2 ms·
What if there's an upper limit in performance, where gains get smaller and smaller with each generation? What if Intel is already hitting that ceiling and ARM i
by mtgx 11y ago
What if there's an upper limit in performance, where gains get smaller and smaller with each generation? What if Intel is already hitting that ceiling and ARM isn't? What if in the next few years this will help ARM catch-up with Intel, while still having its chips cost much less? That would be a problem for Intel, no?
Intel's competitor to Apple A9 is Atom. Core i7 is not a competitor. If the A9 is within 2x of the latest Core i7, then that's great for ARM/Apple, but the real point is the A9 is probably at least 50% faster than the latest Atom.
Intel's Atom has never really caught up with ARM chips despite its process advantage (even now, although much smaller than before, and Intel process generations are also growing further apart). It had a very brief moment in which Atom was more or less equal to the high-end chips in benchmarks - but only because Intel had a generation and a half process advantage at the time being on 22nm FinFET vs 28nm planar for the ARM chips.
Atom is so hopeless in mobile, that Intel has started licensing its design to Chinese chip makers - which will build it on 28nm planar for next year anyway, making it a very pointless exercise, indeed.
The only way it got some foothold in some mobile devices this year is because it baited and switched Asus with a heavily discounted high-end Atom that cost Asus as much as a mid-range Qualcomm chip (which I still think should be highly illegal and worthy of an anti-trust suit). I'm talking about the Zenfone 2 - and even then, the phone got popular mainly because it was the first with 4GB of RAM, and Intel Atom happened to be there for the ride.
If Intel didn't lie when it said it will stop subsidizing Atom in mobile, then that kind of tactic will end and Intel won't be able to trick any other OEM anymore. But I suspect it did lie, because at the same time it said that, it merged the mobile and PC chip groups together to hide the financials of the mobile group. It also started selling $150 Atom chips as "Pentiums", where they probably have a profit margin of 500%, and Intel will use that profit to once again subsidize its mobile chips to drive competition out of the mobile market (which again - should be very illegal).
The problem for Intel is that this will still be a very slow process, and by the time it gets a serious foothold in the mobile market, ARM chips will start to become a threat to it in the PC market.
- msandford 11y ago> What if there's an upper limit in performance, where gains get smaller and smaller with each generation? What if Intel is already hitting that ceiling and ARM isn't? What if in the next few years this will help ARM catch-up with Intel, while still having its chips cost much less? That would be a problem for Intel, no? There's no polite way to put this, but you don't know much about the problem domain so speculating like this is entirely a waste of time. The problem isn't the fairly minute differences between ARM and x86, the problem is that your transistor budget (and thus power budget) is largely spent trying to keep alive the myth that there exists a single thread of execution and that one instruction executes until it's done and that's when the next one starts. I say that there are minor differences between x86 and ARM because compared to something like the Mill or a grid processor out of UT Austin (your data pipeline was physically routed between functional units on the die by a reconfigurable fabric) the differences seem minor. They both have the same underlying microcodes, the x86 front-end is just more complicated in some ways and simpler in others.
- ghaff 11y agoYou raise an interesting question. For the most part, CMOS scaling has dominated for the past 25 years or so--which has meant that investments related to carrying a specific volume design forward (e.g. x86) has dominated. Lower-volume and lower-capitalized designs just weren't able to ride the same curve. But in a world where CMOS process scaling doesn't dominate, it raised the possibility that more specialized designs may play a larger role.