3 ms·
What about a closed-source tool whose source and compiled binary had been vetted by mutually-distrusting, qualified parties who themselves used the tool? And pr
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
What about a closed-source tool whose source and compiled binary had been vetted by mutually-distrusting, qualified parties who themselves used the tool? And provided the binaries and signatures to tools' customers?
Because as I outline here...
https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/05/friday_squid_bl_424.html#c6051639 https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/05/friday_squid_...
...both proprietary and FOSS really come down to you taking other people's word that they reviewed it and they were qualified to do so. So, review and trust in the reviewer(s) are the truly important points. The many eyes argument hasn't held for security for over a decade while a number of closed-source systems survived rigorous evaluation due to good design.
So, would you trusted a rigorously built and evaluated system with closed source if you trusted the reviewers and could verify you had same thing? And, if not, why do you trust/use OSS that's made by people with varying competence with no proof of qualified review?