22 ms·
I'm not really seeing the point of this article. I had already noticed that people are saying "like" a lot, and Hitchens doesn't do anything beyond making this
by foldr 17y ago
I'm not really seeing the point of this article. I had already noticed that people are saying "like" a lot, and Hitchens doesn't do anything beyond making this observation. And he really can't do anything beyond that because he doesn't know anything about language, language change or syntax. (Although to be fair, these are not normally considered necessary qualifications for writing on this subject.)
Anyone who's actually interested in the grammar of "like" would be better off reading something by someone who knows what they are talking about. E.g. this: http://www.jstor.org/stable/454820 http://www.jstor.org/stable/454820
- gruseom 17y agoHitchens doesn't do anything beyond making this observation I don't think that's fair. He wove a lot of observations into the piece. Hitchens is a man of letters, not an academic linguist. He carries on that tradition as well as anyone, and while I disagree with him about a lot of things (who, besides him, doesn't?), boy oh boy can he write.
- foldr 17y ago>He wove a lot of observations into the piece. In what sense were they "observations"? I did see a lot of assertions about people's use of language that weren't backed up by any data, but I didn't see any observations. >Hitchens is a man of letters, not an academic linguist. I guess my question would be whether you'd be equally happy if he wrote in the same style about (say) physics, geology or programming. Is there something special about language that makes it unnecessary for commentators to know anything about their subject? And really, the article is about like, for goodness sake. There are literally thousands of grumpy, contentless articles of this sort written over the past couple decades.