4 ms·
You receive the equity not for being around on the day the decision to found a company was taken, but for being around from day 1 until the company stops being
by Arnt 11y ago
You receive the equity not for being around on the day the decision to found a company was taken, but for being around from day 1 until the company stops being a startup. (Well, some of the equity may also be for other reasons.)
The other founders expect you to be around during that period. One commits in part because the others do.
When you leave earlier, you should estimate how much of the period is left and talk to the others about the portion of equity that corresponds to that period — how big it is and how you can use it for the betterment of the company. Are some new people taking over what you would have done? Perhaps they should get some of the equity, on fair terms?
- ryanbrunner 11y agoIt sounds like this consideration was already made. Only some of his equity was fully vested up front to reflect prior work - presumably the remainder of his equity was vested on a schedule (which at half a year he'd be entitled to none of most likely). If the above is true, then it would be inappropriate to re-examine what amount of equity is fair.
- Arnt 11y agoReexamination is proper because there's disagreement. IMO, as he lays out the facts, he shouldn't give away more than a token amount. But the other founders see the facts differently. So the right thing to do is to agree on what the equity is for and then discuss what the numbers should be and why.
- crusso 11y agoThe "right thing" was to agree on that before the work was performed. It's too late to go back on that now. The original vesting agreements are all that should hold. If the other founders want to come to a new agreement with some cash compensation or other special status in exchange for his returning some of the company's equity, that's up for negotiation.
- Arnt 11y agoI've never been in a vaguely successful startup where people do the right thing. What people do is approximate, do well enough to survive and grow, and defer the Right Thing until later. Doing the Right Thing takes time.
- mikeash 11y agoIf you receive equity for being around for the long-term, shouldn't that actually be written down somewhere and made a hard requirement of retaining that equity? Otherwise it's just wishful thinking, not reality.