4 ms·
I'm curious why you put strong analytical skills in quotes. It reads like you are using a definition outside the standard one (the typical use of scare quotes).
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I'm curious why you put strong analytical skills in quotes. It reads like you are using a definition outside the standard one (the typical use of scare quotes). But putting that aside for a moment.
Analytical skills are simply the ability to develop new information and insights from a mix of information that is present and identifying and acquiring information that is necessary and not present.
You say "Mary went to the movies, how much did she pay?" Analyst questions is "Is there any thing special about Mary?" Interview question is "What characteristics of Mary do you consider special?"
Now if the interviewee can come back with the typical spread of movie prices (child, adult, student, senior) that is the minimum response. They get more credit if they also include matinee vs prime-time shows, they get still more credit if they test the assumption that Mary was going to a theatre that required payment, and full marks if they want to be sure that Mary does not own, or work at the theatre where the movie is being shown.
Analytical skills are, in my mind, being able to identify all of the variables that might bear on the solution of the problem, ranking them in order of how likely they are to come into play, and constructing alternatives based on the most likely combinations of variables. And doing that quickly and methodically without losing track of the variable expansions in the process.
The reason I prize those skills in an employee is that it gives them the capability to solve poorly specified problem tasks. Flipping my question around, as a manager I would much prefer to tell my employee "Give Mary money for the movie tonight." and be assured that they will expand the variable list, talk to Mary if necessary to fill in missing gaps, and then disburse the funds. But if they either freeze up unable to break down the variables into an action plan, or if they simply provide the "typical" money needed without figuring out if that will be too much or too little, then I know that managing them will take too much of my time. HTH
- mswen 11y agoI loved this response until the end. When the absolute cost is actually really low relative to the cost of the analyst's time then skip the expansive analysis, use a reasonable heuristic and be done. I get frustrated with analysts who are so caught up in their analytic prowess and technique that they lose sight of the business context and basic ROI. Despite my objection at the end, I really did like this example as a way to explore a person's ability to ask good questions.