4 ms·
It's stunning that you may have read this conversation and still think people have an issue with security research on Tor in general. The testing, and perhaps
by unethical_ban 11y ago
It's stunning that you may have read this conversation and still think people have an issue with security research on Tor in general.
The testing, and perhaps even the specific methods of the this test, are not the question. The question is the morality of CMU being paid by authorities to uncover PII about hidden services and report back to them.
Test the system (potentially with your own uni's red/blue teams instead of on other 'public' hidden services) and report back anonymized reports of the data. One can say "Doing X, I got result Y" without giving out the personal details of results, much less to the FBI.
- caf 11y agoYes. It's the difference between pubishing a paper "How to break TLS" and a paper "How to break TLS, with an appendix of 10,000 credit card numbers I logged using this method".
- eadz 11y agothis. Doing the legwork of law enforcement, is different from doing research.
- tedunangst 11y agoThe comment I replied to said developers should only welcome white hat attackers. We seem vaguely agreed that black hats won't stop attacking because they are unwelcome, so what change is effected by only welcoming white hats?
- Canada 11y agoTo use the lock analogy: It's not OK to break into random houses under the guise of lock picking research. Even if it is research, it's still B&E. However, the designer/manufacturer/seller/marketer of the defeated locks would look silly to come out and say, "No fair, you're not allowed to pick those locks. We clearly said you could only do that in our test lab!"
- tedunangst 11y agoSo where does that leave the guy who discovered nearly all hotel locks are trivially hackable?
- maxerickson 11y agoIf I understand correctly, he did a lot of the work with the idea of selling hotels an alternative to the keycard programmers that come with the locks, and the company that did that purchased stuff to work with. This story has lots of discussion of it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4281722 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4281722 Especially this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4282666 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4282666 (Also, not all hotels, just lots and lots of them that used that particular implementation)
- Canada 11y agoI'm pretty sure everyone here would mock the hotel lock vendors for complaining... even if a government paid that guy to illegally break into a bunch of hotel rooms.
- nitrogen 11y agoNo, if your scenario occurred, there would be a similar sentiment as in the thread here. Motive matters.
- jacquesm 11y agoI don't recall Cody going into a number of rooms, photographing their contents and sharing those photographs with the authorities.
- mmcwilliams 11y agoWhat if those locks were willingly sent from house to house with the intention that the sending would obscure their source/destination? If you signed your house up to be one of those locations and decided to try to pick some of the locks that were shipped through your house, you would consider that B&E?
- tptacek 11y agoIt's not stunning. It is a long-running controversy with Tor and its operators. Most of what's in the "Ethical Tor Research Guidelines" is common-sense, but some of it potentially forecloses important research.