2 ms·
Copyright protection does more than generate profit. For example copyright provides the teeth for the GPL, and the various CC license requirements. In general,
by snowwrestler 11y ago
Copyright protection does more than generate profit. For example copyright provides the teeth for the GPL, and the various CC license requirements.
In general, I think the concept of tying copyright explicitly to profit and fees could produce a pretty strong chilling effect on hobby projects and other free culture.
I'd prefer to see some sort of safe harbor defined for people to archive orphaned works, or otherwise keep track of them. Active copyright holders could opt out of the safe harbor on a regular basis via some centralized process akin to registration. If their opt-out lapses, the safe harbor returns.
The difference is that the safe harbor would be narrowly defined to permit archiving, but not free distribution or reuse. That way a community can keep track of things, but there is no radical shift in the protections that rest on copyright.