9 ms·
What Is the Chinese Economic Model?
- newsio 17y agoThe list under the subheading "What Is the Chinese Economic Model?" is worth reading. He is overly harsh on some points ("there is perhaps a 30-year supply of poverty-level wage earners happy to make export goods at below global cost") but he is right on the money for others (currency manipulation, stolen IP, etc.) Note that this came out more than a week before Google made its announcement that it was considering pulling out of China. I think other startups or established companies considering an expansion into China should read this first. There are certainly opportunities, but lots of asterisks too.
- BrentRitterbeck 17y agoSorry about the downvote. It was a mouse slip. It should have been a +1.
- nfnaaron 17y ago"When one of Australia’s top mining firms, Rio Tinto, refused to allow China’s Chinalco to double its ownership interest last year (to 18%), China arrested local CEO (and Australian citizen) Stern Hu and three managers, who remain in jail today, under espionage charges. China denies any connection. In politics, thought, and business, China remains a police state." I think any CEO should be concerned about his and his employees' safety in light of this kind of thing.
- misdirection 17y ago> at below global cost The funny thing about cost is that it defines itself.
- mrtron 17y agoNot when you manipulate your currency and throw aside human rights and environmental restrictions. The playing field isn't level.
- mcdoh 17y agoNot to mention subsidizing the production of raw materials such as steel. If China could put more US steel mills out of operation they could raise the price considerably. The cost of bringing a steel mill back online is astronomical.
- jhancock 17y agoThe currency manipulation was agreed to by many foreign countries. China could not have done this without WTO and U.S. approval. There are many human rights problems in China, but it is unfair to say they throw _all_ these issues aside. I known many Han Chinese that openly support Tibetan culture and wish to see it preserved. Environment damage has been a calculated cost and there are many in China that push against it trying to say its time to pull back. A few years ago, I was walking up to a subway station in the Shanghai suburbs. There was a group of local college students with a huge banner urging people to protect the environment. They were asking people to sign the banner. I stopped and said hello and signed. The students were thrilled to have a foreigner sign, but the banner already had hundreds of local Chinese signatures on it. There were no police harassing them and the students seemed at ease in their public protest. Sure, the playing field is not level. This is by design and China is fairly transparent about the mechanisms they will use to protect or lock in economic growth. Look at a different trading partner with the U.S.; take a look at Mexico. NAFTA was promoted as a "trade highway" to U.S. voters. Most would take that to imply the highway goes in both directions. But if you have done business in Mexico or travelled there outside the confines of a resort, you'd notice that U.S. goods do not move into Mexico as freely as Mexican goods move out. In English, we always distinguish something that is "one-way" by being sure to say so. But, I never heard a U.S. politician talk about the one-directional nature of NAFTA. I think much of our problem with China is that most simply don't know what the real deal is and some of us are just starting to figure it out.
- showerst 17y agoFor those looking for actual economic policy history and statistics, I suggest Barry Naughton's excellent "The Chinese Economy: Transitions and Growth" http://www.amazon.com/Chinese-Economy-Transitions-Growth/dp/0262640643 http://www.amazon.com/Chinese-Economy-Transitions-Growth/dp/... It's a textbook, but extremely readable and full of interesting history, as well as modern stats and tables.
- garply 17y ago"At a time when the world thinks the communist model has been proved obsolete, China remains a communist country. In fact, under the current leader, Hu Jintao, human rights in China have recently suffered and are now in serious decline, according to Amnesty International-USA, the Committee to Protect Journalists, Human Rights Watch, and others." I take two related issues with this statement: 1) He says "in fact... human rights have recently suffered" as if it demonstrates that China remains a communist country. Certainly attempts at communist societies and human rights violations are correlated in recent history, but human rights violations are not evidence of communism. 2) China is not communist, it is Communist - that is, run by a political party which has the name Communist in it. People use the phrase "communist China" as slur. I believe this perpetuates the notion that China is actually communist among a non-trivial portion of the American population. It would be better to call attention to China's authoritarianism, which I think is what he's taking issue with.
- poutine 17y agoWhile China is certainly not communist in the literal sense do not underestimate the extent that the Communist party and its ideals pervade society. However I do agree that China is better referred to as an Authoritarian government with communist and capitalist influences. Also, we should all not underestimate how revolutionary the Chinese can be. They have a short fuse and do not in general enjoy the authoritarian regime. They put up with it for strictly pragmatic reasons, if given a path of their own choosing that they perceive as better they quite possibly will take it.
- rw 17y agoImagine saying "Capitalist America". How accurate is that? Not very :-)
- zaphar 17y agoName an attempt at communism that isn't correlated with human rights violations. The fact is that despite the "ideals" of pure "communism" every time it's tried bad things happen.
- garply 17y agoOne seeming inconsistency that stuck out at me is how he criticizes China's lack of free market behavior - he uses the pegging of the RMB to demonstrate this, which is definitely valid support for his argument - and simultaneously decries the "slave wages" paid to workers. Claiming the workers are underpaid relative to the USD because of the RMB peg is one thing, but saying that they underpaid relative to their own economy (which is how I interpret "slave wages") is a very different thing. He suggests that the government is the source of these "slave wages". In what way is the government responsible for low wages for uneducated workers when those workers are in competition with many other uneducated workers in a country with a population of ~1.3 billion? Is it so unreasonable that an "auntie" who cleans houses and does laundry for a living is paid about 1.25 USD / hour (approximately the rate here in Beijing) when a low-level analyst at McKinsey here makes 15,000 USD a year? In relative terms, the manual laborer doesn't seem like she's making slave wages to me.
- pchristensen 17y agoHe meant it literally - he said you don't have to pay construction workers for the first 6-12 months of a job, and you could fire them before that time without consequences. "If you are building a downtown tower in Shanghai (and there are a lot of them, many empty), you may not have to pay some of your workers for six months to a year. Or you fire them just before that: free labor!"
- SlyShy 17y agoYes, this kind of payment withholding happens to immigrant workers almost always, and to native Chinese workers often. That's not to mention the children and mentally handicapped that are literally sold into slavery. http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1635144,00.html http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1635144,00.htm...
- poutine 17y agoAlmost always? That's a bit of an exaggeration though I don't doubt it does happen. Most Chinese workers do get paid, even the migrant workers. Indeed the laws protecting them are way better than laws in the US, though of course endemic corruption means laws are often ignored. You'd hear about the odd riot here and there where the builders didn't pay in a failed construction project but they'd have a tough time completing a project and not paying anyone. Certainly in any urban area.
- pchristensen 17y agoWell that's the scariest thing I've read in a long time. Turns out the image of China as a worthy, powerful opponent destined to greatness is a carefully crafted ruse. There's no doubt about it's power but some of the stuff in the article would make a young Bill Gates blush. I wonder what would have to happen for America and Europe to stand up and deal with this? What would be worth the conflict and political outcry due to temporarily lowered standard of living?
- poutine 17y agoIt suits those in power in western governments to paint China as an existential threat to their respective countries. The reality is somewhat more complicated but it will be impressive if China manages to hold itself together over the next 20 years, never mind becoming a superpower which is laughable on examination.
- grandalf 17y agoYou're supposed to feel scared, that's the goal of that kind of propaganda. You may feel better if you read my other comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1056013 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1056013
- poutine 17y agoAfter working (in tech, not as an english teacher) and living in China for several years this is pretty much on the mark. The deck is stacked against foreign companies. If they get large enough their business will be manipulated to fail in the favour of a home grown competitor. There is no effective rule of law and most foreign companies are seen as resources to strip and discard when their utility has ended. (I had posted a more detailed comment along these lines in the Google thread here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1050829 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1050829 ) China also has a looming demographic timebomb that will tear the country apart. This year was the peak of the working age percent of the workforce. From now on the ratio of working age adults will only decline (thanks to the single child policy). China isn't wealthy enough to support all those non-working people. The world needs to start being more forceful with China. We don't want their model to succeed. Trust me, you don't want to live in that world.
- garply 17y agoForeign businesses won't necessarily fail - I think what is primarily necessary for a foreign company to be successful in China is for it to cede a significant portion of control and operation to Chinese co-owners / managers of the company. Essentially, to people who understand and are willing to work with the current system. Successful examples would include Starbucks, KFC, Pizza Hut.
- poutine 17y agoIndeed these business are quite successful (especially KFC and McDonalds) but I believe they're mostly joint ventures which in itself has a whole bunch of pitfalls. More importantly they're in an exceptional business segment (that of selling western fast food) which local Chinese companies are unable to play almost by definition. I suppose Intel is another example, but that's really only due to the fact that it's also not practical to have a local competitor to it. They would if they could. I'm sure you could find other companies where there's an exception, so my statements and that of the OP's article should only be taken as generalities. But I believe they're true much more often than not.
- noelchurchill 17y ago(One good answer: five evil traders on the 7th floor at Goldman Sachs.) What did they mean by this?
- po 17y ago> What could possibly be more dangerous to the world than a command economic system run on a global scale? > (One good answer: five evil traders on the 7th floor at Goldman Sachs.) I didn't get that either. My reading of it was simply to answer the question of what could possibly be more dangerous? I don't think it's referencing any actual event, only pointing out that the western model is vulnerable to top-down destruction as well. I think it's a bad point.
- raphar 17y agoI like the article and agree in the increasing threat of this nation. What it isn't mentioned, but I think it adds to the main points, is the relationship of China with Africa. You can read about this situation in this excelent report [2008 fast company]: http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/126/special-report-china-in-africa.html http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/126/special-report-china... In short, the complete report tells how china is extracting and securing its future flow of raw materials. China is extracting all that is possible from the continent by every mean available to them.
- Semiapies 17y agoWhile not a prototypical example, "fascist" describes China's economic system from the 70s forward better than "communist". Fascist systems seem to tolerate private enterprise better than communist ones, though the government tends to pick winners and losers (and shamelessly back the winners with force, as in the Chinalco example). Of course, in such a system, the government is still mucking about in the economy, substituting cronyism for market decisions, and trying to dictate profits and define their rate of economic growth just like that state legislature tried to redefine pi. Even Europe and the post-bailout US look like libertarian fantasies of free enterprise and transparency in comparison. We have nothing to fear from the Chinese Model. Their explosive economic growth has almost certainly been exaggerated, and even if taken at face value, this fascist system still leaves China, aside from a few rich spots, closer to the third world than the first. Companies dealing with China should be aware of what they're getting into - but to put it coldly, they should do so at their own risk, without tariffs or rattled sabers on their behalf when things go wrong. Tangentially, I'm a little amused that "locovorism" has a better cachet than open "anti-globalism".
- Perceval 17y agoThe Chinese model is not new. It's called mercantilism, and this was the predominant economic development model before Adam Smith's free trading capitalist critique of mercantilism. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercantilism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercantilism This is how the United States developed in the past. Alexander Hamilton's economic strategy for the United States followed a similar script. See his Report on Manufactures: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Report_on_Manufactures http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Report_on_Manufactures This report was read by Friedrich List, who then wrote a similar development strategy for the 19th C. German economy. It was this strategy that made the German industrialization so rapid and effective. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_List http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_List There are a number of spectators who have correctly characterized China's model as modern-day mercantilism (even though they disagree on specifics and the appropriate response): Krugman: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/12/31/macroeconomic-effects-of-chinese-mercantilism/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/12/31/macroeconomic-ef... NRO: http://www.nationalreview.com/nrof_bartlett/bartlett200311050823.asp http://www.nationalreview.com/nrof_bartlett/bartlett20031105... See also: http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1764172/china_mercantilism_and_new_global_economic.html http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1764172/china_merca... and http://chinaconfidential.blogspot.com/2006/06/mercantilism-with-chinese_23.html http://chinaconfidential.blogspot.com/2006/06/mercantilism-w...
- grandalf 17y agoIt's worth pointing out that some US economic policies count as mercantilism, and many Americans would prefer that the US adopt more mercantilist policies. The US is far from a proponent of free trade!
- Perceval 17y agoThe U.S. most certainly is a proponent of free trade, even if we aren't the best practitioner of free trade. As far as I know, only one country ever practiced fully free trade, and that was Great Britain for about thirty years starting in 1846 (after the repeal of the Corn Laws, a feat accomplished in part by David Ricardo, who you might remember came up with the theory of comparative advantage). This time period was more or less the height of the British Empire's power.
- gamble 17y agoThe degree to which East Asian economies are built to exploit Western liberalism is almost as astonishing as the amount of abuse Western nations will tolerate in pursuit of another quarter's profit. The Chinese may participate in free trade, but it's a mistake to assume they've become liberals in any sense. When the Chinese learn about free trade, it's in the context of gunboats shelling their cities to protect drug runners, not John Stuart Mill.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- cturner 17y agoWhen one of Australia’s top mining firms, Rio Tinto, refused to allow China’s Chinalco to double its ownership interest last year (to 18%), China arrested local CEO (and Australian citizen) Stern Hu and three managers, who remain in jail today, under espionage charges. China denies any connection. ... In politics, thought, and business, China remains a police state. No. I'd support the conclusion, but the evidence presentation here is shabby. The event that immediately preceded the Rio executive being arrested was the closing of contract negotiations for a yearly contract on iron ore shipments [1]. The rejected Chinalco acquisition mentioned in the quoted section was only a month before, but evidence for link of causality between that and the arrests is weaker than between the price negotiations and the arrests. Other motivations need to be weighed up as well: * At the time the arrest happened there were internal riots in China's western provinces (causing their leader to abort one of those G meetings and fly back to China). There's nothing like stirring up trouble against foreign devils as a mechanism to distract your people away from internal strife. * The snubbing given to the Australian foreign office also suggests a political aspect. Did the Rudd government imply that it could cause things to happen that it could not deliver? Or did it hamper the process? Or are China just being big-girl's-blouse because they can? [2] In weighing up iron ore issues you need to be aware that China is easily the largest producer [3]. It tends towards bilateral deals on 'strategic' commodities rather than working through global markets like the other major consumers (e.g. oil). This pushes the dynamic of areas affected by those commodities from flexible markets into a zero-sum game. [1] See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rio_Tinto_Group#Arrests_in_China.2C_2009 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rio_Tinto_Group#Arrests_in_Chin... [2] "The Chinese seem determined to continue to humiliate Canberra.", http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/beijing-ramps-up-the-humiliation/story-0-1225748894393 http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/beijing-ramps-up-the-hu... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_Ore http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_Ore
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- drinian 17y agoWhile traveling in China, I realized that nearly everything about the way they do business, produce goods, etc. is far less efficient than in the US. Many activities that would be automated in the US require the interaction of many people; ever bought a train ticket online and had to pay a bike courier in cash to receive it? If the Chinese let their currency float on the open market, my bet is that China would go from being extremely cheap for Westerners to fairly expensive. They're effectively using currency manipulation to compensate for an uncompetitive internal economic structure. (Hopefully in the long run they will be able to use what is in effect a huge foreign subsidy to fix their problems, but who knows).
- poutine 17y agoThis in many ways is quite desirable. China has so much excess labour that automation would cause severe problems. I once worked with a North American automated parking meter company that was ambitious at entering the untapped Chinese market for parking meters. This was doomed since parking is almost always done by a parking attendant, even on the street. Parking is also often controlled by the owner of the block. The attendant is usually someones uncle or whatever that needs a subsistence job. Another example are elevator attendants who sit on stools (often in private apartment buildings) and press the button for you. They often come with the building and are relatives of the manager or property developer. Absurd, but there you go. Chinese work gangs always take at least 3 times more people to do the same job that you'd do in the west. Most of the peoples jobs in such a gang is to sit around watch and offer advice as far as I could tell.
- heresy 17y agoCoincidentally, this is though to be one of the reasons why the Industrial Revolution occurred in the West. Because of the excess of cheap, expendable labour in China and India, there was never really any push for mechanization and automation and associated development of technology and methods related to mechanized production. Of course, the ascendance of the science in the West also contributed substantially.
- drinian 17y ago
- grandalf 17y agoI'm shocked by the amount of anti-China bias on HN. Consider a few points: - The conditions inside US prisons (daily, predictable rape, etc.) rival those in any labor camp anywhere in the world. - Many US prisoners are nonviolent drug offenders. - Don't forget the human rights abuses in Abu Ghraib and Gitmo and the hundreds of thousands of innocents killed in our oil wars. - China's main social issue is rich coastal cities and extremely poor inland areas. This geographical accident is behind many economic policies. The US is lucky to have rivers that tend to lead to a far more even distribution of wealth across geographical areas. - In its early days the US embraced mercantilism. It has particular political causes and over all countries who practice it lose more than they gain from it, but the tradeof is considered worthwhile for political reasons in spite of its foolishness. In China's case, it represents a way to grow the Chinese economy while not risking social stability (which is considered highly important considering the above bullet). - The US was also formerly a thief of intellectual property. Notably, many writers and publishing houses in England were irate that presses in the colonies paid no royalties, etc., a situation made worse after the American revolution. - Massive sectors of the US economy are under significant government control, even before the bailouts. It's splitting hairs to bemoan China's "communism". - The average person in China does not care about all the political nonsense that we are being propagandized to stew over. Most people all over the world just want to be able to lead a reasonably happy life, etc. China surely has some "backward" aspects, but consider that we did not have women's suffrage in the US until quite recently, and that we had a draft until VERY recently. Suppose China is 100 years behind, is that the end of the world? Do we really deserve to feel such righteous indignation?
- poutine 17y agoI would like to clarify that at least personally I'm anti Chinese government and not anti China or the Chinese people. I love the country for many reasons and don't fundamentally wish it harm. When someone points out something bad about a country it's silly to say they can't say that because there's bad things about their own country. There's bad things about every country, it doesn't make them beyond criticism. And that sir is why you get my downvote.
- 17y ago
- IsaacL 17y agoAn excellent article; my only caveat was at the beginning, where he basically said "China is not capitalist, it's communist because it lacks human rights". My initial thought was "it's possible for a country to be both capitalist and authoritarian." However, the rest of the article states his case more clearly.
- grandalf 17y agoThe article was full of poorly reasoned points. See my more elaborate rebuttal: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1056013 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1056013
- gscott 17y agoHuman rights in China is similar to here in the United States... as long as you stay out of trouble you are largely ignored. Once you do something that brings negative attention to yourself you can find yourself in the "system". A person doesn't want to get to closely exposed to the justice system of the United States, it is not always just.
- danbmil99 17y ago"But reusing the old label of "Communist China" misses the mark. I don't know what a better label would be." They've created something new, and it seems to be very powerful. By allowing some small-scale free-market enterprise at the local level, but keeping iron-fisted control at the top, they seem to be maximizing their competitiveness wrt the rest of the world, in a no-holds-barred fashion. Our Western system is in some ways inherently too fair to compete effectively with this new scenario. Not sure what that means but I suspect it isn't great if you're a big fan of western ideals, most particularly the idea that the rights of individuals should be paramount. I sometimes wonder if Asian cultures simply don't believe that the way we do. They seem to have a bit more of a 'hive mind' thing going on. Europe and USA have had to deal with a crazy mix of cultures and ethnicities; not so much in Asia.
- lucifer 17y agoStrike a strategic deal with the International Banking Cabal (HQ: Basel, Switzerland), whereby they move production capacity from the West to China and China agrees to continue the Ponzi scheme affectionately known as the "International Monetary System" by buying the bonds of the consumers of their products. The cartel hope that in the process the Communist China will transform and become integrated in the political control system before the scheme comes crashing down. The Chinese hope to acquire sufficient technological and industrial base to mount a credible defense/attack which will inevitably occur when the scheme crashes.
- amutap 17y agoits like taking the greediest best out of communism and capitalism. china implements a wonderful new beast - "commu-talism"