3 ms·

I've had this message several times, but "What the heck are you talking about" doesn't break any rule whatsoever that I can find. In fact I fail to see how it c

I've had this message several times, but "What the heck are you talking about" doesn't break any rule whatsoever that I can find. In fact I fail to see how it could be toned down anymore. Are we not permitted to express confusion? Is 'heck' not the lightened American friendly version of 'hell'? How much more would you like me to blunt what I say in order that it doesn't violate unclear rules?

dang 11y ago
What you posted was uncivil. "What are you talking about" adds no information and is a variant of name-calling. Asking whether someone is "trolling or ignorant" is also name-calling, just with a branch in it. And "name X or retract your claim" is a form of intellectual bullying, so also uncivil. Any substantive point you have will become sharper once you edit such rudeness out, so it isn't a question of "blunting", but of being respectful. Even if you don't respect the person you're talking to, you need to respect the community by holding yourself to a higher standard.