3 ms·
Here's a better idea: Get rid of electronic voting entirely. It's an incredibly hard security problem that hasn't been solved. Making the software open-source
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
Here's a better idea:
Get rid of electronic voting entirely.
It's an incredibly hard security problem that hasn't been solved. Making the software open-source is putting lipstick on a pig.
(Somewhat reassuringly, a slim majority of the readers of the article agree with me: http://i.imgur.com/k5OZ7vB.png http://i.imgur.com/k5OZ7vB.png)
- philipn 11y agoPlease see my comment below. The author of the piece mis-captioned the photo. This is not an electronic voting proposal. It's simply making the existing multi-step process that San Francisco uses open-source. For instance, we currently use optical scanning machines here (as do most cities). With this proposal, those machines will run open-source software.
- lazaroclapp 11y agoIsn't optical scanning as hackable as if the votes were originally recorded electronically, though? Or are people performing random checks on the machine's count? (Honestly curious) Don't get me wrong, running open source software is a plus for many reasons, if one is using software at all. But any automation in elections seems to carry a hard to bound amount of risk.
- philipn 11y agoRandom manual recounts are done on a statistically significant portion of paper ballots. Additionally, paper ballots allow for manual recounts in contested contests (e.g. a legal challenge). E.g. see https://twitter.com/SFElections/status/534405668258594816 https://twitter.com/SFElections/status/534405668258594816 and https://twitter.com/SFElections/status/535541022915186688 https://twitter.com/SFElections/status/535541022915186688
- stonesixone 11y agoAnd here is a video of the random selection process for last week's election (the two tweets above are from last year): http://sfgov2.org/index.aspx?page=4938 http://sfgov2.org/index.aspx?page=4938 This took place this morning (Tuesday, November 10). I'm the lone member of the public who showed up and rolled the dice the first few times (5:15 into the upper video). :)
- ossreality 11y ago:) That's dorky, in the absolutely most awesome way. I don't know why I keep grinning at your post, it just seems really neat.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lazaroclapp 11y agoThis is, unfortunately, true. I say unfortunately because there are things we could do with software voting that are impossible with paper ballots (e.g. directly overriding our representatives on specific bills, liquid democracy, etc). But as the state of software security stands now (and it doesn't seem to be likely to get any better), the voting alternatives seem to be: (mostly) accurate, secret, electronic. Pick at most two.
- bduerst 11y agoThere was talk of using ATMs as voting booths and your bank account as a method of verification. Sure it's not perfectly secure and is biased to voters who have debit cards, but it seems to be a step in the right direction.
- ghubbard 11y ago"Open a GNB account today - No ATM fees when you vote Republican"
- Houshalter 11y agoElectronic voting is already widely in use. I've never voted on a paper ballot. And it makes some really cool voting systems possible. For example, you can do Condorcet voting systems, which are far superior to normal first past the post. Or cool systems like single transferable vote for electing groups of representatives. These systems are much harder to do manually and with paper ballots, but trivial to do electronically.
- stonesixone 11y agoSan Francisco uses both paper ballots and single transferable voting (in its single-winner, instant runoff voting form). Indeed, I believe all jurisdictions in the United States that use STV also use paper ballots. In San Francisco, voters vote on paper ballots, and the ballots are electronically scanned. This generates a digital representation of the rankings cast on all ballots, which can be fed into tabulation software. SF actually releases these rankings publicly as a text file for each contest. See here, for example: http://www.sfelections.org/results/20151103/#english_detail http://www.sfelections.org/results/20151103/#english_detail
- Houshalter 11y agoYes it's the vote tallying machine that needs to be electronic, not necessarily the ballot that the voter fills out. But even then, it's harder to do ranked paper ballots. Presumably someone has to transcribe the numbers voters wrote on the ballot into a computer, which introduces room for mistakes and lots of work.
- thwarted 11y agoNone of that requires manually transcribing numbers. Here's what the ranked paper ballot looks like that we use in SF. This is entirely scanable by machine. http://californiawatch.org/files/imagecache/image-full-width/Ranked-choice-voting-sample-ballot_0.jpg http://californiawatch.org/files/imagecache/image-full-width... Notice that it says (hard to read in this image) in the second and third choice that the selection must be different from the other choices.