpoint.
- jacquesm 11y agoNo, they just shift the party that can see the referrer to whoever runs the link shortener.
- 0x4a42 11y agoI'd add that they allows evil persons (read SEO/Marketers) to hijack traffic by changing the target URLs.
- Klathmon 11y ago
- ThomPete 11y agoExactly! Which is IMO actually one of the reasons why Twitter is having such a hard time monetizing. I see them more like a router protocol where people are pointed towards consuming content outside of twitter instead of on the twitter platform. My guess is that they will change exactly that sometime soon. First allowing you to write longer texts as attachments and first then might join FB and Apple in "killing the open web"
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoGetting content directly through Twitter and being linked to it through Twitter wouldn't change all that much from a monetisation standpoint. The value of Twitter is in the interest graph.
- mbrock 11y agoIs there no value also in how millions of people stare into its feed day and night? Or the vast amounts of content created for free by its huge amount of users who include both the influential and the aspiring?
- ThomPete 11y agoNot really because they stare at the feed only to find something that then lives somewhere else. It's like being that guy the girls hang out with because you are good friends with the handsome guy in school. You might get to hang out with them but in the end they go home with your friend.
- brianzelip 11y ago> Not really because they stare at the feed only to find something that then lives somewhere else. Maybe not. When I want to jump in to @fat's stream of thought and humor for a while i read his twitter log, scrolling thru dozens of tweets. For me, twitter is for a few things: connecting with folks in a cold-call way; learning of trends and new ideas in my areas of interest; getting to know someone.
- treenyc 11y agoWhat I didn't like about twitter is that they uploaded my contact info on smart phone app without my consent. To date, they still have NOT erased those information and I still get email asking me if I know someone who just happen to be in my address book a few years ago.
- ducuboy 11y agoMore than half. Twitter is basically a commenting system for web links. This is obvious if you look at tools such as http://svven.com http://svven.com or http://nuzzel.com http://nuzzel.com.
- japhyr 11y agoThese projects are pretty interesting: "News from people like you." It seems like these kinds of apps further the isolation people develop from reading mostly articles recommended by like-minded friends. I wonder if anyone is building an app that recommends articles that provide a variety of perspectives different from your own. "News from people who think differently than you do", or something like that. But I think that's what newspapers are supposed to be.
- tnorthcutt 11y agoI use Twitter this way, to some extent. I consciously try to follow people with different perspectives than me and with opinions counter to my own. Sometimes I end up unfollowing those people if the signal:noise ratio is too high, but over time it serves as a way of introducing me to new ideas and ways of looking at things that I hadn't considered before. And, because of retweets, I'm then introduced to more people with similar perspectives. Once you "seed" your timeline with a few people with different perspectives/opinions than your own, this works really well. All that to say you can use at least Twitter to intentionally break out of that intellectual isolation that can otherwise be difficult to escape.
- ducuboy 11y agoOk good idea, I just followed you on Twitter ;) But if you're interested in different perspectives from your own, isn't this part of your, well, interests? Do you still need to break out of that? Personally I see the "filter bubble" as a non-issue. Partly because people will go with their interests no matter what. Forcing them to see everything else reminds me of this image https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Clockwork_Orange_(film)#/media/File:Clockwork%2771.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Clockwork_Orange_(film)#/med...
- gambiting 11y agoMy only use for twitter is literally to complain to companies if I want a refund quicker. Works wonders. Other than that, it's just full of noise, don't understand it personally.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- spdustin 11y agoAnd all those links go through their redirect gateway first. Open? Sure, just let me check those papers first...
- a3_nm 11y agoTwitter still bugs you to create an account to access their content. (Try to see someone's list of followers when you're not logged in, even when that information is public.) Compare with Wikimedia where you don't even need an account to edit content. Further Twitter is still promoting a model where to talk to people you have to create an account on a centralized platform first. ("Want to get support from a company? Chat with them on Twitter. You need a Twitter account for that.") Compare with email where you can email from any provider to any provider. Twitter might be more open than Facebook, but they're certainly not the champions of openness.