2 ms·
Read the informed comments on Derek Lowe's blog about Theranos [1]. This is the money shot quote from johnnyboy "@Pete: it is entirely justified to have doubts
by danieltillett 11y ago
Read the informed comments on Derek Lowe's blog about Theranos [1]. This is the money shot quote from johnnyboy
"@Pete: it is entirely justified to have doubts about the validity of blood results obtained from finger pricks. The blood you get from a prick will be a mixture of blood from small venules, small arterioles, capillaries and lymph vessels, mixed with whatever loose tissue and cells have been cut by the prick and carried over into the blood. No way you could ever get a reliable CBC from such a sample. Since the kind of general blood tests that this company is targeting are usually CBC + chem panel, even if you could get your chem results from the prick, you still need a normal blood draw for the CBC, so the competitive advantage that they are trying to push (quick sampling by patient at pharmacy, without need for phlebotomist) is lost. On top of that, the variability inherent in chem results from prick blood will be significant for several analytes, like CK and AST (present in muscle so could be raised from prick injury), glucose and lipids (different levels in venous or arterial blood or lymph), etc… They are focusing on their fancy technology without much consideration of the underlying biology, typical error of engineering types.”
1. http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2015/10/15/theranos-and-its-blood-test-machine http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2015/10/15/the...
- refurb 11y agoNo doubt that a blood sample from a finger prick is different than from a vein. That said, diabetics just use finger pricks for their blood glucose tests. Is the result calibrated for a finger prick test or do we just assume it's close enough?
- danieltillett 11y agoYou don’t need the accuracy that you need for the other tests plus glucose is in really high concentrations relatively to the other compounds they want to measure. If you are out by 20% on the glucose concentration in diabetes it does not matter too much, but it does for everything else. It is not like the current machines are 100% accurate anyway even though the ISO threshold is +-20% [1]. 1. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3317395/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3317395/