3 ms·
I think this is a really good point - if we can never break a law, we can never change one. There is another good point as we move towards more perfect surveil
by cortesoft 11y ago
I think this is a really good point - if we can never break a law, we can never change one.
There is another good point as we move towards more perfect surveillance and enforcement of laws; so many of our laws are designed with the idea that you will only catch x% of infractions. If we knew we would catch 100% of the violators when we created these laws, we might have chose different thresholds and punishments.
For example, take speeding - if we knew that we would catch 100% of people driving faster than the speed limit, we might set a higher speed limit and a lower penalty. We set the current penalty based on the idea that it needs to be high enough to offset all the times that we speed and don't get caught. For example, if we get caught 1% of the time we speed, then we can expect a $500 fine for speeding to cost us about 5 dollars per time we speed. If we are caught 100% of the time, that jumps to $500 per time we speed.
Also, the speed limit is lower because we can't enforce it perfectly - we need a little bit of a buffer, so that a cop can be sure the person is speeding before issuing a ticket. This means speeds are lower than they should be with perfect enforcement.
We really need an overhaul of our laws if we are going to allow automated and perfect enforcement.
- yuhong 11y agoIt also reminds me of incidents like http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=3106555&cid=41288357 http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=3106555&cid=41288357 In fact, one of the reason I dislike anti-discrimination laws are because enforcement using things like statistical analysis was really only designed for unskilled labor and the like.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]