4 ms·
Anyone paying attention has been aware of this since last fall. It's common knowledge that CMU/SEI works for the US military. And the timing was a total giveawa
by mirimir 11y ago
Anyone paying attention has been aware of this since last fall. It's common knowledge that CMU/SEI works for the US military. And the timing was a total giveaway. They pulled the Black Hat talk, and SR2 etc went down not long thereafter. But it's not surprising that CMU/SEI would do this. Legal niceties aside, it's arguably part of their mission.
The focus here, in my opinion, ought to be on the Tor Project's role in this. Although they did speak up last summer, and have blogged this update, I'm not impressed. They ignored the CMU attack for five months last spring. Maybe they did get blindsided by a new kind of attack. Maybe they just weren't paying enough attention. Or maybe, as they've noted, there aren't many devs who focus on onion services.
But so far there's been no mea culpa from the Tor Project. It's disingenuous to whinge about unethical researchers and investigators. It's stuff like this that fuels conspiracy theories about Tor and the US military. The Tor Project needs to take a stand.
- mirimir 11y agoEdit: The Tor Project didn't see the CMU/SEI attack while it was happening. Maybe it was too subtle. Maybe the network is too chaotic. But I have no basis for saying that they ignored it. Still, maybe the Tor network needs an IDS.
- ENOTTY 11y ago> We actually noticed these relays when they joined the network, since the DocTor scanner reported them. We considered the set of new relays at the time, and made a decision that it wasn't that large a fraction of the network. It's clear there's room for improvement in terms of how to let the Tor network grow while also ensuring we maintain social connections with the operators of all large groups of relays. Sounds like they did know?
- eadz 11y agoNo, it sounds like they knew new nodes joined the network. Not that they knew what they were doing - they seemed to have suspected something, but made the decision that it was a small enough fraction of the network to not worry about, but obviously in hindsight they were wrong about that.
- mirimir 11y agoYes, they saw a bunch of new relays, starting in February 2014. And they weren't doing anything obviously alarming. But once Tor devs had seen the Black Hat abstract, they figured out what to look for. Once they were monitoring relevant parameters, the attack was obvious. In retrospect, more monitoring seems an obvious approach. But that would probably hurt performance. And threaten security and anonymity. Maybe there's a middle ground.
- doktrin 11y agoI don't have much to add, but I just want to say this is my favorite comment in this thread. It's not confused about basic details (i.e. CMU vs. SEI), lays out some relevant history and touches on what is to my mind the single biggest concern to emerge from this : namely, Tor's unsettling brittleness.