4 ms·
How is this a win for Snowden? They can deem the entire program illegal, disband the NSA and put everyone in charge in prison for violating US law and it still
by dogma1138 11y ago
How is this a win for Snowden? They can deem the entire program illegal, disband the NSA and put everyone in charge in prison for violating US law and it still won't help Snowden get back into the US without cuffs.
Unless it's an executive pardon or a statement from the attorney general exempting Snowden from prosecution this isn't a win for Snowden.
In any case there might be an interesting development as it might turn into a catch 22 for the NSA if they'll claim that it's technically unfeasible for them to filter out their collection based solely on specific individuals/organizations (which is probably technically correct) it can open a whole new can worms for them (since they've claimed that the collection is targeted and ensures that certain parameters are met (other than it's a phone call, email, skype call or 1 or more person(s) talking in range of a microphone they can jack into)). If they'll find a way to comply well they might be flooded by similar law suits, and even FOIA requests from individuals and organizations about if and when any data about them was collected.
On the other side of the coin this might come to bite us in the arse if the NSA makes a case that to comply with this ruling they'll have to perform in-depth analysis of every communication they collect to ensure that no phone call data is being collected which might involve J.J. Little, especially if VOIP communications fall under this jurisdiction and ofc they can later claim that any intelligence gathered from that analysis is lawful and actionable/admissible because it was gathered in the course of achieving compliance with a court order.
Dear Citizens,
In order to comply with Civil Action No. 13-851 Klayman et al. v Obama et al. we now need to transcribe all domestic and international calls conducted from and to the continental united states, the pacific states as well as any incorporated and unincorporated territories and any commercial fleet vessels sailing under the US flag in order to ensure that the call does not contain any information, data or reference to J.J. Little & Associates, P.C. or it's clients.
Sincerely the NSA.
- jonknee 11y ago> How is this a win for Snowden? They can deem the entire program illegal, disband the NSA and put everyone in charge in prison for violating US law and it still won't help Snowden get back into the US without cuffs. It's good for Snowden because it means he really was a whistle blower. Things can still be good for him even though he's not back at home.
- tptacek 11y agoAre there serious opponents of Snowden that deny that he was in some real sense a whistleblower? The problem Snowden's critics have is that he wasn't just a whistleblower.
- jonknee 11y agoTons of folks. Here are a couple: Hillary Clinton http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/oct/14/hillary-clinton/clinton-says-nsa-leaker-snowden-failed-use-whistle/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/oct/... > "He broke the laws of the United States," Clinton said. "He could have been a whistleblower. He could have gotten all of the protections of being a whistleblower. He could have raised all the issues that he has raised. And I think there would have been a positive response to that." Bill Nelson http://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/man-traitor-article-1.1369682 http://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/man-traitor-article-1.136... > "Edward Snowden is not a whistleblower. What Edward Snowden did amounts to an act of treason."
- tptacek 11y agoGrandstanding politicians are not serious critics. I tried to choose the words "serious opponents" to exclude morons.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 11y agoI don't know, but we are now arguing over the semantics of something I wrote earlier, which seems like a pretty boring argument. My point is probably better expressed as "many of Snowden's critics don't dispute that he's a whistleblower, but have a problem with what else he is".
- jonknee 11y ago
- rakoo 11y ago> How is this a win for Snowden? They can deem the entire program illegal, disband the NSA and put everyone in charge in prison for violating US law and it still won't help Snowden get back into the US without cuffs. It's a win for Snowden because the game is not and has never been whether Snowden is innocent or safe, but whether Snowden was right that bulk collection of phone records is unlawful. Until a judge said what it was, it was still disputed, now if a judge actually declares this program unlawful nobody can say he was wrong, and we can formally advance the state we're in.