2 ms·
Mumbai actually got renamed, though. It was previously Bombay, then the name was changed to Mumbai. So yes, the same could be said of Mumbai, because it actuall
by mikeash 11y ago
Mumbai actually got renamed, though. It was previously Bombay, then the name was changed to Mumbai. So yes, the same could be said of Mumbai, because it actually fits. My whole objection is that the phrasing describes a case like Mumbai's, which is not what happened with Beijing. In the case of Beijing, the official name is the same, it's just a question of which romanization you use. Both Beijing and Peking are right, or wrong, and to a roughly similar degree. (I'd argue that English speakers unfamiliar with Chinese will usually produce something slightly more accurate when phonetically reading "Beijing," but it's not a huge difference.)
I know the purpose of the statement is to make readers understand that the two spellings refer to the same place. And I agree that a person unfamiliar with the origins would consider the two spellings to be different names. Which is my whole objection: the article encourages people to think this way, when with a simple change in phrasing they could still convey the main point without also encouraging people to think the city got renamed.