8 ms·
The iPad Pro
- dhatch387 11y agoFrom the OP: > The entire x86 computer architecture is living on borrowed time. It’s a dead platform walking. The future belongs to ARM, and Apple’s A-series SoC’s are leading the way. > The A9X didn’t come out of nowhere. Watching Apple’s A-series chips gain on x86 over the past five years, we’ve all been speculating about whether Apple might someday start using ARM chips in MacBooks. As of now, it’s only a question of whether they want to. The most interesting point of this review in my opinion. x86 is hampered by backwards-compatibility. Could anyone comment on some of the more technical CPU architecture reasons for this? Do A64 CPUs have potential to outpace x86_64 processors in power consumption and performance simply because of the architecture?
- klausa 11y ago>Could anyone comment on some of the more technical CPU architecture reasons for this? >x86 is hampered by backwards-compatibility. Those two sentences don't belong in a single comment.
- spicyj 11y agoI assume the question was about _how_ backwards compatibility is holding x86 back and what features are problematic.
- revelation 11y agoNo one beats Intel at their own game.
- wmf 11y agox86 is hampered by backwards-compatibility. Could anyone comment on some of the more technical CPU architecture reasons for this? The reasons are mostly (1) x86 has strong memory ordering which is slower than weak ordering and (2) x86 needs a "complex" decoder to parse all the prefixes and crack instructions into uops (but ARMv8 cores require two decoders and may crack shifts) and (3) x86 is so hairy that it requires a massive test suite and dozens of errata still slip through, but the overhead of these is really small compared to Intel's advantages in money, manpower, and accumulated expertise. Do A64 CPUs have potential to outpace x86_64 processors in power consumption and performance simply because of the architecture? IMO no. It's cheaper to reach parity (Apple's processor R&D is much lower than Intel's), but I don't see why they'd outpace.
- Sanddancer 11y agoARM's 64 bit is pretty much always [1] dragging just as much legacy baggage as Intel's 64 bit. However, that's fairly irrelevant once you get everything decoded into micro-ops and sent into the pipeline. There, branch prediction, pipeline depth, number of pipelines, etc all matter a lot more than the opcodes the CPU sees. Also, you have to keep in mind that Gruber's been banging the single core benchmark drum pretty heavily, and rather loudly ignoring that Apple's ARM chips are very inefficient in multiple core benchmarks. In Geekbench's tests, Intel chips scale at nearly 1:1 with additional cores [2], while dual core performance of the ipad is only 70% better [3]. So, any sort of operations where you're wanting multiple intensive threads going on, the A9X falls on its face. So when you start looking at the hardware in the light of a heavier workload, Apple's not gaining that much ground on Intel, who has a lot more experience going broad than Apple does. [1] AArch32 is optional, but pretty much on every ARM chip for compatibility [2] http://browser.primatelabs.com/geekbench3/search?q=6600u http://browser.primatelabs.com/geekbench3/search?q=6600u [3] http://browser.primatelabs.com/geekbench3/search?q=iPad6%2C8+ http://browser.primatelabs.com/geekbench3/search?q=iPad6%2C8...
- cromwellian 11y agoAll of the claims of ARM vs x86 performance are based on Geekbench and Javascript benchmarks. This seems woefully thin data to make real comparisons, especially against platforms with active cooling. 1. How does an A9x fare with long endurance workloads? Bursty benchmarks are one thing, but what's performance like after 30 minutes of active use? None of the A9x benchmarks do any kind of battery rundown throttle tests. 2. How does A9x fare with large workloads? Loading up small streaming kernels into the CPU is one thing, but what about workloads that lean more heavily on the cache, memory architecture, and branch prediction units?
- jjtheblunt 11y agoWhy do you assert those benchmarks are "bursty"? Have you looked at the code in the benchmarks?
- rys 11y agoExecution time is incredibly short and the whole thing is over in seconds.
- mtgx 11y agoIf anyone is cheating in "burst performance", that would be Intel with its "Turbo Boost" feature. Unfortunately, most benchmark only reveal the performance of Intel's chips with Turbo Boost, not without.
- wmf 11y agoAllowing your computer to run faster within a given power/thermal envelope is hardly cheating. Everyone should be using turbo and Intel shouldn't be penalized if some others aren't smart enough to implement it.
- berntb 11y agoThe Ars review [0] did run the new iPad 10 + 30 minutes and compared it to a 6s iPhone, at least for heat overload. (It would be more interesting with a 6s Plus). [0] http://arstechnica.com/apple/2015/11/ipad-pro-review-mac-like-speed-with-all-the-virtues-and-limitations-of-ios/4/#h2 http://arstechnica.com/apple/2015/11/ipad-pro-review-mac-lik... "... but it’s roughly on the same level as a Core i5 from 2013 or so and it’s well ahead of Core M. And despite the fact that it lacks a fan, the A9X shows little sign of throttling in the Geekbench thermal test, which bodes well for the iPad Pro’s ability to run professional-caliber apps for extended periods of time."
- mark_l_watson 11y agoGood review. I especially appreciated the comments about app support for the keyboard issues - although I expect most will get resolved in a few months. I have an iPad mini 4 and I am surprised at how much I use it for work tasks. I write a lot and having a text editor open for markdown manuscript files in Dropbox with a generated PDF open for viewing (I use leanpub.com for writing) is really convenient. Easy to edit markdown files and it just takes a second to switch the latest PDF file. For situations when I am only adding a few pages in a writing session, text input speed is not an issue. In the same spirit, when I need to SSH to a server for something simple, it is faster to use my iPad. I sometimes use the nitrous.io web IDE, but not often on my iPad. With a larger screen, multi Windows, and more processing power of an iPad Pro, I think that it will make a fine partial laptop replacement. I will always, probably, need a laptop for running IDEs like IntelliJ however. My wife also has an iPad mini and we have talked about just traveling with a mini, not a smartphone. Right now, my Note 4 does everything I need while traveling (SSH shells, writing using leanpub, calls, and web access) but an iPad with 4G might also be a replacement for a phone when traveling because I always have a backpack with me. I am very keen on the iPad model as being the most used device in the near future. I think this is Apple's plan.
- xlayn 11y agoIt has been some years since we got the first "iX will kill the pc" and we know where the story goes. There are several things you have to keep in mind when referring to ARM and how fast it's been evolving, PC and iX devices: -Apple is pushing forward at an incredible pace, the new Ax cpus with the pciE based storage solutions are remarkable proofs of it. -contrary to x86, ARM power is still increasing per release, some day it will hit Moore's law 2: more cores and not speed (MHz) irremediably, this is: it wasn't fast enough. Moore's law 2: a side effect of not being able to make cores faster thus taking the path of adding more cores with the well know issues of not being able to spread work across cores efficiently. -x86 on the other side has been getting better at power usage, I can't do a forecast but I would suggest the race comes to if x86 can get power efficient enough or ARM can get fast enough. *as the review mention is already very fast, the question is what's the thermal envelope, how much time it can stay there and the ram in soc package. -traditional x86 work vs ios ecosystem, another comment here states:"how much I use it for work tasks" referring to the ipad where those tasks are "text editor open for markdown manuscript files in Dropbox with a generated PDF open for viewing" vs what he states is pc work "I will always, probably, need a laptop for running IDEs like IntelliJ however" and again what he feels is the new ipad pro lacking "larger screen, multi Windows, and more processing power" this is: pc capabilities. -user cliche? is always the argument about being laptop killer that you can write on it? "I write a lot" and from the article "I’ve written this entire review using it"? what does define the ability to be a pc killer? to browse the web? -ecosystem, unless apple get macosx to run in arm it's a very fast iPhone.
- mmastrac 11y agoThe ecosystem is a killer. As a developer, it's missing everything I need to be built-in on a device: a terminal, VMware, SSH, remote access to other machines. Obviously I'm not the target market, but consider the same thing for designers: where is Sketch for iOS? Where is the equivalent of desktop Photoshop? I still think that iX devices are create for consumption and very basic creation, but anyone who is doing creation full-time isn't going to able to switch for some time.
- motdiem 11y ago
- hackuser 11y agoThe question that most interests me is, how does it compare with Microsoft's Surface Pro?
- PeCaN 11y agoSeems to me more like a well-executed Surface RT than a Surface Pro.
- tdkl 11y agoSeems that "desktop class hardware" is needed nowadays to run iOS 9 blur smoothly, which was fine in iOS 8 : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxtQ8IoiYa4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxtQ8IoiYa4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agsN6Dxwk7g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agsN6Dxwk7g
- ics 11y agoI held off upgrading to iOS 8 for a long time out of fear that my iPhone 5 would slow to a halt; when it had to be replaced for an expanding battery I got it back with the upgrade and was pleasantly surprised at how well it performed. I took the jump with iOS 9 and now experience almost the same as in your link. I rarely have more than 3 apps open at a time, no media (photos, music, ...) stored, and all optional effects disabled. I wish they had some internal incentive for keeping old stuff working like new; it used to be a source of pride to own an Apple device that was several years old and still looked and worked like a new product. The iPhone 5 and unibody MacBook Pro are both examples of products that I've owned for years but continue to impress.
- walterbell 11y agoWe need a law mandating security updates which are decoupled from new features. Alternately, an OS vendor who makes this a point of competitive differentiation. Unfortunately, MS is forcing new features alongside security fixes, and Android devices have a poor track record of timely security updates. So we are left with Apple, whose iOS9 effectively destroyed the performant usability of older devices.
- danudey 11y agoOn the other hand, at least you can get those updates on your older iOS devices. Most Android devices have never seen updates at all, and of the ones who have, most of them will never see more than a few minor updates above what they came with.
- oneeyedpigeon 11y ago
- Artistry121 11y agoIf iPads are able to become the defacto portable work/personal device I wonder how Apple forcing a 30% cut on every digital things sold through apps will work. Are there any people here who use an iPad regularly for work? Is it easy to keep things organized without a file system?
- nextos 11y agoI think laptops are becoming irrelevant for many use cases. They are not sufficiently powerful to do heavy data processing without running into thermal issues, and they are less mobile than tablets equipped with external keyboards. This is what Microsoft has realised about when they created the Surface product line. Workstations are surprisingly capable for the money. A big NVMe consumer-grade SSD, some RAM and a good GPU can take you really far. 5 years ago I never thought I would be able to run my stuff on a workstation instead of a big server. Tablets are very interesting, because they fill in the mobility use case much better than laptops. They are way more ergonomic as long as you have an external keyboard. The shame with the iPad Pro is not being able to run a full OS. I'd love to run say Arch Linux ARM.
- mreiland 11y agoIt almost sounds like you're saying laptops may be on the decline, something that many people claimed laptops were going to do to desktops.
- BillinghamJ 11y agoDesktops did go on the decline. Certainly not eradicated, but the laptop is now the default choice, and the correct choice for most people.
- mreiland 11y agodesktops simply stopped being used in situations where laptops were the better choice, but they were never in danger of ever being displaced by anything. Most of those people who have laptops either have desktops at home or have a docking station with a full blown monitor and keyboard at home. There's a reason for that.
- nextos 11y agoWell, I actually meant tablets with keyboard are a better realisation of the laptop concept. More ergonomic.
- bluedino 11y ago
- smcl 11y ago"The entire x86 computer architecture is living on borrowed time. It’s a dead platform walking. The future belongs to ARM, and Apple’s A-series SoC’s are leading the way." That is an extremely bold claim. I'd love for it to be true though.
- justinator 11y agoHe's a journalist. It's his job to make bold claims - no one want to read about boring things. You'll notice that this particular journalist is seen as very polarizing (you love him, or you hate him). That's shows he's doing his job well.
- cwisecarver 11y agoHe's not a journalist, he's a pundit.
- Retra 11y agoHis job is to make true claims. Your job is to require that he do so.
- listic 11y agoWhy stop with ARM? Once we get rid of x86, the future could as well belong to various ISA's, including open-source, royalty-free ones like RISC-V [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RISC-V https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RISC-V
- twblalock 11y agoIt would not surprise me to see an Apple ARM chip in future Macs. The improvement to battery life would be huge. As with the Intel transition, I bet Apple already has OS X running on ARM chips. The biggest problem would be to get third-party software developers to port to ARM, especially the major ones like Adobe. Microsoft already does a lot of work for ARM, so the barrier to getting Office running on OS X on ARM might be pretty low.
- bryanlarsen 11y ago
- motdiem 11y agoI really wish they'll upgrade keyboard navigation (whether scrolling or selecting items, etc) - I've started relying on my iPad more and leaving my computer at the office, and it's fine for most tasks with a keyboard except when navigating in an app - having to touch the screen is just too slow. I wonder how the option-tab combo works when multitasking with two apps on the screen though
- walterbell 11y agoThe Logitech keyboard is available at Apple stores, offering real (19mm) keys, backlighting and shortcuts for home/lock, spotlight search, brightness, volume and music (reverse/play/pause/forward). A bit cheaper and heavier than Apple's keyboard. Walt Mossberg said, "Of the three keyboards I used to write this column, I found that the MacBook Pro was best, the Logitech Create second, and Apple's iPad Pro Smart Keyboard dead last.", http://www.theverge.com/2015/11/11/9711284/logitech-ipad-pro-keyboard-case-announced http://www.theverge.com/2015/11/11/9711284/logitech-ipad-pro...
- motdiem 11y agoAlso Logitech have Azerty and qwertz keyboard, whereas I think Apple only has qwerty at the moment
- tolmasky 11y agoThis reads more like a bad review of the new Macbook than a great review of the new iPad Pro. Of course, this was already the case before, the new Macbook has always been kind of a head-scratcher: 1. Despite the amazing battery advancements it gets worse batter life than the Macbook Air (9 hrs web vs 12 hrs). 2. A worse graphics card than the Macbook Air yet MORE pixels. 3. A higher price point. Any time I bring this up, I'm told I don't get it and this isn't a computer for a "pro" like me. But that doesn't really mesh with the fact that its a super expensive computer. Who is this for? I guess it makes for a really great comparison to the new iPad Pro.
- potatolicious 11y ago> "But that doesn't really mesh with the fact that its a super expensive computer. Who is this for?" Early adopters and people who need absolute maximum portability and are not particularly price-sensitive. The MacBook is smaller, thinner, and lighter than the MBA, and has a higher quality screen. If you need a laptop that fits the above description and don't mind the cost, it's a good bet. More to the point though - it occupies a similar space as the MacBook Air when it originally came out (recall that the MBA was ~$1500-2000 when it first came out). I think it's fairly obvious that Apple's letting early adopters pay the premium, and once they can get production costs down enough it will simply take over as the lowest-tier Mac laptop entirely, probably at the same $900-1000 price point the MBA is at today. It is the exact same trajectory as the original MacBook Air - introduced as premium ultra-portable product, eventually replacing the plastic MacBooks as the base-level product.
- tolmasky 11y ago> The MacBook is smaller, thinner, and lighter than the MBA, and has a higher quality screen. I just find it hard to say that its a higher quality screen when you have a worse graphics card, and thus the stuff that will actually be on the screen will be worse (more dropped frames, worse effects, etc). What does it mean to want a higher quality screen? If it had 8x as many pixel but was black and white, is it higher quality? If you want a retina screen for awesome gaming, this isn't for you. If you want a retina screen for video editing, this isn't for you. If you want a retina screen for ... web browsing, as long as there are no CSS animations because they'll be horrible... then its for you? > it occupies a similar space as the MacBook Air when it originally came out Sure, I get that, but the difference is that when the Macbook Air came out the Macbook Air didn't already exist. Let's think about it another way, if next year they announce an EVEN thinner Macbook with even stranger performance tradeoffs, would we accept 3 computers in this space? Probably not. I suppose my fear is that the plan here is to replace Macbook Airs with this. What I wanted out of a Macbook Air was more RAM, that's about it. Instead this huge detour was taken on compromise features -- which again is fine, except if the plan is to turn this entire product category into a worse-than-iPad computer, which is definitely not where the Air sat before. The Air before seemed like good compromises, and perhaps the Macbook will get there too.
- jonstokes 11y ago"The entire x86 computer architecture is living on borrowed time. It’s a dead platform walking. The future belongs to ARM, and Apple’s A-series SoC’s are leading the way." I can't believe that lines like this are still being written. I devoted the better part of a career to successfully debunking this idea that ARM has some sort of magical power efficiency advantages over x86. I can, however, console myself that such claims are exceedingly rare. Most people who lived through the "RISC vs. CISC" platform wars and made such claims conceded defeat a long time ago. Anyway, I addressed this issue in one of my last CPU articles for Ars back in 2011: http://arstechnica.com/business/2011/02/nvidia-30-and-the-riscification-of-x86/ http://arstechnica.com/business/2011/02/nvidia-30-and-the-ri... Quote: "It's also the case that as ARM moves up the performance ladder, it will necessarily start to drop in terms of power efficiency. Again, there is no magic pixie dust here, and the impact of the ISA alone on power consumption in processors that draw many tens of watts is negligible. A multicore ARM chip and a multicore Xeon chip that give similar performance on compute-intensive workloads will have similar power profiles; to believe otherwise is to believe in magical little ARM performance elves." Also, I think that benchmarks run in this article for the purpose of comparing the iPad to the MacBook are pretty worthless. I don't have a good answer for how to comparatively benchmark them, or even if that makes sense. Meaningful cross-platform benchmarking is really hard, just ask the SPEC people. Finally, in the article linked above, I predicted that the only way ARM is a threat to x86 is because it's cheaper, and that if ARM can get within something like 2X the performance of Intel's higher end CPUs, it might have a shot by virtue of being widely and inexpensively licensed. Anyway, the TL;DR here is that those benchmarks say more about the software stack (the benchmark software included) than the do about the CPU and GPU hardware, and the reports of x86's death at the hands of PowerPC^H^H^H ARM are, as always, greatly exaggerated.
- mtgx 11y agoWhat if there's an upper limit in performance, where gains get smaller and smaller with each generation? What if Intel is already hitting that ceiling and ARM isn't? What if in the next few years this will help ARM catch-up with Intel, while still having its chips cost much less? That would be a problem for Intel, no? Intel's competitor to Apple A9 is Atom. Core i7 is not a competitor. If the A9 is within 2x of the latest Core i7, then that's great for ARM/Apple, but the real point is the A9 is probably at least 50% faster than the latest Atom. Intel's Atom has never really caught up with ARM chips despite its process advantage (even now, although much smaller than before, and Intel process generations are also growing further apart). It had a very brief moment in which Atom was more or less equal to the high-end chips in benchmarks - but only because Intel had a generation and a half process advantage at the time being on 22nm FinFET vs 28nm planar for the ARM chips. Atom is so hopeless in mobile, that Intel has started licensing its design to Chinese chip makers - which will build it on 28nm planar for next year anyway, making it a very pointless exercise, indeed. The only way it got some foothold in some mobile devices this year is because it baited and switched Asus with a heavily discounted high-end Atom that cost Asus as much as a mid-range Qualcomm chip (which I still think should be highly illegal and worthy of an anti-trust suit). I'm talking about the Zenfone 2 - and even then, the phone got popular mainly because it was the first with 4GB of RAM, and Intel Atom happened to be there for the ride. If Intel didn't lie when it said it will stop subsidizing Atom in mobile, then that kind of tactic will end and Intel won't be able to trick any other OEM anymore. But I suspect it did lie, because at the same time it said that, it merged the mobile and PC chip groups together to hide the financials of the mobile group. It also started selling $150 Atom chips as "Pentiums", where they probably have a profit margin of 500%, and Intel will use that profit to once again subsidize its mobile chips to drive competition out of the mobile market (which again - should be very illegal). The problem for Intel is that this will still be a very slow process, and by the time it gets a serious foothold in the mobile market, ARM chips will start to become a threat to it in the PC market.
- davidy123 11y agoIt really is a loss that Apple enthusiasts are so trapped in their bubble. Apple makes some fantastic gear, but there's a whole world exploring design choices. I recognize some of the compromises the author talks about trying to use a tablet as a computer from time spent with those devices, like the Samsung Q1 and numerous exotic devices that were more like prototypes than anything. It's not clear Apple will care to consider developers on the iPad platform, or professional users of any requirement, since Apple seems to like to sell users a device for every purpose. I just spent time with an Asus Chromebook Flip, which has an excellent keyboard and trackpad and converts into a tablet or the useful tent mode, has a quality aluminium body and IPS display, and weighs less than 2lbs. Give that $300 device a faster CPU, backlit keys, replace the bezel with a full size 4:3 12" screen and it's pretty much the perfect no-compromises browser-centric device that'd still be less than half the price of the iPad Pro with keyboard. And ChromeOS acknowledges enough of its Linux base that the user will get respect when they want to go below the covers.
- ghaff 11y agoI really like my Asus Chromebook Flip, but I suspect that by the time you're done enhancing the design you're getting into the laptop/high-end tablet price range. And I don't understand the market for the Pixel. I do think there's going to be a re-convergence between tablets and laptops even given the track record of convertibles but it's going to require a lot of thought and engineering and testing around specific use cases. (And I also understand why Apple might not be incented to drive things too hard in this direction.)
- davidy123 11y agoI've wondered about the price too, but I think with $200 they could upgrade to a 12" IPS display and something like a Core M chip. Maybe the more square display would be too exotic, 16:9 is weird in tablet mode but could be acceptable for the price. I'd expect USB 3.1 charging in that timeframe too. Backlit keys are a $20 option for Thinkpads so they should be achievable too. What's there is already so nice and the form factor works so well I'd be really surprised (and disappointed) if we don't see this in 2016, and it should be something of an inflection in the market to contrast with Apple's unrelentingly expensive offerings. The Pixel is clearly for Chromebook developers, or those with money to burn.
- archagon 11y agoThe iPad Pro mainly interests me for the stylus. I can't wait to read some reviews by actual artists who've been using Wacom hardware for years. If the Pencil is as precise and lag-free as early reviews indicate and it comes to the Mini, it will be my first must-buy iPad in many years. "The entire x86 computer architecture is living on borrowed time. It’s a dead platform walking." This kind of talk makes me sad, though. It almost seems like Apple bloggers get excited at the prospect of an ARM future. All I see, though, is a future where the walled garden has won out over open computing, and also a future where several decades of x86 video game history have been dumped in the trash. Not in any way acceptable to me.
- intended 11y agoReviews are out, but in general, if your work flow involves photoshop, you'd be on the wacom/surface lines.
- jbandela1 11y agoI think this is an Apple me too moment that does not have the right stuff to succeed. Apple decided they needed a tablet that was geared for production versus consumption. Unfortunately, the OS X is not optimized for touch interaction, so they are forced to go with iOS and ARM. Microsoft on the other hand went through the pain with Windows 8 of actually making their main OS touch friendly. They are now on their 4th generation of tablets that actually run a real desktop OS on Intel x86 processors. I think for the professional person that is wanting to work on a tablet, Microsoft Surface Pro is going to be a much better choice. You will have a real desktop operating system on x86 that actually runs the productivity/design/development software that is actually out there. It will be interesting to see how this develops.
- nilkn 11y agoEven with Windows 10 and the latest Surface Pro 4, I don't think they're very usable as actual tablets. Virtually every time I see a Surface Pro, either in real life or even advertisements, it's being used as a laptop with the kickstand and keyboard attachment. You almost never see anybody use it as a tablet. This happens so much that it's actually hard to find a review of the SP4 that even shows what it's like to use as a tablet. So while Windows 10 supports touch interaction, it's honestly not that great at it, and so far as I can tell nobody really uses it outside of content consumption. But by taking this approach, Microsoft skipped the massive step of needing to get new versions of all major software developed for a truly touch-centric interface. The SP4 is also not nearly as good as a family device. It's much harder to use and is far more susceptible to user error. Apple seems to be taking the opposite approach. They're taking a hit early on by building up everything from scratch for a touch interface, but their bet is that over the long-term the end result will be better. I don't know which approach will pan out, of course. I suspect to begin with the iPad Pro will simply serve a more affluent segment of exactly the same demographic that the iPad has always served, but over time it might expand to more professional users as its software develops and begins to rival desktop software.
- Someone1234 11y agoHow often do you see people use a Surface in general? I see people using them as OneNote scratch pads regularly: in business meetings, at conferences, and for diagramming. > So while Windows 10 supports touch interaction, it's honestly not that great at it, and so far as I can tell nobody really uses it outside of content consumption. That's fine, that is what tablet mode is often for. You have the kickstand/keyboard/touchpad for actual productivity. You have the tablet for consumption, and you have the tablet + pen for productivity when the activity allows it (e.g. drawing, hand-written notes, etc). I haven't used a Surface Pro 4, but the Surface Pro 3 had issues: It was too heavy, and the touchpad on the keyboard cover was frankly terrible (and per this article nobody wants to sit there with their outstretched arm touching the screen). We'll see if the SP4 solves any of the above. > The SP4 is also not nearly as good as a family device. It's much harder to use and is far more susceptible to user error. Absolutely. Which is why it was never targeted at that demographic. It is a professional device, just like the iPad Pro.
- pedalpete 11y agoThis is starting to feel like Apple and Microsoft are really starting to switch places like some bizarro world. Admittedly, this is Daring Fireball and not Apple itself, but wasn't Apple supposed to always talk about what their products do, why it's important, and not what the specs are? Here, a huge portion of the write-up of the iPad Pro is the performance of the hardware. Was anybody really complaining that their iPad wasn't fast enough? Was that holding back developers? (honest question, maybe it was, I'm not sure). Then there is this statment "Anyone tying themselves in knots looking for a specific target audience for the iPad Pro is going about it the wrong way. There is no single target audience. Is the iPad Pro meant for office workers in the enterprise? Professional artists creating content? Casual users playing games, watching movies, and reading? The answer is simply “Yes”." Isn't this often the kiss of death? Not recognizing a single target audience for your product? The original iPad had a target, all be it a hugely diverse one. It was for people who wanted to consume content on a larger screen device than their phone, but wanted something simpler than a laptop.
- prodmerc 11y agoThe iPad Pro is an overpriced tablet for all the people who bought overpriced MacBook Pros. I think Apple still knows their target audience :-)
- Silhouette 11y agoWas anybody really complaining that their iPad wasn't fast enough? Was that holding back developers? When combined with Apple's effectively forced upgrade policy with iOS, yes, many people have complained that their iPad is no longer fast enough, even if it was just fine before the OS update. App developers are forced to collaborate in that exercise by Apple deciding which versions of iOS (and visual styles etc.) apps must support to go into the App Store. Probably the most serious example so far was people with 2nd or 3rd generation iPads, who were effectively forced to update to at least iOS 7 because of app compatibility issues. Significant numbers of users appear to have experienced serious performance problems afterwards (just google any plausible complaint wording) and to have reported varying degrees of success in ever resolving them.
- 11y ago
- vaishaksuresh 11y agoOver time, I've begun to take daringfireball reviews with a grain of salt. Despite having bought into the apple ecosphere, I don't think iPad Pro or any other product deserves as much appreciation as daringfireball reviews give. Sure they are great pieces of technology, but the difference is not like it was between a dumbphone and an iPhone. The reviews are much more fanboy like than objective.
- netnichols 11y agoDid you read it? A large section of the review was complaining about bugs and software shortcomings. That's not being a very good "fanboy".
- vaishaksuresh 11y agoI was talking about the general articles/reviews from daringfireball. Not this one is particular. I don't understand the need to give a build up that starts from the dawn of civilization to talk about a tablet or a laptop.
- jgruber 11y agoWhich reviews of mine do you think this applies to?
- walterbell 11y agoHow can Apple source laptop-sized 4:3 screens for the iPad Pro, when every laptop vendor has abandoned this high-productivity aspect ratio that offers more vertical real estate for text?
- wmf 11y agoBecause Apple is ordering ~25M units of that display panel but PC vendors are not. Or because Apple gives customers what they need but PC vendors give customers what they want.
- walterbell 11y agoLaptop customers have begged for 4:3 screens, but were told that display vendors had all switched to 16:9 because of movies. Yet Apple managed to find/mandate production of 4:3 high-res screens.
- jgruber 11y agoApple doesn't buy commodity components for things like iPad displays. They're all custom-designed, custom-built.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThat was an interesting read. So in full disclosure I've been an iPad user since they came out (the company bought everyone an iPad in 2010 when we launched the search engine, and I upgraded it to the Retina one when that came out) I was waiting until I could order and iPad Pro, then saw the video demo of the Surface Book and ordered the core i7 one right away. It is entirely possible the Microsoft took money off Apple's plate in my case (we'll know for sure when I can actually get my hands on an iPad pro to play with). My Surface Book arrived last week and I've been playing with it ever since. To understand that my use case is replacing books and notebooks. I want to have a library of books where ever I go, and the ability to sketch as well. In 1997 I saw a prototype 200 dpi OLED display at IBM's Almaden Research lab, I ended up buying an Illiad 2 from iREX which was about 157 dpi and a watcom stylus circuit for about $800. The plan being all docs and notes on docs and sketches. Between then and now I've going through several iterations each adding a bit here or there, cursed the Plastic Logic folks for killing themselves by reaching too far, and finally found the 10" iPad (retina) to have the screen, and battery life characteristics I could live with but drawing really sucked. When I saw the iPad Pro announcement I felt it was the closet thing yet to the ideal paper notebook and infinite library replacement with a couple of shortcomings (limited local storage, possibly limited drawing experience) and then saw the Surface Book announcement which has a different set of short comings (primarily cellular connectivity). So while I vastly prefer IOS over Windows 10, I really need the ability to access my library on my local network, or through SD cards. The drawing experience on the Surface has been perfect, the display resolution also best of class. The application selection less than stellar, and the lack of cellular connectivity means I have to tether it to my phone when I'm out and about. So had iPad Pro come out last February I would already own one. Now I'm not so sure. The Surface is wicked fast, and yes 50% more expensive than an equivalently equipped iPad Pro. From a fundamental engineering capability standpoint I think it holds its own, from an apps standpoint I'm still evaluating various drawing apps (wish I could find one that created the ruler tool when you put down two fingers) I really love the idea of having two compelling solutions available!
- jacobolus 11y ago> The drawing experience on the Surface has been perfect, the display resolution also best of class. How’s the latency, precision, pressure sensitivity, palm rejection (especially latency)? Have you compared the generations of the Surface w/ Wacom vs. N-Trig tech? Have you tried a recent Cintiq? If so, any thoughts? I’d really love to see some reviews from artists comparing Cintiq vs. Surface Pro 2 vs. Surface Pro 3 vs. iPad Pro for stylus use.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoHmm, no one seems to be talking about the use case I'm interested in with the pro, namely watching Netflix/iTunes/VLC, which is currently ~90% of my iPad use. I use an ancient iPad 2 on a stand for this now, I'd like the pro for the bigger, better screen, and speakers. Don't care about the rest, which has been overkill for several generations. Wish there were a cheaper model. ;)
- pedalpete 11y agoCan somebody explain the 'single-core' description in the tests? Doesn't the number of cores need to be taken into account when considering the actual performance? This may be wrong, but the way I'm looking at it is like comparing the power of a 4 cylinder car vs an 8 cylinder but measuring the power that comes only out of one cylinder as your comparison measurement. It is possible that a single cylinder from a 4-banger creates more power than a single cylinder from an 8, but in the real world, that won't matter. I'm guessing I'm wrong, but why?
- jacobolus 11y agoTypically both single-core and multiple-core benchmarks are reported. Because some workloads can be effectively multithreaded while others cannot, single-core performance is often as useful a metric as multi-core performance.
- RexRollman 11y ago"It brings me no joy to observe this, but the future of mass market portable computing involves neither a mouse pointer nor an x86 processor." Or freedom.