3 ms·
That's an argument to ban backyard campfires - not an argument to allow indoor e-cigarette use. You don't get the right to harm other people's health (even in
by Alupis 11y ago
That's an argument to ban backyard campfires - not an argument to allow indoor e-cigarette use.
You don't get the right to harm other people's health (even in a "free society"), even if there are already other unhealthy things present.
- AlexandrB 11y ago> You don't get the right to harm other people's health, even if there are already other unhealthy things present. What about the effects of pollution emitted when you drive a car?
- Alupis 11y agoThis is the same exact argument you made above. You are making really good arguments for banning/regulating other harmful things - You are not making good arguments for allowing a known harmful thing to continue unregulated.
- chroma 11y agoI think the argument AlexandrB is making is: Compared to pollutants such as campfires and car exhaust, vaping is a rounding error. However much you care about banning vaping, you should care 1,000x more about limiting campfires or diesel engines. Even a tiny change in those would benefit public health vastly more than a vaping ban.
- twblalock 11y agoThe difference is that vaping only benefits the vaper, but the harms caused by vaping affect everyone. In contrast, everyone in society benefits from the mobility and economic activity facilitated by transportation. Even if you never drive a car, take a bus, or even leave your house, you are better off because of cars, busses, trains, and airplanes because of the increased economic growth they facilitate. The benefit and the harm are both fully socialized.
- baakss 11y agoThat's a fallacy of relative privation though. "B happens more frequently, is more dangerous, or causes more harm than A. Therefore A can be ignored." AlexandrB was dismissing one argument because he found a bigger issue.
- JamesBarney 11y agoAny time we walk outside with a cold, use your car, drive on less than 8 hours of sleep, or choose not to get a flu vaccine we put other people's health at risk. We accept a certain level of risk to function as a society. If the acceptable threshold of risk was less than "possible threat to another person of any magnitude" we would be a very different society. It seems to me that we use a different rule to decide when to ban activities which is "good evidence of substantial amount of harm(drinking and driving, or second hand smoke)". I would argue that in order to ban e-cigarettes we need to wait for evidence that e-cigarettes are likely to cause significant harm to bystanders.